9 ms·
Of course. The only reason to doubt climate change is if you've been a victim of the concerted misinformation campaign. The campaign that was launched by the s
by epistasis 6y ago
Of course.
The only reason to doubt climate change is if you've been a victim of the concerted misinformation campaign. The campaign that was launched by the same spin doctors that launched tobacco companies' disinformation campaigns.
They were very clear on how they did this, and it's been amply documented in the media, just not super well known still, somehow.
They tied climate change denial to a political identity, because politics is how we turn off the rational part of our brain and activate the tribal defense mechanisms. Get your tribe to attack media vehemently anytime climate change is in the media. It makes news editors very nervous about covering the topic, because of the extremely virulent attacks. Even to this day, the media avoids bringing up climate change on relevant topics because they are scared of political blowback. This is the sort of "political correctness" that ends up harming society greatly.
- RankingMember 6y agoI think this lack of awareness or straight up apathy is just another example of the dearth of "attention energy" available to the average person today. When there's so much vying for peoples' attention on a daily basis, stimulating a concerted response (e.g. political will) is much more difficult. I'm not sure how we solve this at this point, because I don't see it naturally getting better.
- danhak 6y agoMedia is complicit in this, not the victim. By presenting "both sides" equally in many contexts, they give the false impression that the case of the denialists is equally strong. Just because there are two sides does not mean there are two equally valid sides. And presenting them as such is a form of bias. Quite a pernicious one. This is common practice in all sorts of stories. Journalists are trained to solicit / include some counterpoint or naysaying voice, no matter the topic. Even if the story is otherwise uncontroversial.
- macspoofing 6y ago>By presenting "both sides" equally in many contexts This was the mantra of the new atheist/skeptic movement of the early 2010s - that it wasn't worth to present the other side because the other side is just wrong. Given how this mantra is applied today where 'the other side' should not be heard from or platformed or is just plain evil, I'd rather hear both sides, even if that means I get to hear about creationism or climate change denial. I don't want the media or tech companies to be the arbiter on what is and isn't reasonable to discuss. Having Jack Dorsey or some intern at some fact check org decide for me what is and isn't reasonable is much worse than merely hearing from a creationist why creationism should be taught in science class.
- mrlala 6y agoI mean, do you propose equal time be given to evolution & creationism then or what? I would rather students spend 99.9% of the time on evolution and yeah I guess you can spend the 0.1% time as footnote of what crazy people believe in if you really want.
- macspoofing 6y ago>I mean, do you propose equal time be given to evolution & creationism then or what? I support journalists making an effort to present both sides even if one side is unreasonable, because the alternative is they just decide for me what I should and should not be exposed to. That, to me, is much much worse.
- danhak 6y agoIs there any place you draw the line? Should 9/11 truthers be given equal time? Holocaust deniers? QAnon / Pizzagate conspiracists? Obama birthers?
- macspoofing 6y ago>Should we give them equal time? Why not? The standard I advocate for is for journalists to make an effort to present both sides. There will always be a level of editorializing and they will get it wrong from time to time, but at least they are committed to the principle and there is underlying respect for the audience to make up their own mind. Not like what you seem to advocating for - where you want the media to make the decisions for you to what you're exposed to .. because god forbid the media 'platforms' someone that may actually change your mind. So let me ask you because I am curious: What is your limiting principle? At what point do YOU stop delegating to some doofus anchor what you should and shouldn't be exposed to?
- regularfry 6y agoIt's never "both sides" unless someone's actively trying to push a wedge issue for political gain. It's almost always "lots of varied ways to be wrong, and one way we're pretty sure is right" and if you try to present them all, the one that's right gets drowned out in the volume of dross. Journalism must be curation or there's no point.
- laurent92 6y agoI used to believe in climate change, then I studied feminism in depth. I don’t believe in climate change anymore. I’ve learnt 3 things: - It is possible to fake studies and blatantly ignore one side of the problem. I don’t count anymore how many studies claim that mostly women are victims of violence, and when you dive into the paper, you notice the study has been done by studying a panel of... girls mostly, and the scientist didn’t even care enough to weigh the results. This kind of extremely major problem is in all papers that conclude violence is one-sided, and those that include both genders (with seriousness, not males from prison vs women from workplace, as I have also seen) find equal violence from both genders. - It is possible to get these papers peer reviewed, and to scale these peer reviews enough that an entire scientific field is dedicated in find proof that a hypothesis is right while never studying the opposite. In fact, a chapter of Mein Kampf passed a journal’s gatekeeping, of course after replacing « Jew » with « male ». I have been pointed to decent papers that studied genders, but they are quite rare in the domain, if you just sample from the general pool, all have incredible flaws for scientists. - No-one applies the scientific method. It is possible to do such bad journalism as to persuade an entire country that the wage gap is 25 to 30% and that it is the effect of a conspiration against women, even though everyone can notice around them that most men would defend women even if they were wrong. The real % is generally written at the bottom of the article, in the paragraph before conclusion, so nobody reads it and the masses rest persuaded of a wrong figure. It is possible to fake an entire domain of science and have real scientists, public-domain people, governments, doctors, journalists and masses to say the same, false, verifiably false, thing, and literally beat any dissenting opinion until they shut up. The funny thing is everyone can notice around them how many fighters are ready to help protect women, so that would at least tip off that figures don’t match reality. As a result, I had to reassess « science for the masses ». Things I’m being told by journalists that « are certain » (« It is proven: Women are more clever than men ») can be verifiably false and would still be published nationally (the source of the article about women being more clever was a scientific paper finding an upside in one category, weighing it against error distribution, and signing off with « Therefore, it is not possible to determine whether one gender is better at task type X than the other »). If anyone wants to try this experience, try becoming expert in a domain that is in the news, and check whether scientists account for basic facts when they find « results ». I’m sorry, it may be possible that climate change is real, it is just that we have no proof of it, except by people who also claim the feminist science is true. As such, people ask me to « believe in » climate change, and blindly trust data coming from government-paid studies that also find blatantly erroneous data about genders. And this, people, is what it costs to push false narratives.
- tomp 6y agoI don’t think “both sides” is the only issue... Another is also the politization of issues... if you first argue against climate change, and then you argue against meat because of climate change, then I know you’re just using it to push your preferred ideology. How can I be sure you’re also not pushing climate change itself just as ideology? Note: I agree that less meat is a solution (or part of a solution), but unacceptable to push it as the solution, instead of e.g. general carbon taxation...
- FooBarBizBazz 6y agoThey also give the false impression that the number of sides is equal to two.
- bigman434 6y agoMost climate change activists also have tied being for climate change to a political identity. Their solutions to fixing the problem of green house gasses in the atmosphere call for wholesale changes to the current political and cultural system used in the West. If the only goal of the climate change activists was to get CO2 ppm in the atmosphere back to 300, then they should be just advocating for a carbon tax that ratchets down greenhouse gas emissions fairly quickly. Instead many of them are advocating the elimination of capitalism, free markets, and the patriarchy.
- triceratops 6y agoSo? Just work with them on a carbon tax instead of denying the problem. A lot of these "activists" would happily take a revenue-neutral carbon tax that returns money to people via UBI. They don't have a snowball's chance of achieving all that other stuff so who cares? Denying climate change is also tied to a political identity.
- dantheman 6y agoWhy a carbon text, why UBI? Why do these same activists also campaign against nuclear power?
- triceratops 6y agoI'm assuming you meant "carbon tax"? Why? Because it's the most elegant way of putting a price on emissions. Why UBI? It redistributes the tax collected from high emitters (likely to be higher income) to low-emitters (likely to be lower income) so progressives like it. It keeps the tax revenue neutral and doesn't allow the government to expand so conservatives like it. > Why do these same activists also campaign against nuclear power? Because of the long history of cost overruns, waste disposal and management issues, and the fear of a minuscule chance of catastrophic failure (not saying this last one is a rational fear). Why fixate on nuclear power whenever climate change comes up? Why not institute a carbon tax and leave the rest to the market? Some countries (France, India, the UK) love nuclear power, and others (US, Japan, Germany) are not so hot on it. If they all have carbon taxes, each country can figure out for itself what it wants to do, and collectively embargo/tariff countries that don't have a carbon tax. It's weird that a lot of people's default position is "I won't do anything for climate change unless we get nuclear power." Almost like they know there's very little chance of the national opinion about nuclear power changing very soon, so that gives them an "out" on taking any other action.
- JackFr 6y agoThis is very different than the tobacco companies. It was known anecdotally for a hundred years that smoking was unhealthy, despite a very widespread cultural acceptance of it. The evidence was overwhelming to anyone with ears and eyes who knew lifetime smokers. The tobacco companies went so far as paying cardiologists to invent the so called 'Type A' personality to explain excess heart attacks among smokers. Climate change on the other hand is much more subtle. The greenhouse effect is not an obvious on its face, one typically needs to be taught about it in school. Additionally, the natural variation both in weather and climate obscure effects. And the difficulty in measuring global historic temperature series and modelling climate needed to be invented over the past couple of decades. It may seem obvious to many people today, but that's more than likely because they grew up in an environment of scientific consensus. What's funny in the original article, is the the first paper cited, was GM sponsored research to indicate that the particulate pollution (aerosols) couldn't be causing the growth in polar ice caps because aerosols would have a warming effect. The true irony here is that this wasn't a warning about warming, it was sponsored research showing that GM wasn't responsible for cooling which had been observed. (Please note -- I am not claiming that there was ever a consensus about a 'global cooling threat', there wasn't. There was a limited concern that aerosols could have this effect, and luckily GM research was able to step in and show them how those fears were misguided.)
- splitrocket 6y agoThe same goons that peddled the pseudoscience that tobacco was safe are the ones that tried to convince the world that climate change wasn't real. https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/tobacco-and-oil-industries-used-same-researchers-to-sway-public1/ https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/tobacco-and-oil-i...
- googthrowaway42 6y ago> The only reason to doubt climate change is if you've been a victim of the concerted misinformation campaign. Nobody doubts climate change because the climate has and always will be changing.
- Fauntleroy 6y agoThey made a term to satisfy pedants like yourself. Just replace "climate change" with "anthropogenic climate change" when you see it in the news, and you'll be right as rain.
- googthrowaway42 6y agoThey adopted this term for the same reason all authoritarians play Orwellian games with language.
- Fauntleroy 6y agoOof. Isn't it about time for you to delete this throwaway account?
- googthrowaway42 6y agoTypical NPC response
- roenxi 6y agoI can see how it would be comforting to have a villain, but I don't think that is true. Companies deeply linked to the petroleum industry argued against action (as, of course, would be expected). But the basic pitch of the environmentalists has never been acceptable. The idea that we should curtail the comfort of the present population in a speculative attempt to do something in 50 years is unpopular. And in total seriousness, it is rare I've heard an articulation of what that something is vs the alternative. The options I heard were we scale back our lifestyle so our children can scale back theirs, with the alternative of we don't scale back our lifestyle and then our children scale back theirs. The environmentalist movement has avoided: * Pushing overpopulation into the political conversation (we've roughly doubled the global population since 50 years ago. The new arrivals are largely people in dire need of better energy access). We have a lot more talks about banning coal than pushing for a 1 child policy in Africa. * Nuclear energy. Pointing out the obvious, the most successful climate change initiative in the past 50 years has been the energy grid in France. Pro-climate-action has generally correlated with anti-nuclear. * Talking seriously about the costs or implementation strategy. As I recall, people were saying solar was a cheap option when Germany launched their Energiewende. They now have the most expensive power in Europe. The best argument historically for ignoring climate change has been that its supporters don't seem to be taking it seriously; they ignored a bunch of contributing factors or picked solutions based on political beliefs rather than trying to support cheap clean energy for everyone. GM and Ford are not responsible for that.
- throwaway6734 6y agoTo start, implement a carbon tax and more appropriately cost current goods. let people prioritize what things they find important
- roenxi 6y agoOk, but do you think there needed to be a misinformation campaign led by devious ne'er-do-wells to make raising taxes unpopular? That is a mechanism to achieve the goals of the environmental movement. Not a reason to achieve the goals of the environmentalists, or an argument that it is the best path.
- m463 6y agoIt's unfortunate that there are no meaningful visual effects to climate change. As an example, California took action to clean up tailpipe emissions because people could SEE smog. And you can say something meaningful like "1 gallon of gasoline creates 20 pounds of CO2" but since CO2 is colorless and odorless nobody really gets it.
- bamboozled 6y ago> The only reason to doubt climate change is if you've been a victim of the concerted misinformation campaign. The campaign that was launched by the same spin doctors that launched tobacco companies' disinformation campaigns. It's also incredibly distressing to think about what the future will look like, why wouldn't people want to put their head in the sand? When I hear the average person deny climate change, I feel it's more to do with being afraid. At this point people look for something to validate their doubt, which is why misinformation works so well, it's convenient to believe in nonsense. If you told people that climate change was actually beneficial to them, they'd be more likely to want to believe it. In fact this what some political figure heads are doing. I think most people are in shock at this point that it's become real. Especially people who have been deniers for the last 20-30 years.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- notmadnomad 6y ago"Victim?" There are also willing participants. Extending Upton Sinclair's quote: It is difficult to get someone to understand something when their salary, lifestyle, beliefs, or opinions depends upon them not understanding it. Millions of Americans are addicted to their muscle cars, SUVs, BigMacs, steaks, Costco, highly energy-intensive disposable consumer goods, and worldwide jet-setting vacations.