4 ms·
> Now, Brown's sources in all likelihood did tell him that Hitler's anti-Semitism was for show. That is scarier than the alternative of Hitler being a true bel
by roenxi 6y ago
> Now, Brown's sources in all likelihood did tell him that Hitler's anti-Semitism was for show.
That is scarier than the alternative of Hitler being a true believer. What Jew would feel comfortable would want to live in a country where a cynic would choose to attack Jews because it played well to the mob?
- mtgx 6y ago"Hitler was just joking about that!"
- muzani 6y agoIn modern politics, it would be dismissed as a vocal, extreme minority. And if such a person won elections, they'd be accused of gerrymandering and such.
- throwaway2048 6y agoA few bad apples
- brobdingnagians 6y agoThere is audio recording of Governor Cuomo telling Orthodox Jewish leaders in New York that his restrictions on their religious activities are driven by fear (i.e. political) not science. Would that qualify?
- ashtonkem 6y agoBy and far the scariest thing about Hitler’s rise to power is not the small minority of true believers, but rather the large masses of the population that weren’t true believers but went along with it for one reason or another. Perhaps they wanted career advancement, perhaps they feared communists and trade unionists more, or maybe they thought they could do more good on the inside. Whatever the personal reason, tons and tons of perfectly reasonable, nice Germans voted for, joined, or stood by as the Nazis took power and plunged the world into war and committed mass murder.
- thu2111 6y agoEh, look at the modern attacks on white males. Mainstream politicians give speeches where they denounce white men and say things like, "women are better than men" (Obama), "women are the primary victims of war" (Clinton), "It's an English jurisprudential culture, a white man's culture. It's got to change" (Biden). They do it because it their base loves it, it plays well to "the mob" (though of course calling it that won't win me any favours here on HN), discrimination and effective banning of white men from being appointed to top positions is widespread behaviour throughout the west at this point, and so on. There seem like two big differences. One is that - so far at least - the politicians doing this don't call for actual violence against white men. However, it's starting to get close. In places where BLM is active people scrawl on their storefronts that they're black, in an attempt to avoid the violence and damage dished out against any business not perceived as 'allied'. Prominent politicians conspicuously avoid condemning the violently racist behaviour of these rioters. The other is that Hitler genuinely hated Jews as a race. He didn't have any concept of 'allied' Jews. Modern racial hatred often comes across as not especially genuine because it's full of white men condemning "white men", and people demanding women /blacks/black women be put into powerful positions ... unless they're the wrong kind of minority, i.e. conservative, in which case they are treated in exactly the same way as the "white men". Scott Alexander has written eloquently about the way these labels, which on the surface appear to have clear racial or gender-based definitions, have been effectively adopted and rewritten within certain subcultures to be code words for conservatives. This doesn't seem to precisely parallel what happened in Nazi Germany where, for all you can say about him, Hitler said exactly what he was going to do and then did it. Although Goebbels was well known for his ideas on propaganda, the regimes most famous for screwing with their citizens minds were all communist. Orwell's 1984 was inspired by socialism and not the more obvious and immediate example of Nazi-ism for that reason.
- jgwil2 6y agocf. “When Mexico sends its people, they’re not sending their best. They’re not sending you. They’re not sending you. They’re sending people that have lots of problems, and they’re bringing those problems with us. They’re bringing drugs. They’re bringing crime. They’re rapists. And some, I assume, are good people.” White men in 21st century America are still at the top of the totem pole; their situation is nothing like that of Jews in early 20th-century Europe. Perhaps you should spend a little more time worrying about the most vulnerable members of our society, who are also targeted by political speech, ostensibly just to rile up the "masses." Let's not forget that there are now 500 children separated, perhaps permanently, from their parents, as a result of the policies of the man who spoke the words above.
- scatters 6y agoYou just described more or less every country in Europe (if not the entire world) at the time. Zionism came out of a desire for Jews to have a country where they could feel comfortable that demagogues wouldn't fire up the mob against them.