4 ms·
So now it's not just apps and services, they're killing off brand recognition. I don't understand it. Well, on products at least, I have a theory: there used t
by ineedasername 6y ago
So now it's not just apps and services, they're killing off brand recognition. I don't understand it.
Well, on products at least, I have a theory: there used to be "Google Labs", an interesting selection of experimental projects that you knew were experimental and perhaps not permanent.
Then they killed off Labs, and it's like everything that would previously been housed there is now released as if it's a fully fledge and supported service, only Google knows it's really just a "Lab" experiment.
As a result, when those things get killed, it's much more against expectations, so it hits harder. Though perhaps not as much anymore now that we all expect it.
This leads to an adoption problem: previously, a Lab that got enough attention might see a true release or be merged as a feature into an existing service. You could use it, not rely on it, and root for it to succeed. Now it's all reversed. You don't want to try a new thing out, you can't ever rely on it, you have no way to distinguish a fully backed initiative from a spaghetti-hits-wall approach.
Basically, Google should resurrect Labs so people know where they stand on using these things.
- bluedays 6y agoDoesn't explain the death of Google Reader.
- ineedasername 6y agoI'm not proposing a unified theory of Google's choices. Google reader is more easily explained by other factors, specifically that it didn't fit nicely into the G+ push by Google and was not otherwise monetized by ads in any significant way at that point. Somewhat tragically, had they built a content-oriented social network around Reader instead of an ill-conceived integration to G+, it would have been more readily monetized and improved Google's chances of success in Social.
- fossuser 6y agoI’m short on google long term - they’re feeling more and more like yahoo to me. Lots of random projects, often killed, little direction - no overall vision. They better hope the ad revenue keeps printing money. It’s possible they could fix this (Microsoft did), but the direction doesn’t look great.
- hnzix 6y ago> Lots of random projects, often killed, little direction This is what happened inside Yahoo as it was imploding. Every team wanted their own dev library/graphics/app style to "win" internally. It resulted in very arrogant dev & project leads fighting with each other for no customer benefit. It's the same in Academia though. "In the heart of every Vice Chancellor lies an Architect". Gotta build a new building so you can put your name on it.
- impendia 6y ago> It's the same in Academia though. Haha, interesting analogy! (Math professor here.) I'd say in many ways it's the same, but with one key difference. While administrators are fighting to push their visions, many faculty members tune out, do whatever work it is they want to do, and pretty much ignore what is going on overall at their institutions. If you read Inside Higher Ed or the Chronicle of Higher Education, then you can read accounts of university leaders who were brought in to push for big changes, who boldly announced a change of direction, ... and who were simply ignored and then quit.
- emilsedgh 6y agoDid Microsoft really fix it? Or it pulled of an IBM and just pivoted into enterprise offerings like Azure. Can't remember when was the last time Microsoft pulled off a new successful consumer ready product or significantly improved an existing one.
- fossuser 6y agoVSCode is a pretty big deal. Xbox Game Pass is a good idea and the series X also looks like a good bet. Buying GitHub was smart, WSL is also a very positive move for developers. Azure is in second place behind AWS with Google a distant third. Typescript is doing really well too. That’s a lot of positive moves around a coherent strategy. Stratechery goes into more detail, and I think makes a pretty compelling case. It’s not comparable to IBM in my opinion, I think MSFT has really righted the ship - I think they’re in a strong position for the future.
- nirui 6y ago> Google knows it's really just a "Lab" experiment. The change seems happened during the time when Google was switching focus away from "been cool" to profitability. The business reason behind it was probably that Google don't want leak any hit about what they were up to, because a leak may cost a major growth opportunity that is unknown to them when they started the experiment.
- rob74 6y agoSo now (to keep the OP's picture) they throw the spaghetti full swing every time. If it sticks to the wall, it's ok (for now), if it doesn't (or not well enough), it gets mopped up, no harm done to the business - except, as the OP wrote, for users who get wary to rely on stuff that may or may not be here next year.
- sigsergv 6y ago> So now it's not just apps and services, they're killing off brand recognition. I don't understand it. Well, that's fine, next manager now has chance to improve brand recognition and impress top management.
- GoblinSlayer 6y agoThey aren't even wrong. Branding is overrated.
- soulofmischief 6y agoI will never integrate a new Google service into anything ever again. I am only interested in disintegration. Google has failed my trust.