3 ms·
Would the idea be that platforms cannot moderate at all? They must allow all legal content? So spam and porn would have to be allowed?
by amanaplanacanal 6y ago
Would the idea be that platforms cannot moderate at all? They must allow all legal content? So spam and porn would have to be allowed?
- juniper_strong 6y agoHistorically the term platform has meant just that, they have a legal requirement to allow all content. Think something like a phone network. There are rules about what constitutes spam on a phone network - laws limiting robocalls in some situations for example - but it isn't the phone company making those rules.
- r00fus 6y agoplatform != common carrier
- juniper_strong 6y agoHere's an article by Eugene Volokh on the difference between publishers, distributors and platforms: https://reason.com/2020/05/28/47-u-s-c-%C2%A7-230-and-the-publisher-distributor-platform-distinction/ https://reason.com/2020/05/28/47-u-s-c-%C2%A7-230-and-the-pu.... "Historically, American law has divided operators of communications systems into three categories", he says, and he describes the third category as: "Platforms, such as telephone companies, cities on whose sidewalks people might demonstrate, or broadcasters running candidate ads that they are required to carry." His description of the liability rules for platforms: "Platforms weren't liable at all. For instance, even if a phone company learned that an answering machine had a libelous outgoing message (see Anderson v. N.Y. Telephone Co. (N.Y. 1974)), and did nothing to cancel the owner's phone service, it couldn't be sued for libel. Likewise, a city couldn't be liable for defamatory material on signs that someone carried on city sidewalks (even though a bar could be liable once it learned of libelous material on its walls), and a broadcaster couldn't be liable for defamatory material in a candidate ad." If you see a difference between that and "common carrier" that is relevant to whether an entity considered a traditional platform would have to carry spam or porn, what is it?