3 ms·
The big difference is that the CD for a video-game is just a transport medium to allow you to copy its contents on your computer. Sure you own the CD and can a
by mytailorisrich 6y ago
The big difference is that the CD for a video-game is just a transport medium to allow you to copy its contents on your computer.
Sure you own the CD and can actually lend it but the person you lent it to has no right to effectively use that CD since only you were granted the right (license) to copy it on a limited number (which can be 1) of your own computers.
Same if you buy a copy of MS Word. You do own the CD but you only get the license to install it on a couple of computers.
Any term that purports to prevent you from lending your property has no value. The key point is that the license prevents others from installing the software/video game.
- tsimionescu 6y agoYou are more or less right, even in the EU. I think the only part where you are clearly wrong is here: > Sure you own the CD and can actually lend it but the person you lent it to has no right to effectively use that CD since only you were granted the right (license) to copy it on a limited number (which can be 1) of your own computers. The second-hand gaming market is obvious proof that you are it is indeed legal for multiple people to copy the game to their own computers from the same CD. The only limitation is the same one that applies to books: copying a book that you own for personal purposes falls under fair use, but selling/lending the book without also passing on / destroying the copy invalidates the fair use exception.
- mytailorisrich 6y agoI commented about lending, which is not the same as selling on and what you describe, so I don't really understand how my comment is wrong.
- tsimionescu 6y agoThe same rule would apply for lending: as long as, at the time of lending, you do not retain any copy of the work; and, at the time of returning the work, the borrower also does not retain any copy, there is no copyright infringement. This can also be seen from the existence of game rental services, and there are even libraries that lend video games.