3 ms·
Would this be newsworthy on HN for any normal project? I think it would be newsworthy if Linus was invited to speak at the CIA, or Andy Rubin, so: yes. But ma
by erikpukinskis 16y ago
Would this be newsworthy on HN for any normal project?
I think it would be newsworthy if Linus was invited to speak at the CIA, or Andy Rubin, so: yes.
But maybe somebody could take a look and see.
What sort of pattern would qualify as not organic to you? I didn't vote up this story, but I'm happy to see it on the front page because I think Bitcoin is probably the most fascinating hack I've seen in several years.
Full disclosure: I own 154.74 BTC, although I couldn't care less about it as an investment. I just think it's cool technologically and politically.
- trotsky 16y agoI think it would be newsworthy if Linus was invited to speak at the CIA, or Andy Rubin, so: yes. I find it pretty hard to believe that linus would either a) send a warning to a mailing list that he'd be speaking at Langley in a few months or b) that anyone would link to such a low content post on HN. What sort of pattern would qualify as not organic to you? First five to ten votes of each story mostly coming from different people/ips. Or whatever standard HN usually uses to break voting blocks or set a spammy url to auto-dead.
- waterlesscloud 16y agoI was one of the early upvotes on this story. I don't vote up most bitcoin stories, though I read most of them. It's an interesting topic, an extra-governmental currency. I've been undecided about the prospects of bitcoin as anything more than a fringe activity. I have the software installed, but I never run it. I have like 0.05 bitcoin I got from some free source when I first came across it. In other words, I have no vested interest. But this story seemed to be the first early indication that people with actual influence on the world were giving bitcoin some interest. So I voted up for two reasons - 1. To see if anyone in this community of tech savvy people would have any commentary of value on it. 2. To flag it as an early warning sign of a disruptive tech to follow up on later. So. No bloc here, and I was in the first five.
- trotsky 16y agoThanks, I appreciate you chiming in. I'm glad to know it sounds like my suspicions were wrong.
- kiba 16y agoBut I like HN stories about bitcoin! Very genuinely interested in it, not just a speculator. (Actually, I don't trade bitcoins on the exchanges anymore)
- trotsky 16y agoSure, of course you're a global moderator at the bitcoin.org forums, right? With nearly 4,000 posts there in the last 9 months? It's hard to imagine you need to come to HN to see links back to your own forum and other stories that you've already read.