3 ms·
> Have I fallen prey to "it's easy, just do X"? A little bit? A carbon tax is workable, I've just come to favor a sales tax as simpler. They're both consumpti
by samatman 6y ago
> Have I fallen prey to "it's easy, just do X"?
A little bit? A carbon tax is workable, I've just come to favor a sales tax as simpler.
They're both consumption taxes, the latter says "ok, this is what we have to take out of the economy to pay for mitigation, lets do it as a sales tax and then pay some of it back for products that reduce carbon burden, either directly or as substitute goods for especially polluting technologies".
The more moving parts something like this has, the more opportunities there are to take advantage of that. Sales tax already exists, it's well understood, this would be fire-and-forget, and it wouldn't create a bunch of new jobs for accountants (nothing against them, but we don't want that).
- triceratops 6y ago> it wouldn't create a bunch of new jobs for accountants That's the part I'm not convinced about. A flat sales tax rate for carbon will inevitably under-tax or over-tax something. Making it fairer will require armies of accountants poring over the carbon intensity of product categories. And of course companies will say "our factories/trucks/warehouses/stores run on wind power, give us a rebate". I understand the appeal of tacking a carbon tax on to an existing tax regime, but would it really be so easy or fair? PS I've upvoted all your comments in this discussion and I appreciate you engaging with me so far. It's given me a lot to think about.