5 ms·
I can see how it would be comforting to have a villain, but I don't think that is true. Companies deeply linked to the petroleum industry argued against action
by roenxi 6y ago
I can see how it would be comforting to have a villain, but I don't think that is true. Companies deeply linked to the petroleum industry argued against action (as, of course, would be expected). But the basic pitch of the environmentalists has never been acceptable. The idea that we should curtail the comfort of the present population in a speculative attempt to do something in 50 years is unpopular. And in total seriousness, it is rare I've heard an articulation of what that something is vs the alternative. The options I heard were we scale back our lifestyle so our children can scale back theirs, with the alternative of we don't scale back our lifestyle and then our children scale back theirs.
The environmentalist movement has avoided:
* Pushing overpopulation into the political conversation (we've roughly doubled the global population since 50 years ago. The new arrivals are largely people in dire need of better energy access). We have a lot more talks about banning coal than pushing for a 1 child policy in Africa.
* Nuclear energy. Pointing out the obvious, the most successful climate change initiative in the past 50 years has been the energy grid in France. Pro-climate-action has generally correlated with anti-nuclear.
* Talking seriously about the costs or implementation strategy. As I recall, people were saying solar was a cheap option when Germany launched their Energiewende. They now have the most expensive power in Europe.
The best argument historically for ignoring climate change has been that its supporters don't seem to be taking it seriously; they ignored a bunch of contributing factors or picked solutions based on political beliefs rather than trying to support cheap clean energy for everyone. GM and Ford are not responsible for that.
- throwaway6734 6y agoTo start, implement a carbon tax and more appropriately cost current goods. let people prioritize what things they find important
- roenxi 6y agoOk, but do you think there needed to be a misinformation campaign led by devious ne'er-do-wells to make raising taxes unpopular? That is a mechanism to achieve the goals of the environmental movement. Not a reason to achieve the goals of the environmentalists, or an argument that it is the best path.
- AnthonyMouse 6y ago> Ok, but do you think there needed to be a misinformation campaign led by devious ne'er-do-wells to make raising taxes unpopular? The only sensible implementation of a carbon tax is the one in which all of the money is refunded to the population. A program that causes everybody to get ~$1000 while only paying ~$500 in taxes because large corporations are responsible for the majority of carbon emissions would seem to be very popular, absent a misinformation campaign, since the average person would net ~$500 (out of the pockets of Exxon et al).
- specialist 6y agoSquint and Canada's carbon tax dividend looks like UBI. Win / win.
- graeme 6y agoA bunch of environmentalists are idiots. But that doesn’t mean there’s no sensible plan or that it’s all speculative. In economics carbon’s costs have a name: they impose an externality on others. The standard remedy for an externality is a tax. So, to address climate change you would: 1. Institute a tax on carbon 2. Work through an international framework like the UN or WTO to have other countries also institute this tax, and to levy tariffs on any countries that don’t. 3. Since carbon is taxed, you can lower other, less efficient taxes such as the income tax, which is a drag on productivity. 4. You can also redistribute some of the money to compensate the poor for the effective tax increase. For instance this is how canada deals with its sales tax. There are other coherent plans but that’s a big one. Had we implemented thus tax 50 years ago, the effects would have been: * energy efficiency is encouraged in production as there is a higher cost * other forms of energy such as nuclear and hydro gain an advantage * There would have been more capital available for researching other alternatives such as solar * The economy would have remained good due to the benefits of a sharply lower income tax Environmentalists tend to be rather bad at math and not good at thinking through economics or evaluating tradeoffs. Because everyone else abandoned the field, they produced the most prominent (and wrong headed) solutions. But with gradual economically sensible action 50 years ago, we could have been in for a very soft landing. We could have still used fossil fuels too! They were pretty necessary, but the system I outlined would have nudged us towards a different energy base.
- tomp 6y agoThis sounds like a very good plan. The best part of it is that a single country can institute it on it’s own - just start taxing products and imports by carbon! A big enough country could move the needle, and encourage others to take action. Instead, the only actual ideas that actual people actually propose are 100% braindead. Ban meat (lol), ban nuclear (lol lol), ban plastic straws (lol lol lol), ...
- lovemenot 6y agoThis style of argumentation is chilling the discussion. Please stop with the ad hominems. There are many overlapping problems, not only climate change. It's complex. Partial solutions are still solutions. They are just incomplete
- nahuel0x 6y agoWhy push 1 child policy in Africa? Start with USA, where the pollution per person ratio is much higher.
- malandrew 6y agoProbably because the US is already on the trajectory towards 1. The birthrate today is at an all time low of 1.73 in the US. In Africa it is currently 4.6.
- nitrogen 6y agoFully industrialized countries already have declining birth rates and modest populations. Having more kids in places with fewer resources isn't a sustainable proposition. If you have a stable rather than exploding population, it's much easier for that population to raise its standards of living in a sustainable way.
- splitrocket 6y agoFirst off, simply because you don't like the people that support a position doesn't mean that position is incorrect. And overpopulation? Um... because draconian population control tactics and policies are evil? China's one child policy was unconscionable. German energy is costly not due to production costs, but instead due to taxes on energy utilization in general to subsidize a more rapid transition to environmentally sound energy. Other countries, i.e. France, have chosen to lower costs substantially. (France is unwise, IMHO. Lower costs increases utilization which offsets carbon gains, see rebound effects [0]. Germany is doing the right thing) [1] Nuclear: Has always been on the table. Environmentalists are not a unified block. The Gates foundation is substantially funding nuclear. Most of what you think of as "environmental support" is actually funding from petroleum based business. The whole personal recycling movement? paid for by the petroleum industry. [2] Finally, the petroleum industry hired the exact same goons that the tobacco industry did to peddle pseudoscientific nonsense. [3] There are coherent, comprehensive, effective plans for fighting climate change. You are just unlikely to hear about in the news because they are deeply wonky. There are paths out, they are neither easy (there will be losers) nor simple (it's a complex system). However, most of what we hear are the voices of very, very, very rich and powerful oil industries trying to muddy the waters. And lets be clear: they will be the losers, if the rest of us have any hope of not either having to bear terrible austerity or the horrors of climate change. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rebound_effect_(conservation) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rebound_effect_(conservation) [1] https://www.forbes.com/sites/michaelshellenberger/2019/02/05/if-saving-the-climate-requires-making-energy-so-expensive-why-is-french-electricity-so-cheap/#1312eaa41bd9 https://www.forbes.com/sites/michaelshellenberger/2019/02/05... [2] https://www.npr.org/2020/09/11/897692090/how-big-oil-misled-the-public-into-believing-plastic-would-be-recycled https://www.npr.org/2020/09/11/897692090/how-big-oil-misled-... [3] https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/tobacco-and-oil-industries-used-same-researchers-to-sway-public1/ https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/tobacco-and-oil-i...
- specialist 6y ago"However, most of what we hear are the voices of very, very, very rich and powerful oil industries trying to muddy the waters." I'm shocked, shocked by your suggestion that bad actors would conduct disinformation campaigns to discredit and neutralize inconvenient truths.
- closeparen 6y ago>scale back our lifestyle Low-carbon-footprint urban lifestyle doesn't feel "scaled back." If anything it feels scaled up, intense, high maintenance, premium. Something for wild and rambunctious twenty-somethings. It leaves people yearning to settle down in "the simple life" with a big lawn, a big SUV, and a big steak on the grill.
- vk5tu 6y agoIt feels pretty much the same, except there's no second car. The first problem is that housing stock takes a lot of modification to get to modern energy usage (essentially, 0 joules after construction). We haven't started down that road in any serious way as a society, even though the technology is commercial and past early-adopter pricing. But living in that house, it's no different to living in any other nice house -- a McMansion has a big reception hall, my passive solar house has a airlock/mudroom -- that's not a difference in lifestyle, just in detail. The second problem is transport. At a personal level this might mean EVs, except that they are so very expensive. You might afford to replace one of the family's cars, but not all of them. Public transport would appear to be an alternative, but if you don't have access to that already, then the build time for that is over a decade. So there's going to be an uncomfortable interim of, say, twenty years. Which I suspect will be filled with bikes and e-bikes, as adding bike lanes and bikeways are minor projects. There are times when your description of personal transport as "scaled up" is very true. There are many small annoyances from being slightly ahead of the bulk of the population. But one of the things Covid-19 has done has been to make local government is far more open to change: they've flipped from sending me letters about my vegetable garden in my front yard, to asking me if I'd be happy for their staff to tour it and collect ideas.