4 ms·
This is a great example of how codifying good behavior into an all-encompassing Code of Conduct has a lot of unintended consequences. The organization's Code o
by PragmaticPulp 6y ago
This is a great example of how codifying good behavior into an all-encompassing Code of Conduct has a lot of unintended consequences.
The organization's Code of Conduct was so broad-reaching, thorough, and explicit that it doesn't appear to have left any leeway for common sense. Why did they simply follow the explicit procedures of the CoC rather than stopping to question if what they were doing was the right thing to do?
I suspect they were afraid to deviate from their own Code of Conduct, for fear that the 2 complainants would use social media to criticize the event operators. No event organizers want to be publicly accused of ignoring their own Code of Conduct or denying that a CoC complaint was valid. Getting on the wrong side of this issue could be a death sentence for the organizers.
So instead, they used the Code of Conduct machinery to turn the complaints into a vague punishment for the speaker. In doing so, they washed their hands of responsibility and shielded themselves from criticism. It doesn't make any sense, but they upheld their end of the CoC and therefore are "safe" from being cancelled.
- btilly 6y agoThe organization's Code of Conduct was so broad-reaching, thorough, and explicit that it doesn't appear to have left any leeway for common sense. Did we read the same article? The article says that he was pointed at two contradictory codes of conduct, and violated for violating unstated standards from an implicit code of conduct that wasn't revealed to him. That's making shit up to be able to say you did something. It is exactly the opposite of rigidly following a code of conduct. And, as the article points out, they managed to fail to follow their own official code of conduct in the process.
- toast0 6y ago> Why did they simply follow the explicit procedures of the CoC rather than stopping to question if what they were doing was the right thing to do? > I suspect they were afraid to deviate from their own Code of Conduct, for fear that the 2 complainants would use social media to criticize the event operators. As described, they didn't follow the procedures as written, nor did they follow through on the procedure as suggested in their early communications. They didn't seem to have a problem with deviating from their code of conduct.
- josephcsible 6y ago> explicit that it doesn't appear to have left any leeway for common sense. Why did they simply follow the explicit procedures of the CoC rather than stopping to question if what they were doing was the right thing to do? It's good that they blindly applied their CoC in a case where it's clear-cut that it's bad, since it revealed the problems with the CoC. If they chose not to enforce it in this instance, then when a more political issue inevitably came up down the road, a similar bad result may have happened but without the backlash necessary to fix it.