7 ms·
The fundamental prerequisite for functional mass transit is a high population density. That's why it works in NYC and doesn't work in Los Angeles. But that mea
by AnthonyMouse 6y ago
The fundamental prerequisite for functional mass transit is a high population density. That's why it works in NYC and doesn't work in Los Angeles.
But that means it's not just a matter of building mass transit. First you have to build taller buildings.
And even then there are going to be places where it's just not happening. It doesn't matter how you change the zoning, nobody is going to build skyscrapers in Pine Bluffs, Wyoming.
- atharris 6y agoThe rest of the world is rife with small, rural towns that nevertheless have great public transit systems, or at least ones that are more effective than what we see in the US. The major difference is that these places are willing to invest in the public sphere, and they're by and large willing to permit construction that is not car-centric (i.e., no parking minima to subsidize drivers).
- zamfi 6y agoCould you give a few examples of small rural towns where people can afford cars but instead the town has great public transit? Genuinely curious!
- JoeAltmaier 6y agoIowa City, Iowa
- zamfi 6y agoAm I missing something? Iowa City seems to have only busses, and they run hourly. Perhaps I'm wrong? If I'm not wrong, then we have vastly different definitions of "great public transit" -- I would not be happy there without a car.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- cfarre 6y agoRedmond, Oregon
- zamfi 6y agoAm I missing something here too? Redmond seems to have only inter-city busses.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- edogg 6y agoWhistler, BC
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- jcranmer 6y agoThat's not exactly true. Bus systems are viable for low-density urban areas. Indeed, prior to the mass adoption of the automobile, buses and streetcars were fairly ubiquitous, even in such heavily urbanized areas as Peoria (population at the time: 70k).
- sirsar 6y agoLA has an order of magnitude more population than is required for functioning public transit. But you're right they don't have the density. The key is to realize the cars themselves killed density. Parking lots, parking spaces, and extra lanes all conspire to push humans and human spaces further apart. This then makes walking less feasible, cars more required, and more space required to accommodate those cars in a feedback loop. Taller buildings are not required for density, far from it. Look at Somerville, MA, where just about nothing is higher than 3 stories, yet they fit almost 20,000 people into a square mile -- and they like it. What they don't fit is 20,000 parking spaces, and that makes all the difference.
- Domenic_S 6y ago> almost 20,000 people into a square mile That's less than 1/3 the density of Manhattan and about on par with SF.
- theplague42 6y agoRight... >where just about nothing is higher than 3 stories The point is that cars destroy density regardless of what your building height limits are.
- paul_f 6y agoThe car did not directly kill density, it enabled people to choose less density.
- Analemma_ 6y agoThat's a distinction without a difference.
- vkou 6y agoIt doesn't enable people to choose, it made a choice and forced it upon everyone.
- agentdrtran 6y agoI love making the free choice between a car that costs hundreds each month vs unlimited public transit for $90
- jhardy54 6y ago> The fundamental prerequisite for functional mass transit is a high population density. What does "high" mean? I think this should be quantified, preferably by someone qualified. Unqualified opinion: It seems to me that if we took all of the money spent on personal vehicles, time spent driving, fuel and emission costs, infrastructure maintenance, and costs to human happiness + safety, we would be able to provide a better transportation system.
- claudeganon 6y ago> The fundamental prerequisite for functional mass transit is a high population density. The Chinese and Japanese rail networks would like a word.
- thescriptkiddie 6y agoYou don't have to build skyscrapers to achieve high population density, you just have to build 3-6 story buildings close together. See Paris for an example. And you can have functional public transport at modest population density as long as the road network is a well connected grid and not a maze of cul-de-sacs. See Toronto for an example. I agree that most of the US has been designed explicitly around the car, but there is no need to be fatalistic about it. Most US cities (including LA) had good public transportation before WW2, and they could have it again if they wanted.
- owyn 6y agoYeah, there's a cool project [1] that maps out all the historic streetcar routes in SF. There used to be a LOT of them, they all got ripped out to make more room for cars. There were rail tracks on the bay bridge! Those got ripped out in 1956 apparently. Everything was converted to buses so yeah, there's still public transit but I definitely feel like something valuable was lost there. I'd also argue that much of the bay area was built for street cars (they existed after all!) and we could always put them back if there was a compelling cost/benefit to doing so. [1] https://sfstreetcars.co https://sfstreetcars.co
- clairity 6y agoLA has good public transportation but car-induced sprawl makes it less useful than it could be, and car culture here makes public transportation less appealing and less used than it could be. but if you live & work near one of the train lines, it’s awesome.
- ska 6y ago> The fundamental prerequisite for functional mass transit is a high population density. This just doesn't seem to be true. It probably needs some density (think "town", not "farmland") but the fundamental prerequisite is a commitment to planning and building public transit infrastructure, rather than automobile focused infrastructure. Lot's of relatively low density places in Europe, Japan, etc. have very functional public mass transit. It's not universal, but there are good examples. If you start with the assumption that approximately everyone has a car, you can choose build cities in ways that only support that...
- jsinai 6y agoPrecisely. And the second fundamental prerequisite is frequency. Make public transport frequent enough, and with privileged access (eg bus lanes) and it will be more convenient than private cars.
- Kaze404 6y agoThe city I live in has around 65 thousand people and has perfectly functional public transportation. This doesn't ring true for me.
- khrbrt 6y agoLos Angeles is spread out because it had functional mass transit at the turn of the last century. The Red Car interurban line sprawled out from downtown into the county and housing popped up six blocks on the side from every stop. Later mass car ownership filled in the blocks further out and the space in-between stops. In that same period, just about every large town and small city had a trolley line. You don't need skyscrapers for mass transit. Just enough political will to keep it funded.
- JoeAltmaier 6y agoRunning a bus isn't that expensive. Running one every 15 minutes around a small town in a loop isn't that expensive. I don't think there's anything fundamental about density. Its about ridership and funding. Even LA could have functional mass transit if it had the will to fund 15-minute busses on a grid all day. A 25 cent tax on gas would do it. If even 2 people average rode each bus, it'd break even on traffic density as well?
- dragonwriter 6y ago> 25 cent tax on gas would do it. If even 2 people average rode each bus, it'd break even on traffic density as well? Busses accelerate, decelerate, and turn differently than cars, so even if in terms of steady-state flow the two-riders = break-even argument is correct, it's not in city traffic. Moreover, I'd like to see your work on operating and capital costs, especially accounting for road wear for which the usual approximate rule of thumb is that it varies with the fourth power of vehicle weight.
- JoeAltmaier 6y agoWell, I'm repeating something my old boss Eric Carlson at Unisys said, in his Master's thesis on City Planning. And remember, the City busses are running only every 15 minutes. So whatever effect they have on localized traffic, it's very intermittent.
- an_opabinia 6y agoListen you’re totally right. But even if car people lived somewhere with the best public transport in the world, they would drive. It’s not about technology or even reality. This conversation is a lot like trying to tell private health insurance users about single payer systems. Or private school users about federalized education. Or telling people with 4 children or 0 children how to live in a world where a thing like the sedan is designed for people with 2 children. It is telling rich people you know better and also they are wrong, which is not an emotion you’re permitted to send.
- 6y ago