2 ms·
China has the jurisdiction over the Chinese resident, their ISP and other local infrastructure. It doesn't have jurisdiction over foreign companies and foreign
by viraptor 6y ago
China has the jurisdiction over the Chinese resident, their ISP and other local infrastructure. It doesn't have jurisdiction over foreign companies and foreign companies don't have to comply with anything. (Unless they want to do business with Chinese residents or operate in China) Same applies to the EU situation.
You may want to be nice to the foreign visitors otherwise and comply with the foreign laws, but that's it.
- darekkay 6y ago> Unless they (...) operate in China Exactly. If you're operating in the EU, you are bound by the EU laws. But "operating" doesn't mean you have to sell something: > The GDPR applies to US businesses, regardless of their size in terms of revenue or staff, if at least one of the following two conditions are met: > 1. The company offers good or services (even in the absence of commercial transactions) to EU/EEA residents. > 2. The company monitors the behavior of users inside the EU/EEA. So yes, if the news website in this thread tracks me without my consent, they are violating my rights and the EU laws. I am not sure how realistic enforcing this law actually is, though, unless they have a EU branch (what you described as jurisdiction). Source: https://termly.io/resources/articles/gdpr-in-the-us/ https://termly.io/resources/articles/gdpr-in-the-us/
- viraptor 6y agoThe website you linked brings up 2 out of 4 examples where the EU data is collected, the business is not aimed at the EU residents, and says (verbatim) "GDPR does not apply". Same reasons seem to apply to the context discussed here (news site aimed at the US region). Specifically: > Although such a website would likely track the user behavior of EU/EEA citizens, as the website would attract native speakers of several European languages, the GDPR does not apply here because: > the service does not target EU/EEA residents, and > the tracked user behavior is not occurring within the EU/EEA.
- darekkay 6y agoNice catch - I didn't expect the examples to somehow contradict the general statement from the same section. TIL.