3 ms·
“What rational lawyer would have signed on to represent the Concepcions in litigation for the possibility of fees stemming from a $30.22 claim?” Isn't this the
by tedunangst 16y ago
“What rational lawyer would have signed on to represent the Concepcions in litigation for the possibility of fees stemming from a $30.22 claim?”
Isn't this the purpose of small claims court?
That question actually sums up my dislike of most class actions. It's not about righting a wrong, it's about a lawyer winning the jackpot. I've been a part of about a dozen class action settlements, and had I dug up sales receipts from ten years ago, could have earned myself awards sometimes approaching $5.00. Meanwhile, the law firm earned about $10 million. Not bad for a year's work.
- Joakal 16y agoYou might assume it's a lawyer hitting the jackpot, but the company had to pay it out of their coffers. The hit to the coffers (typically investors' money) means the company needs to avoid doing the same issue again. Same argument for governments. If the taxpayers are upset at government losing taxpayer dollars in court, then they have their chance to voice a change in government. The opposition could point out the waste in next election and the current government gets defeated. If you don't want to be part of a suit for $5.00 refunds, you can put yourself down as an exception. You can then sue them yourself.
- bluedanieru 16y agoExactly. Griping about lawyers getting a payday is just class warfare nonsense. (I agree they generally get too much, but this is throwing the baby out with the bathwater). There is also the argument that when companies lose lawsuits they just pass the expense on to the consumer. I've always thought that was part of the point though. If the company in question is a monopoly however, I suppose there is some merit to that...
- guelo 16y agoWithout class-action why would these giant corporations NOT steal $5, $30 or more from all of its customers, when probably less than 1% will fight back?
- hncommenter13 16y agoUm, the potential to lose in arbitration? Possible state and federal criminal liability? Civil enforcement actions by federal and state agencies? Bad publicity? Competition?