4 ms·
That is a common misunderstanding of canonical Catholic teaching about "indulgentia a culpa et a poena". Keeping the carbon offset analogy, an indulgence in t
by mensetmanusman 6y ago
That is a common misunderstanding of canonical Catholic teaching about "indulgentia a culpa et a poena".
Keeping the carbon offset analogy, an indulgence in the Catholic sense would be more akin to first making sure you are carbon neutral (all parties are at peace and forgiven/reconciled), then you spend %10 of your salary to go beyond that and offset the carbon credits of the person you wronged.
- friendlybus 6y agoUntil Teztel started selling carbon offsets for dead polluters. An offered coin springs a dead soul from purgatory.
- mensetmanusman 6y agoSounds like a new ICO opportunity :) Would be interesting if there were a climate change coin... oh wait, https://earth-token.com/ https://earth-token.com/
- schoen 6y agoThe obvious response is that every PoW coin is a climate change coin. :-(
- el_nahual 6y agoAn even bigger misconception is that indulgences were actually bought on behalf of _someone else_. They were meant to address a very real problem with catholic heaven/hell theology: What if I belong in heaven, but somene I love, who I can't possibly imagine spending eternity without, belongs in hell? Indulgences were originally meant to address this: the party that belonged in heaven could, through their sacrifice, guarantee a spot in heaven for their loved one. It was only later that the "sacrifice" become strictly monetary.
- eru 6y agoAs far as I know, indulgences never got you out of hell. They were to shorten your time in purgatory.
- mjh2539 6y agoIndulgences for the damned were inefficacious and applied to the Church suffering in purgatory.
- Thorrez 6y ago>An even bigger misconception is that indulgences were actually bought on behalf of _someone else_. Are you saying it's true that indulgences can be obtained for others or that it's false that indulgences can be obtained for others? In reality indulgences can be obtained for yourself, or for others, including those in Purgatory. They can't be obtained for people in Hell. >It was only later that the "sacrifice" become strictly monetary. Indulgences are not strictly monetary. The vast majority involve no money at all. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Indulgence#Plenary_indulgences https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Indulgence#Plenary_indulgences
- joubert 6y agoInstead of sticking with the carbon credits analogy I'll articulate more directly what I understand from reading up on indulgences at https://www.newadvent.org/cathen/07783a.htm https://www.newadvent.org/cathen/07783a.htm For a sin that has already been forgiven, an indulgence is associated payment you owe that if you didn't pay, you will spend more time in purgatory. If this is an accurate reading, does it not dilute the meaning of "forgiven"? Does it not amount to a money-making racket at best, or, more probably, extortion?
- klodolph 6y agoYou have some good points, maybe you should write them up and post them up where church-goers would see them, like a church door or something.
- Thorrez 6y ago>Does it not amount to a money-making racket at best, or, more probably, extortion? The vast vast vast majority of indulgences have no money aspect at all. See the list of plenary (meaning all temporal punishment is removed) indulgences on Wikipedia[1], none of them involve money. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Indulgence#Plenary_indulgences https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Indulgence#Plenary_indulgences
- mensetmanusman 6y agoFrom your link: “ Least of all is an indulgence the purchase of a pardon which secures the buyer's salvation or releases the soul of another from Purgatory. “ One might associate it with helping move an individual from a smaller circle to a larger circle of ethics: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Expanding_Circle https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Expanding_Circle “ Singer discusses the relationship between biological capacity for altruism and morality. He argues that altruism, when directed to one's small circle of family, tribe or even nation, is not moral, but it becomes so when applied to wider circles. “ E.g. charity where you sacrifice your individual goods for the larger community is good for the soul.
- tripzilch 6y agoSo common in fact, like language, it becomes a prescriptivism / descriptivism thing ...