3 ms·
I didn't watch the video because i don't want this type of nonsense in my viewing history and because the premise is inherently flawed. Socialism means somethi
by sofixa 6y ago
I didn't watch the video because i don't want this type of nonsense in my viewing history and because the premise is inherently flawed.
Socialism means something, and Nazi Germany and the NSDAP don't fit any of the criteria. Did the workers own the means of production ? Did the NSDAP even remotely move in that direction? No and hell no. The NSDAP worked closely with industrialists ( which helped finance their rise to power), destroyed unions, etc. Having a few national programs ( Volkswahen, the Autobahn, etc.) doesn't mean socialism.
They were as socialistic as horses are fish. Yeah, they have two eyes, but that's about it.
- rendall 6y ago"Did the workers own the means of production ? Did the NSDAP even remotely move in that direction?" The arguments in the video address everything you bring up, here. It would be lovely to have you refute those very specific arguments. My precis won't argue nearly as well: "Did the workers own the means of production ?" Nazis seized businesses, positions and property from Jews and absolutely handed them over to Germans, which is the Nazi analog of seizing the means of production "destroyed unions..." Destroyed communist labor unions in favor of Nazi labor unions, youth groups, etc "The NSDAP worked closely with industrialists..." I would imagine if you were one of those industrialists, and you didn't work closely with the Nazis, you would swiftly find your industry "nationalized" "I didn't watch the video because i don't want this type of nonsense in my viewing history" ... the fellow is decidedly anti-socialist, and if you're pro-socialist I can imagine you would find it upsetting. But, given that you know socialism intimately, you are the only one who can refute those ideas! It would be nice to know where he goes off the rails
- BlueTemplar 6y agoThey're "socialist" like current "democratic socialist" European governments?
- rendall 6y agoPersonally, I don't think so. I wish there were two separate words for these two concepts: * the proletariat seizing the means of production from the bourgeoisie (or 'volk' from 'untermenschen' in the case of the Nazis) and distributing resources from a centralized economic authority * generous social benefits funded by high taxes as a matter of public and social policy They're both labeled "socialism" but completely different ways and results. In the US, discussion of the second is always stymied by conflation with the first