7 ms·
Scarey note that Biden has said he may support repeal. As every CEO noted, censorship would have to (radically) increase if platforms were no longer had protect
by rektide 6y ago
Scarey note that Biden has said he may support repeal. As every CEO noted, censorship would have to (radically) increase if platforms were no longer had protection from the speech they happen to host.
So weird how Cruz &c keep making this sound like there's some mandate that these platforms be nuetral. Definitely in large part to score sympathy, but what if he & his sect realize (how can they not?) & do want to errode the Safe Harbor provisions, make it unsafe to host content online? Or are they confident this is only a PR stunt, & that it will go nowhere?
- perryizgr8 6y agoI'd prefer full censorship instead of the partisan sham that Twitter is doing now.
- rektide 6y agowhy don't you go someplace else then? no one is forcing anyone on to Twitter, it had no more sway or status than the Babylon Bee or any other media. if people vote with their feet to hang out someplace, it should not face increasing nuetrality regulations, imo. to answer Cruzcs question, every active Twitter user voted for Twitter, & our choice not to go use an alternative is an ongoing continual voting that could change any day. I also don't agree, don't think Twitter is acting at all biased. I think they have very basic rules & have been very kind about trying to enforce them.
- perryizgr8 6y ago> no one is forcing anyone on to Twitter, it had no more sway or status than the Babylon Bee or any other media. That is probably the most untrue statement I've heard this week. Twitter the de facto standard way by which famous people and journalists speak out to their audience. As a general user, I have no alternative for the kind of news that is on Twitter. As a journalist/celebrity, there is no alternative to reach my audience directly. There is an immensely strong network effect. > I also don't agree, don't think Twitter is acting at all biased. I think they have very basic rules & have been very kind about trying to enforce them. Why then did they let people post about the fictional Russian collusion for 3 years? Investigations by federal agencies finally concluded that there was none. So why did Twitter allow that narrative to play out? Why did they let the leaked video of Trump saying random things in personal conversations be posted and shared? Why did Twitter let people post about fake and unproven allegations against Bret Kavanaugh? What was different?
- rektide 6y agoThis is incredibly insightful commentary, and I think it confesses to what a lot of the people protesting these platforms are actually angry about. It's unfortunate that humanity is addicted to a couple pairs of supra-governmental private entities, that governments are less important than these private properties, but I don't think their massive massive world dominating size entitles governments to come meddle with their affairs & poke & prod & demand they become certain specific forms of free speech vehicles. It's up to the company to decide what kind of platform they want to be. And it's up to us to use these systems or not. This above statement works & holds, so long as it's only network effect & not technical barrier to generating our own speech systems. Which, thankfully, I feel like the internet readily supplies (at least for now!).
- dragonwriter 6y ago> I'd prefer full censorship instead of the partisan sham that Twitter is doing now. Historically, and this is one of its major problems, "full" censorship is a partisan act by the party defining and implementing the standards. So, when you say this, all I hear is that you prefer a different partisan basis for censorship, and for it to be globally-consistent partisanship rather than variable to reflecting the partisans preferences of individual outlets.
- perryizgr8 6y agoI meant make them responsible for anything that is posted/published on the platform. Oh, someone tweeted out a link to download a pirated copy of Mulan? Twitter is sued by Disney for losses incurred. Someone tweeted a threat to the President, secret service will interrogate Twitter execs/mods. Someone posts a tweet about depression and later is found to have committed suicide, Twitter will be criminally responsible for not informing the local police about a possible suicidal person. Then they will be forced to vet every single tweet for accuracy/illegal content, or face continuous threat of lawsuits. Right now, they are blatantly bidding for one party's candidate, and abusing their monopoly by doing so. And hiding behind the guise of being a "platform".
- dragonwriter 6y ago> As every CEO noted, censorship would have to (radically) increase if platforms were no longer had protection from the speech they happen to host. If 230 was repealed, outlets could still retreat to only distributor rather than publisher liability by abandoning pro-active censorship entirely.
- dlp211 6y agoAnd their platforms would all devolve into 4/8chan. No thanks.
- dragonwriter 6y agoWell, yeah, I didn't say it was a good option, just that total preemptive moderation (also not a good option) isn't the only choice.
- dlp211 6y agoIt's almost like Sec. 230 is actually a good statute that may need to be tweaked, but not fundamentally changed or repealed.
- dragonwriter 6y ago> It's almost like Sec. 230 is actually a good statute that may need to be tweaked, but not fundamentally changed or repealed. Well, yeah, while I don't point that out in every comment on 230-related issues, that's 100% my position. Pre-230, mass communications platforms were between Scylla and Charybdis in a way which had previously been masked by the economics of print publishing and distribution making total editing the only sensible approach independent of liability concerns. The emergence of online platforms really brought that to light, and 230 was, if perhaps problematic in some details of application, exactly the right kind of solution.
- UncleMeat 6y agoThat’s not true. A moderation-free platform can still get in trouble for defamation posted on their platform if 230 was removed.
- hnlurker 6y agoOscar Wilde: "Just as the worst slave-owners were those who were kind to their slaves, and so prevented the horror of the system being realised [sic (wink gbr)] by those who suffered from it, and understood by those who contemplated it, [...], the people who do most harm are the people who try to do most good." Better to have all the cards face up on the table. You want to shadowban or outright censor the Right, fine so be it, just have a backbone and do it in the open. It will allow competitors to come in and fill the market for people who don't take their marching orders from the Left, and vice versa. Just put the shoe on the other foot. What if NYT was banned for publishing an article about Trump's stolen tax information? What if anyone who tried to share NYT article was similarly banned or muted? NYPost is mostly trash, but the only way we can be sure the NYT has their rights protected is to ensure NYP has their rights protected.
- ocdtrekkie 6y agoIt's not scary, it's promising. It means both sides understand the harm Section 230 causes, even if they disagree on how it plays out on their party specifically. It allows platforms to be judge, jury, and executioner, while insulating them from any risk of appeal (being taken to court and held liable). It's an incredibly bad law, and it took election tampering for politicians to realize it also harms them, not just the little people who voted for them. Politicians mostly care about themselves, and 2016 finally proved that 230 is a mistake that can no longer be ignored.
- edmundsauto 6y agoJudge, jury, and executioner of the behavior they allow on their property. Let’s not mix this up with the roles in the legal system that actually have those powers.
- ocdtrekkie 6y agoSocial media is the public square in 2020. There's no way to claim we still have free speech while all speech is done in a private company's territory where said freedom "does not apply". So realistically, we have two options: Regulate what those companies are allowed to do and hold them liable for what they do, or nationalize them so that we can once again treat them as public space.
- edmundsauto 6y agoI don’t concede that social media is the public square; at most, it is one piece. It also seems to be one of the less useful, judging by the overall timbre of the engagement. Even if true, what right does the govt or people have to reprieve the companies of their property rights? Nationalization is not generally in line with our system of laws in the US.
- ocdtrekkie 6y agoI certainly don't think nationalization is the ideal outcome. I'd hate for Twitter to become "the" official state communication medium. I'd far rather we stop making social media public squares by requiring social use decentralized protocols, like email. But if we're not nationalizing, we need to accept that companies operating these platforms must at minimum be regulated, just like privately owned utilities are. They're conduct should be transparent, the public should be able to inspect the algorithms in use, and most crucially, these companies must be liable for their behavior. And that is directly contrary to the goals of Section 230.
- jariel 6y agoThese platforms are already censored. It's not that hard to get a Tweet annulled or kicked off FB. The issue is that right now, it's just 'opaque, private policy', mostly concerned with over violence, literally hate speech, that kind of stuff. Twitter's banning of The NY Post a few days before an election though is quite problematic. If there were some reasonable guidelines it might be a good idea, but I'm not sure how it would work. The only answer I see is for Social Media to be very transparent about their policies, very consistent, probably have an external board and commit to some common standard approach. It's one thing for FB/Twitter, altogether more difficult for Google though they've managed to stay out of it mostly.
- whammywon 6y ago"So weird how Cruz &c keep making this sound like there's some mandate that these platforms be nuetral" My understanding is that if these companies wish to use Section 230 to keep themselves from being held liable for what their users post. By censoring users' posts that don't violate the law they are acting as a publisher and not a platform, ergo eliminating Section 230 protections. To my understanding, Trump didn't authorize the publishing of his tax info, so surely that would count as "hacked" or "illegally obtained", right? From what I've read about Hunter Biden's laptop, the information was legally obtained because he left the computer at the repair shop long enough that it legally became the property of the shop owner. I could be wrong (and if I am, please let me know) but that, to me, seems like clear bias on the part of Twitter and Facebook. If they had treated both articles in the same manner I would likely agree with you about a lack of bias, but it seems to me that this was done to prevent damage being done to one campaign.
- rektide 6y agoMy understanding was that Section 230 was to protect platforms from liability. It was not to create new restrictions on how they must or must not otherwise regulate & shape speech on their platform. This implication that platforms have to allow anyone to say whatever they want unless it's a certain pre-set class of illegal speech, lest they become some other service class with additional liabilities for speech, seems facetiously misguided & contrary to all evidence there is for how Section 230 was proposed, discussed, and how it describes itself.
- whammywon 6y ago"...seems facetiously misguided & contrary to all evidence" It may be, I'm certainly no expert. As a layman I've been led to believe that if you alter user-generated content you toe the line of being classified as a publisher as opposed to a platform. And my understanding of platform versus publisher is that the latter is legally liable for the site's content and thus allowed to be moderated more heavily than the former. Again, I have zero experience with writing/interpreting law so recognize that I could be wrong here...