3 ms·
> Why? Because it's the most elegant way of putting a price on emissions. I used to agree with this, and now I don't. A carbon tax has to be an approximation,
by samatman 6y ago
> Why? Because it's the most elegant way of putting a price on emissions.
I used to agree with this, and now I don't.
A carbon tax has to be an approximation, and there are significant judgement calls on what the total carbon burden of a given product or service might be. This is a recipe for paperwork, loopholes, and a raft of unintended consequences.
Instead, I support an across-the-board carbon sales tax on everything. Use some of this to subsidize carbon-reducing technology at the point of sale. Put the rest of it toward everything else we use taxes for, and make sure that renewable research, nuclear energy, and so on, are adequately funded. UBI? sure, why not; but let's not attach it directly to a climate tax, that only confuses both issues.
There are some exceptions: it's practical to calculate the carbon burden of electricity, and handle the taxation-and-subsidy market directly in that field.
- triceratops 6y ago> A carbon tax has to be an approximation, and there are significant judgement calls on what the total carbon burden of a given product or service might be. Sorry, could you explain more? I always assumed a carbon tax meant an extraction tax on any fossil fuel. For example, taxing companies per barrel of crude, per ton of natgas or coal they take out of the ground. Since practically all carbon emissions involve the use of a fossil fuel somewhere in the chain, wouldn't this capture the carbon output of any product or service?
- samatman 6y agoSure, that would be one way to do it: if there were a one world government, which could impose such a tax. But in the world we have, it's not going to work: that tax would be imposed on only the developed world, which already has issues competing in manufacturing, due to paying reasonable amounts of money for labor, and at least some attention to workplace safety and environmentally-responsible behavior. So you'd have to apply tariffs of some sort on imported goods, and base it on some guesswork as to the carbon footprint of the items. At which point, just giving up and charging a sales tax is better, for the reasons I described.
- triceratops 6y agoCouldn't countries with carbon extraction taxes impose blanket 25% (or 50%, whatever it takes to get immediate compliance) tariffs on all imports from countries that don't have the same carbon taxes? Or impose economic sanctions, freeze assets and so on? Sorry, I'm just spitballing here. Have I fallen prey to "it's easy, just do X"? I agree this would still require a fair amount of coordination between the countries that do the tariffs. But less so than deciding tariffs on individual products based on their pollution.
- samatman 6y ago> Have I fallen prey to "it's easy, just do X"? A little bit? A carbon tax is workable, I've just come to favor a sales tax as simpler. They're both consumption taxes, the latter says "ok, this is what we have to take out of the economy to pay for mitigation, lets do it as a sales tax and then pay some of it back for products that reduce carbon burden, either directly or as substitute goods for especially polluting technologies". The more moving parts something like this has, the more opportunities there are to take advantage of that. Sales tax already exists, it's well understood, this would be fire-and-forget, and it wouldn't create a bunch of new jobs for accountants (nothing against them, but we don't want that).
- triceratops 6y ago> it wouldn't create a bunch of new jobs for accountants That's the part I'm not convinced about. A flat sales tax rate for carbon will inevitably under-tax or over-tax something. Making it fairer will require armies of accountants poring over the carbon intensity of product categories. And of course companies will say "our factories/trucks/warehouses/stores run on wind power, give us a rebate". I understand the appeal of tacking a carbon tax on to an existing tax regime, but would it really be so easy or fair? PS I've upvoted all your comments in this discussion and I appreciate you engaging with me so far. It's given me a lot to think about.
- vkou 6y ago> Sure, that would be one way to do it: if there were a one world government, which could impose such a tax. You can just impose such a tax domestically, and tariff all imports from countries that don't have that tax. The low-carbon industries in those countries will very quickly force their governments to implement a carbon tax, because such a tariff punishes them unfairly.