4 ms·
Is the question about qualia even a meaningful one? It feels to me like running a program twice and asking whether it's really the same program that was run, gi
by TeMPOraL 6y ago
Is the question about qualia even a meaningful one? It feels to me like running a program twice and asking whether it's really the same program that was run, given that each time, the addresses of library functions the program used were different[0].
It could be that when you see 450nm light, the pathways in your brain that process this information correspond to the pathways that respond to 700nm light in my head. But it doesn't matter; our experiences are adjusted to match, because they're synchronized, thanks to shared environment and language. In both of us, despite invoking different neuron groups, seeing a blue sky will evoke images of water, or Windows error codes, and not of roses or rust. If we talk, both of us will use the word "blue" to describe what we're experiencing.
Whether the rainbow is upside-down or not in your head doesn't seem to be a meaningful question, if through all imaginable ways to observe and communicate it, it seems you perceive it the same way as the rest of us.
--
[0] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Address_space_layout_randomization https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Address_space_layout_randomiza...
- DennisP 6y agoI would say the question of qualia is meaningful, in the sense that a good answer might teach us something about the nature of reality. It's just not a practical question. However, it might become a practical question, if someday we have to decide whether AGI should have rights, or whether we think a human uploaded to silicon would have qualia.