2 ms·
"This time it's different" comments are always suspect, but there's a reason to think it is different this time -- though in the opposite direction of TFA. The
by jfengel 6y ago
"This time it's different" comments are always suspect, but there's a reason to think it is different this time -- though in the opposite direction of TFA.
The closest thing to "permanent" in American politics is the Supreme Court, and it belongs to one party for the rest of my lifetime. The Supreme Court's power is indirect, but it's absolute: the Constitution means what they say it means.
And that makes them the final say in who gets elected. They can nearly always find a reading of the Constitution as a fig leaf for the outcome they want.
That includes determining who will choose their successors. They don't usually apply that indiscriminately, but as of now there's no reason not to. There is no appeal.
Eventually the demographics may change who makes up the party. But as a matter of partisanship, the opposition is now irrelevant. Even if they have a short-term win next week, it won't suffice to change the permanent nature of the composition of the Supreme Court. It's different this time because there's no adaptation that can suffice to overcome that thumb on the scale of every future decision.