7 ms·
The consistent push toward the "sharing economy" and or the "gig economy" makes me very uneasy, especially when it comes to physical things like houses, cars, o
by keiferski 6y ago
The consistent push toward the "sharing economy" and or the "gig economy" makes me very uneasy, especially when it comes to physical things like houses, cars, or food. The end result will be that regular people don't own anything and don't know how to do things, whether that's repair your vehicle or cook a meal at home. When push comes to shove, the corporation actually owning such things can cut you off with virtually no consequences.
- pintxo 6y agoAnyone wondering how this might look like may like reading "Radicalized" by Cory Doctorow
- TeMPOraL 6y agoI feel bad about it too. I'll just quote what I wrote the other day[0] on the topic of "throwing money at things" instead of doing or owning things yourself: "Why would you own things and accept responsibility for maintaining them, if you could just throw money at the service provider and have the thing be present when it's needed? Of course the thing will be extremely limited in what you can do with it, subject to Terms&Conditions, but why would you want to do anything non-standard with stuff? There's always another service you can throw money at to solve the same problem. What's the end-game here? That we specialize into sub-species of humans, forever stuck in one role, with zero autonomy? No longer building wealth, we'll only be allocating the flow of money - from what Society gives us in reward for our work, straight to Services of said Society? Will we become specialized cells of the meta-multicellular organism Society becomes? I can see how we're on the path towards that reality, and I absolutely hate it." -- [0] - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24787804 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24787804
- bserge 6y agoI see the same thing and it's disheartening. At least we're not immortal, now that would be hell in such a system. And the main problem is (imho) that people just seem to hate responsibility. It all stems from that, at the core it's all just shifting responsibility onto something or someone who will take it.
- Latty 6y agoThe rent-seeking economy, just create more renters to increase the amount you can skim off the top.
- gpderetta 6y ago> houses have a look at leaseholds in UK.
- martin-adams 6y agoand the unregulated estate charges now where they can seize your house if you fail to pay.
- gpderetta 6y agoI'm currently in the process of buying an house which is subject of estate charges, and I'm very worried about those.
- martin-adams 6y agoI got a new build last year and it's not really an issue, just something to be aware of. The only thing I worry about is the escalating prices in a few years, but you have the benefit of the whole estate being in the same situation, so you can club together to complain I guess.
- iso947 6y agoWhich apply to freeholds too - leaseholders actually have more rights!
- martin-adams 6y agoThis does concern me. For example, if I buy kindle books instead of physical books, my kids can't enjoy those books when I'm gone. I have a car that can now do software unlocking of physical features (e.g. rear heated seats). Am I adding value to the car which I can sell to the next person, or am I licensing the right to that feature for the duration for my own use. We're moving to a model where we spend the same, but their value is zero when considering the value of our assets.
- wycy 6y ago> I have a car that can now do software unlocking of physical features (e.g. rear heated seats) Was this a permanent unlock, or do you need a subscription to unlock the rear heated seats?
- bonkabonka 6y agoWell and is the permanent unlock transferable? There was that fellow who bought a Tesla from a used-car dealer and had a bunch of paperwork stating certain things were unlocked that when he bought them got disabled because he wasn't licensed for them.
- martin-adams 6y agoYeah, it's pretty much this. Apparently Tesla locks the features when the car is sold to them. The guy in question had a broken paper trail but apparently it was sorted. What is worrying is that these aren't clearly explained when you make the purchase. And it's really down to the company's policy, which if all companies do the same, the consumer ends up having no choice.
- judge2020 6y agoSupposedly the story is: Tesla bought a car back then sold it to an auction house and enabled FSD as a "demo". The auction house mistakenly listed the features as being enabled, and when the car sold Tesla never disabled the FSD demo. When the user then privately sold the car to a new owner, the new owner performed an ownership transfer - when they did this, either a human or some automated system saw that the FSD demo was enabled and disabled it. 0: https://www.businessinsider.com/tesla-disables-autopilot-on-model-s-without-alerting-owner-2020-2 https://www.businessinsider.com/tesla-disables-autopilot-on-...
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- k__ 6y agoThe sharing and gig economy aren't the problem. The companies are.
- mmcconnell1618 6y agoTry not paying your real estate taxes and you'll discover that you're only renting the land under your house. The local authorities have the ability to confiscate and sell your dwelling if you don't pay your taxes.
- falcolas 6y agoThere's a slight difference between paying government taxes for the land you've purchased and renting a book from a private corporation. The government taxes pay for services which can directly and indirectly benefit you. For example, they pay for providing a force which will help against unlawful intruders, pay for the manpower who will help you should your house catch on fire, pay for the maintenance of roads, and so forth. Amazon's revenue... lines the pockets of Amazon's investors.
- oaiey 6y agoI want to add one thing here: Owning is sometimes also a burden. There is a whole sub culture focusing on downsizing (there are fans which are owning less than 100 items .. and that includes battery cable). But I agree also with your statement.
- Finnucane 6y agoYes, but normally you have some degree of choice. You can choose to rent or buy depending on your circumstances and needs. It's bad enough enough that the degree of 'choice' is very limited for a lot of people, but it is clear that the political direction of tax law, corporate law, is toward the direction of establishment of a permanent aristocracy that owns everything and everyone else is completely dependent on them.
- bmitc 6y agoI don't think it's just that. I think it's the corporations having engaged in decades long propaganda pushing towards unlimited capitalism. It's a new brand of authoritarianism. Corporations make all the rules and have all the power. If we as a consumer make a single mistake, we are to pay for it, yet consumers have essentially zero power towards a corporation. Corporations are given nearly endless rights on what they can do and own, and consumers are quickly having ownership rights yanked out from us. Corporations own our data, many of the products we "buy", and even what we can do with the things we "buy".