5 ms·
amusingly enough, coming from the EU the site told me: "451: Unavailable due to legal reasons"
by bryanrasmussen 6y ago
amusingly enough, coming from the EU the site told me: "451: Unavailable due to legal reasons"
- parliament32 6y agoPlay stupid games, win stupid prizes.
- madsbuch 6y agoWell, if the prices are 1. the legal tools to make Spotify not lockin ones personal content and 2. Read some random article on the internet where the publisher actively does not want to protect the readers privacy then I think I know what price I want.
- jedberg 6y ago> where the publisher actively does not want to protect the readers privacy You don't know that. They may take privacy very seriously, but don't see any point in risking possible GDPR issues, especially if they get no income from people in Europe.
- garmaine 6y agoI really don’t. You’re telling me some music app is more important than being able to access local news from other regions?
- Swenrekcah 6y agoA vpn is always an option, and it's commoditized enough. Eventually all regions that pretend to care about their citizens freedom should adopt a GDPR like law.
- AnthonyMouse 6y ago> Eventually all regions that pretend to care about their citizens freedom should adopt a GDPR like law. But unless they all adopt the same one, the requirements will all be different, which means they'd each have independent compliance costs, which means local news providers like this will still block everybody outside of their own jurisdiction so that they only have to pay one set of compliance costs instead of sixteen or a hundred.
- parliament32 6y agoExactly. Attempting to regulate the internet will always end in failure, as we've seen again and again. The EU's initiatives are very noble but I think: as they try to keep enforcing their laws and fines, they're just going to end up with less content being available to people in their jurisdiction. You thought copyright region-restrictions were bad.. just wait until Spotify refuses to serve your continent because compliance is costing more than the profits you generate.
- Swenrekcah 6y agoIf spotify stops taking my money I and millions others will go buy music somewhere else. Spotify is not exactly popular with non-superstar musicians either.
- parliament32 6y agoLike where? It's not exactly a bustling market -- Google is dead since they killed Play Music and tried to force everyone to YT, Apple Music pretty much only appeals to Apple users, and all the other alternatives have relatively small catalogs. I'm not trying to be combative, I'm legitimately asking: what alternatives to Spotify are there?
- Swenrekcah 6y agoThe premise was that Spotify would decide it wasn't worth the bother to service the EU (or another market) due to GDPR (or a similar law). In that event, I have no doubt that an alternative or two would emerge.
- madsbuch 6y agoActually, no. Try to reread the comment.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- think814 6y agoGDPR FTW
- quercusa 6y ago451 is a great status code, right up there with 418.
- smabie 6y agoNot better than 420. You could say that 420 is the highest of all status codes
- maxcbc 6y agoMy favourite part of GDPR is getting to use 451 legitimately everywhere.
- OJFord 6y agoI'm not sure it is really though is it? It's legitimate in the same way that '451: we want to load up our site with so much javascript your computer catches fire and burns your house down, but that's illegal in your jurisdiction so this site is Unavailable for Legal Reasons' is. To me 451 is like 404 (nothing here) and 410 (was something here but now there isn't) - it's a further progression/specificity to 'was/sort of is something here but it's not presently available for legal reasons'. Common obvious one is DMCA takedown notices, but it might also be an injunction, or even accidentally published while still under embargo - or deliberately to prime SEO (not advice) - or NDA, etc.
- ben_w 6y agoIt’s a Carol business decision that letting Alices & Bobs view content for free isn’t cost effective if Carol isn’t allowed to track Alice and Bob without their permission and make money by letting Eve, who is unknown Alice and Bob, to build up a detailed profile of Alice and Bob. Project Guttenberg in Germany (and The Pirate Bay in the USA, I think) would be 451.
- wizzwizz4 6y agoWhy is Project Gutenberg illegal in Germany?
- jedberg 6y agoFor local news organizations who don't get any revenue from foreign viewers, it's much cheaper (and more profitable) to just block Europeans than to try and comply with GDPR.
- guitarbill 6y agothis isn't correct, and i wish it would stop being repeated on HN. if you don't target/do business with Europeans specifically, there is nothing to comply with. what jurisdiction does Europe have? however, a lot of "small", local news organisations are actually owned by huge (multi-national) corporations. they might work hard to preserve that small appearance, but do have a reason to fear the GDPR.
- jedberg 6y ago> if you don't target/do business with Europeans specifically, there is nothing to comply with. what jurisdiction does Europe have? Because as you said yourself, they're part of a large organization that DOES do business with Europe, but that part of the business doesn't get any money from Europe, so there is no reason for that part of the business to go to the effort of complying.
- guitarbill 6y agosure, if they do business with Europe, they should be complying with the laws. i don't think that's controversial. you said "local news organizations", and i was simply pointing out if that is what they truly were, they wouldn't have to comply. so i think we agree?
- jedberg 6y agoEven for a truly local news org, it might make more sense to just block Europeans then allow them, because Article 3(2) of the GDPR, which gives the EU extraterritorial powers to prosecute. While it's never been tested, there is a good chance the USA would cooperate with an extraterritorial prosecution, and so it's easier to just avoid it altogether by blocking Europeans.
- tzs 6y agoEven if any tracking your site does already fully complies with GDPR as does your handling of personal data, it still takes some effort and costs some money if GDPR actually applies to your site. If you are not in Europe, the main thing that determines whether or not GDPR applies to your site is Article 3 of the GDPR, "Territorial Scope", and the corresponding Recitals. A big factor there is whether you are offering goods or services in the Union, irrespective of whether or not users have to pay. Mere accessibility from the Union isn't enough to show you are offering things in the Union. What matters is whether or not the site "envisages offering services to data subjects in one or more Member States in the Union". There are several things that can show you are envisaging offering in the Union. Having localized versions of your site in languages that are used in the Union but not in your own country, accepting payment in Euros or the national currencies of Union members, targeting Europeans with ads for your site, and many others. If you aren't doing those things, it gets more subjective. If your site should be of no interest to Europeans, and you don't expect to make any money from whatever Europeans happen to somehow end up on it, it is simplest to do a geoip block on Europe. That should conclusively establish that you do not envisage offering services to people in the Union.
- mytailorisrich 6y agoIt's not only offering goods and services but also "monitoring of behaviour" so analytics and tracking, which, strictly speaking, makes the GDPR applicable to most websites on this planet. In practice, if you don't have high visibility (i.e are small enough, which probably means 90% of websites) and don't have any presence in the EU then just ignore GDPR because no-one is going to go after a website on another continent because it tracks visitors and sometimes people from the EU visit it.
- nabilhat 6y agoIt's just bulk distributed townnews dot com generated content. Search the name "Lisa Landon" to find the verbatim story in dozens of tabloid rags. Some of them are east of the Atlantic.
- willis936 6y agoI thought it was suspicious that the Useless Leader managed to publish an interesting piece.
- fauria 6y agoThe Four Internets... https://stratechery.com/2020/india-jio-and-the-four-internets/ https://stratechery.com/2020/india-jio-and-the-four-internet...
- pornel 6y agoGood to know that their business model is illegal in 27 countries.
- eli 6y agoGDPR requires far more than a compatible business model. In practice, you need a consultant and maybe a lawyer to help with the paperwork and that's assuming all the processes are basically in compliance.
- mgraczyk 6y agoInterestingly, I get this from my US corporate VPN as well
- divbyzer0 6y agohttps://outline.com/3jtrdR https://outline.com/3jtrdR