3 ms·
> Wait wait wait, are you actually saying that poor quality research in field X convinced you that field Y also has poor quality research? How does this make se
by AnthonyMouse 6y ago
> Wait wait wait, are you actually saying that poor quality research in field X convinced you that field Y also has poor quality research? How does this make sense?
I'm not sure that was the case being made. It's not the quality of the research, it's the quality of the journalism, which in turn demonstrates that the journalism is of sufficiently low quality as to be incapable of revealing the existence of propaganda-quality research.
Then the problem becomes that if you can't trust the media coverage, you would have to go to the primary sources. But what percentage of people have the time and competence to actually do that?
> How long does it take for you to consider yourself an "expert" in a field?
The poster is clearly referring to the Gell-Mann amnesia effect:
https://loricism.fandom.com/wiki/Gell-Mann_Amnesia_Effect https://loricism.fandom.com/wiki/Gell-Mann_Amnesia_Effect
- Udik 6y ago> It's not the quality of the research, it's the quality of the journalism It's not only that. At some point you realise that even science with all its safeguards is not indifferent to the dominant, accepted belief systems. People simply align with a group and will blindly repeat anything, even self-contradictory statements, as long as it's expected by their peers. It's quite uncanny when you notice it for the first time.
- AnthonyMouse 6y agoThat's because the safeguards in science guard against unintentional error. Peer review isn't robust against political alignment because if the author and the reviewers are all making the same false unstated assumption, nobody is looking in the direction of the error. And it gets even worse if people who do see it are penalized for saying so. The scientific method assumes good faith, good skepticism and a willingness to admit mistakes. Without that you're doing politics, not science.