4 ms·
For those who want to know where those numbers from from. Under the 1909 Copyright Act, it was 28 years which could be renewed for another 28 years, giving a t
by tzs 6y ago
For those who want to know where those numbers from from.
Under the 1909 Copyright Act, it was 28 years which could be renewed for another 28 years, giving a total of 56 years. The work was first published in 1966, giving 1966 + 56 = 2022.
The Copyright Act of 1976, the term became life of the author + 50 years for non-corporate works, and 75 years after first publication for corporate works. For works from before 1976 there were still under copyright, it was sort of retroactive.
I say "sort of" because instead of simple saying those simply got the new term, keeping their original start date, it changed their renewal term from 28 years to 47 years, which gives 75 years. Works that were still in the first term would still have to renew to get that 47 year renewal term. Anyway, 1966 + 28 + 47 = 2041. (Yes, I know that is not 2040. No, I don't know why not. (Well, I know why 1966 + 28 + 47 is not 2040...)).
The 1998 Copyright Term Extension Act (which, BTW, is the only copyright term extension in the US that Disney lobbying might have actually influenced [1]) changed the term for corporate works to be 95 years from publication or 120 years from creation, whichever is earlier.
1966 + 95 = 2061.
[1] There have only been two copyright term extensions in the US since Disney was founded. I haven't been able to find anything on where they stood on the 1976 Act or if they did any lobbying for it. Of course they were in favor of it--but so was nearly everyone else. It made the US system much more compatible with the rest of the world, paving the way for the US to join the Berne Convention.
- iso1631 6y ago"It's a wonderful life" was released under 1909 rules. It came out in 1946, so was copyrighted until 1974. The owners (RKO) didn't renew the copyright, as it was a failed film, it was well before home video, so why bother I guess. Thus in 1974 is became public domain, and all the networks could play it as many times as they wanted with no cost, and did so - making it a very popular film in the American cultural zeitgeist. In 1993 this was all undone though, and now only the owner (which is NBC) is allowed to show the classic film, because it was based on a story that is copyrighted (and NBC acquired the copyright) Copyright length are ridiculous. Any implication (we need copyright otherwise people won't create) that Philip Van Doren Stern wrote his story in 1943 because he felt he could capitalize on the rights of a derivative film in the cable tv and streaming era is laughable.
- tptacek 6y agoPhilip Van Doren Stern sold the rights to his short story for the equivalent of about $150,000. Whatever he thought about the prospects for that story, the acquirer surely had had their own plans, and those plans funded the Stern's subsequent work and lifestyle. Knowing what we know now, Stern surely would have bargained harder and perhaps gotten more money from RKO --- as is the case in any business transaction where we're given perfect information about outcomes. But that doesn't change the underlying moral rights involved. I think this appeal to Stern is a pretty weak argument. Further: the argument about copyright lapsing on Its A Wonderful Life is misleading. RKO let the copyright lapse, but if they hadn't, it would properly have been copyrighted --- under the 1909 rules! --- until 2000.
- iso1631 6y agoIf it hadn't lapsed it would have remained unloved at the bottom of a vault somewhere and not become a cultural icon.
- tptacek 6y agoIf RKO hadn't bought the rights to it for $150,000 (2020) practically none of us would have even heard about it, the same way we haven't heard of thousands of other short stories from the first half of the 20th Century.
- mncharity 6y agoThat characterization of the 1976 act... let's just say, years later, person on the government side of that negotiation was still defensively apologetic, claiming it a success... as damage control, because of all the "crazy stuff" Disney et al were pushing. Beware a concerted effort since to rewrite history as "just Berne, no biggy". Berne reflects a major defeat of a US tradition of copyright as "industrial policy for the general welfare", by a European tradition of "rights and property", and by rent seeking.
- dredmorbius 6y agoAny background / references on this?
- mncharity 6y ago[conversation moved]
- dredmorbius 6y agoThanks, appreciated. Any details on branch/department of gov't?