3 ms·
It's time we started separating actions that are illegal from those which violate company policy. Illegal actions should be dealt with by the police and the co
by londons_explore 6y ago
It's time we started separating actions that are illegal from those which violate company policy.
Illegal actions should be dealt with by the police and the courts. Apart from providing evidence, the company should stay out of things.
Company policy violations should be dealt with by the company as they see fit, including no punishment at all, or even a bonus!
In this case, the article criticizes the company for not sufficiently punishing people for their actions, when clearly it's a matter for law enforcement not the company.
- henriquez 6y agoDevil’s advocate, what about this conduct was criminal? It seems abhorrent to me, but most likely a civil matter.
- markstos 6y agoIn the United States, sexual harrassment is illegal. https://www.eeoc.gov/sexual-harassment https://www.eeoc.gov/sexual-harassment The parent wasn't claiming it definitely was, so much as expressing that the police and courts are appropriate parties to determine the legality, beyond what actions the company itself may take for violating internal policies.
- jahewson 6y agounlawful != illegal
- henriquez 6y agoSexual harassment is illegal, but the conduct described here doesn't sound _criminal._ The police are only relevant when it comes to enforcing criminal law. Workplace discrimination policies are typically enforced under the authority of a state or federal regulatory agency with _civil_ penalties (aka. getting sued into next Sunday). Many people see how problematic it is to increase the surface area of police enforcement, which carries the threat of physical violence. Is it really necessary to resolve workplace disputes with armed state agents?
- meheleventyone 6y agoIllegal actions are normally company policy violations as well though.
- argomo 6y agoThe average HR department is highly motivated to avoid lawsuits of this kind. Police departments, by contrast, have no liability if they get it wrong. Officers themselves are disproportionately male and have traditional/regressive upbringings (as demonstrated by the high prevalence of domestic abuse against officer spouses). Then too, we must consider the rights of the accused. Simply being arrested can be a huge life-altering event. Being docked pay or fired is more proportional to the size of the infraction. And society needs a gradient of responses: not every offense should consumer the resources of the police and the courts... that simply doesn't scale, and it's not a humane solution.
- zajio1am 6y agoFrom rights of the accused point it seems that handling these issues by police seems much better, as criminal justice have established rules to protect accused (e.g. including 'beyond a reasonable doubt' evidence level) that seems to be lacking in these extrajudicional punishments.
- argomo 6y agoI see your point, but we aren't talking criminal behavior here with criminal consequences and criminal standards of proof. Businesses can decide you are a liability and/or reputational risk without a jury.
- zajio1am 6y agoDepend on jurisdiction. In many countries there is no at-will employment and you need a legally valid reason and procedure to terminate someone's employment.
- dragonwriter 6y ago> llegal actions should be dealt with by the police and the courts. Apart from providing evidence, the company should stay out of things. Illegal actions often violate company policy. Indeed, there are often legal mandates that company policies must also effectively address illegal conduct or else the company will be liable for the conduct.
- jmull 6y agoThere’s no clear separating line, though. Generally, illegal things done while on the job or representing the company are also against company policy. I’m not sure how it could possibly be different. Companies should be able to develop policies about things that affect their business and employees, which obviously includes illegal behavior.