8 ms·
Tumblr "Disappears" Microsoft's Danah Boyd
- qq66 16y agoSeems pretty dumb for a "social media consulting company" to get on the bad side of a social media poster child.
- zethraeus 16y agoI'm really surprised they've managed to beat her in google ranking.
- achompas 16y agoWhy? They're a social media consultancy. They must be familiar with SEO.
- zethraeus 16y agobecause she really has content and they are relative nobodies. maybe i'm just not cynical enough when it comes to the effectiveness of SEO.
- pero 16y agoNot when I search for 'Zephoria'. .org (her site) has the first 6 spots; .com (them) has the next 4; and then it's her twitter and flickr accounts.
- atacrawl 16y agoThe sad part of this is that it won't matter in the least. If frequent outages don't keep people away, this certainly won't.
- wccrawford 16y agoYou may have your priorities backwards. An assault on human dignity is far worse than frequent outages, especially for a free service.
- larrik 16y agoI don't know about that. Outages don't really hurt your "cool factor" so much, whereas bending over for corporations (and thereby looking corporate yourself) really does.
- turbodog 16y agoUm, no. These people were disappeared: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rettig_Report http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rettig_Report Apparently her blog was only moved. Inconvenient, yes. Gross human rights violation, no. See also: comparing yourself to Rosa Parks.
- ZoFreX 16y agoAbsolutely agreed. What Tumblr did was rotten, but we live in an age where people are genuinely disappeared on a daily basis, and we've even had posts to HN regarding missing persons. It's very misleading to use the word to mean something different given the amount of proper usage it receives.
- jsavimbi 16y agoYeah, but, if you're a very important social media researcher who has important information to disseminate to your followers in order to justify your own very importance, then anything short of "Tumblr disappeared me…" isn't going to generate the same outrage, and publicity, that Xeni Jardin did when she tried to erase Violet Blue's posts from BoingBoing. "Erase posts" being the conventional and operating phrase. So don't blame her; it's the social media-generated apathy.
- ZoFreX 16y agoNo, I will blame her. Of course lying and exaggerating will generate more outrage, that's exactly what I meant by my claim of "linkbait". She could have generated more outrage by saying that Tumblr raped her, but I do not believe the ends (generating outrage) justify the means (being misleading).
- jsavimbi 16y agoI was being sarcastic if reference for not blaming her. For a person who markets themselves as a preeminent scholar on all things social, it seems odd that the only times I hear about her is when she's over-dramatizing some issue related to her personal interests or herself. Again, this person has never created anything, held down a job that required results or contributed anything aside from opinion and self-centered promotion to any discourse. She reads about what others do in order to pass judgement and when people, or in this case Tumblr, doesn't take her seriously, she whines. I expect more reports of violations from this source in the future.
- jdp23 16y agoTitle fix: she spells her name danah Boyd (lower-case letters)
- zethraeus 16y agob :)
- michaelcampbell 16y agoAnd titles are typically capitalized.
- petercooper 16y agoThanks for letting me know but I'm not planning to change it - though a moderator is welcome to, if they're reading this. There's no semantic difference between upper and lower case in a proper name and I suspect more people would complain I'd typoed or got the name wrong if I corrected it to the "right" version. It's like transliterating the French "é" to a US English "e"; technically erroneous, but a better fit for Anglophones.
- jdp23 16y agoTrue, there's no semantic difference between spelling somebody's name correctly and incorrectly. It's "just" a matter of respect.
- quinndupont 16y agoWOW, that's radical. Next up, she'll add a "/" to her blog name, and we'll all remember that it isn't 1985 any more.
- wccrawford 16y agoIt's sad to me that companies get priority for names, even when people have had the names for years before the company existed. If she really was using their name improperly, Tumblr would have been within their rights... But they STILL should have contacted her first and let her try to explain. Yanking it out from under her and selling it to someone else is just rude at best, and criminal at worst. (I'm assuming they sold it... If they didn't, they're dumber than I think. This kind of BS isn't worth it unless they get something from it.)
- jaysonelliot 16y agoI've been mired in the vagaries of trademark law for a few weeks now, and based on my limited knowledge, there is no legal reason that a company with the trademark Zephoria would be able to prevent her from also using that name, if she were able to show that she had used it since 1998. Part of obtaining a trademark is doing due diligence and finding out how the name is being used in public. That includes use that isn't trademarked, but is publicly visible. This is a different matter, since it's about a username on a private service, but the principle still holds. Danah has no legal recourse in this instance, but it does show that Tumblr is acting hastily and, in my view, improperly, by just yanking her account away from her without notice, appeal, or recourse.
- warfangle 16y agoUsername and public URL. That's probably why Zephoria went after it so aggressively.
- protomyth 16y agoAlso, isn't trademark restricted to an "area"? I would think it wouldn't be out of the realm of possibilities for two companies to want the same username with trademark claims to back both.
- petercooper 16y agoYes, but then it'd be a deliberation between two holders rather than one holder and a non-holder. I'm surprised there aren't many famous 'double' trademarks. The only one that springs to mind is Jif, the lemon juice, and Jif, the kitchen cleaner which were both household names in the UK. The kitchen cleaner renamed to Cif as part of a global brand realignment, though.
- AndrewWarner 16y agoAnother reminder that we should all just get our own domains. Using a subdomain of another company is always risky and it's bad branding.
- Raphael 16y agoIn fact, Tumblr lets you use your own domain. She could use tumblr.zephoria.org and Zephoria Inc. could use tumblr.zephoria.com. Everyone wins!
- msy 16y agoAnother case of "if you're not paying for it, don't expect shit"
- teaspoon 16y agoThere's an ongoing Twitter thread between danah and David Karp: http://bettween.com/davidkarp/zephoria http://bettween.com/davidkarp/zephoria
- kmfrk 16y ago"@davidkarp I wrote back to your team & CCed you. What I want is my acct name back. I'd be happy to help you improve your notifying processes" That's the best combination of kindness and passive aggressiveness I've seen in years.
- sdizdar 16y agoI understand frustration but Zephoria is trademarked from 2002. http://www.trademarkia.com/zephoria-78132833.html http://www.trademarkia.com/zephoria-78132833.html So my question is following: when trademark should be enforced and when not? If a company X is an internet consulting company and somebody has a blog talking about internet using the same name, is that trademark infringement? Does Tumblr (or any blog operator) need to contact user to explain if they get Demand Letter from lawyer representing the trademark owner and Tumblr's legal department determines it is valid? I'm not trying to defend anybody but just want to understand how trademark can be enforced.
- TillE 16y agoTrademarks are inherently limited in scope. If I'm making widgets named FOO, and I've registered that trademark, I have no inherent right to FOO.com or @FOO or anything else that's completely general and may have nothing to do with widgets. http://www.chillingeffects.org/domain/faq.cgi http://www.chillingeffects.org/domain/faq.cgi > Of course, you aren?t expected to look up trademark registrations around the world or research legal issues like common law trademark rights. That?s why the Policy requires the trademark owner (the complainant) to prove bad faith and why the Policy offers domain name holders the opportunity to demonstrate that they have rights or legitimate interests in the domain name.
- teaspoon 16y agoThat's true regarding infringement, but trademark dilution can apply to uses that aren't in competition with or relevant to the trademark holder. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Federal_Trademark_Dilution_Act http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Federal_Trademark_Dilution_Act
- elehack 16y agoThe really difficult thing is that, while in many cases the demand letters are legitimate and appropriate, in some cases like this they aren't. If Zephoria sued danah for trademark infringement, I would certainly hope they would lose since danah can probably prove that she's been using the pseudonym since 1998, 4 years before their trademark issued.
- zalew 16y agoIt's a lame move from both tumblr and the company zephoria. Here I'd like to ask if anoyone heard of twitter stealing one's username? I was once very surprised finding that http://twitter.com/#!/bmw http://twitter.com/#!/bmw is used by some guy, while the company uses other twitter accounts http://twitter.com/#!/search/users/bmw http://twitter.com/#!/search/users/bmw and I wonder if they even tried to get the username.
- mc32 16y agoWhile I can feel some sympathy, I can't feel outrage. It's not outrageous. They did not delete the content -they moved it (at first she complained about losing her data, then retrenched to complaining about broken links -so what was the real problem? She does not own the URL, the site operator does. She made assumptions which proved untrue. The result of such is unfortunate and inconvenient. It's worthy of a rant of displeasure with how they reach name collision resolution -but it's hardly an affront to the person. That is to question the "disappeared me" harking to military summary executions of actual physical people? (not online handle). If anything, that's an outrage in itself. A delusion(?) of importance. I think it's basically a problem of disconnect in expectations. TL;DR. My data was deleted -I'm upset. Oh, wait, it wasn't; It was moved. I'm pissed anyway.
- msravi 16y agoSo if gmail or yahoo or hotmail or whatever, suddenly decided that your username is trademarked and "moved" your email, without notifying you or giving you a chance to contest the trademark infringement, you'd be ok with it? You'd sympathize with yourself but wouldn't be outraged with their actions?
- mc32 16y agoI could only expect what they outline in their TOSes. However, that said, mail is different in that mixing signals (email intended for me going into a mailbox now under control of someone else) might leave them open to liability, depending on what kind of information could be compromised). So, I don't think that would be a valid comparison. Look, her basic argument was her data (content) was lost, then, learning it wasn't, revised the complaint to, my links are broken. That's moving the goalpost. That was my main point.
- mc32 16y agoCorrect me if I'm wrong, but trademark law does not come into the picture here at all. It's a name collision. Resolution of such are generally relegated to site operator. No one is claiming she's infringing on their trademark, as far as I know.
- mmaunder 16y agoWelcome to The Cloud. We have an internal policy that determines what is OK to store in the cloud and what we store on internal servers. e.g. sensitive strategic docs don't get put on Google Docs. All customer service emails stay on internal servers and aren't outsourced to cloud providers. Our mission critical servers are our own hardware, but we use cloud providers for non-critical services.
- citadrianne 16y agoSome more context on this: http://www.betabeat.com/2011/04/27/tumblr-gave-danah-boyds-username-to-a-marketing-company/ http://www.betabeat.com/2011/04/27/tumblr-gave-danah-boyds-u...
- _pius 16y agoPeter, could you fix the headline? Her name is lower case. http://www.danah.org/name.html http://www.danah.org/name.html
- nitrogen 16y agoIf The Headline Is In Title Case, is it still appropriate to use lowercase letters for her name?
- quinndupont 16y agoIf you are pretentious, then yes.
- _pius 16y agoIt's her name ... she gets to decide how it's spelled.
- nitrogen 16y agoNaturally. I'm just wondering if there's a convention for capitalization of lower-case names in a location (such as a title) where any other word would have been capitalized.
- _pius 16y agoI'm curious too actually ... my response wasn't criticizing your question.
- michaelcampbell 16y agoSure. That doesn't make it not pretentious, however.
- kmfrk 16y agoOf course it is. It's a proper name. Are we going to capitalize the "i"s in Apple products? I can only assume that's her actual name, as unusual as it is. But a proper name is a proper name.
- johncoltrane 16y agoIf I remember well, there has been at least one precedent involving a music publication called pitchfork. Like two years ago. Tumblr just seized the URL and I think the matter was histerically handled by a crazy girl at Tumblr. Here, in France we had a David Vs Goliath situation years ago: an old woman called Milka who had a microscopic sewing/retouching business had to fight Milka/Kraft's bigwig lawyers for her milka.fr domain name. http://fr.wikipedia.org/wiki/Milka_contre_Kraft_Foods http://fr.wikipedia.org/wiki/Milka_contre_Kraft_Foods
- jw84 16y agoTumblr has done this multiple times in the past, justified or not. Last year I picked up mediaite.tumblr.com and within 2 weeks it was taken from me and given back to Mediaite. Gawker got me to shutdown a feed-reblog tumblr. I was never notified. What Tubmlr fails to do is notifying their users of making drastic changes to account information. If giving them benefit of doubt I wager it's because they're a still a small team supporting a huge community. If blaming them then it's likely just them being arrogant and not giving a fuck. I opt for the former but feel better about the latter.
- js2 16y ago"Change your blogs name. Not that big of a deal."
- rkon 16y agoDid this marketing company forget what happened to Cook's Source when they screwed with the little people? The internet doesn't respond kindly to that type of bullying: http://techland.time.com/2010/11/17/cooks-source-magazine-controversy-episode-3-the-editor-strikes-back/ http://techland.time.com/2010/11/17/cooks-source-magazine-co...
- brendano 16y agoThe question of historical precedent is interesting. In her post she says she's been using "zephoria" personally since 1998; Wayback Machine shows a zephoria.org landing page in 2002 and a full website in 2003. And she had a public profile even back then (There was an NYT article ... wow, in 2003). The trademark apparently was from 2002, but hypothetically, had it been a few years later, would having the same name as the handle and personal domain of a (mildly) well-known person be relevant for a decision to grant a trademark?
- bad_user 16y agoIf you want a blog -- just buy your own domain, use a service that you can replicate yourself in case you need to (e.g. Wordpress or plain HTML, using a plain web server -- GitHub Pages is free of charge ;)) ; and do monthly backups of everything (the storage of an entire blog on S3, Dropbox, or heck, GitHub, is cheap). Personally I'm using GitHub pages, on my own domain, using a commenting system simpler than Disqus, but that I'm hosting on a free GAE account. Wordpress with regular dumps is also appropriate. My blog is not popular, but I like feeling in control. I'm surprised that people haven't seen this coming with services like Tumblr.
- wdewind 16y agoS3 could do the exact same thing tumblr just did (though for different reasons, granted). This is the risk of the cloud in general (or really of outsourcing ANY labor in general) and is not isolated to tumblr etc. More a question of where you draw the line in terms of price/risk.
- bad_user 16y agoThe problem is that Tumblr is a freemium, and most users are not Tumblr's customers, but rather their product. By using S3, you are Amazon's customer. And my whole point is not that you should host it yourself, but rather that you should use services which makes it easy for you to migrate, in case shit happens. Setting up a Wordpress blog is trivial, lots of alternative providers other than Wordpress.com are available, doing backups from time to time is also trivial, and if you own your own domain, restoring your blog can be done in only a couple of hours tops. The only reason to use something like Tumblr (IMHO) is the ease of setup (that becomes painful once you want to customize), and the social aspects of it -- but nothing stops you from automatically sending all your links to be posted under your Facebook/Twitter account; and you can give users the option to comment under their Facebook/Twitter ID -- as long as you keep the comments / the articles / the domain, I don't see a problem there.
- r00fus 16y agoI think there's a place where "freemium" is the right fit... if you have non-essential content, or don't spend much time or effort on your web properties, it's probably an ok thing. Once you have anything worth backing up/restoring, you should start paying for what you use, because being a customer means something (http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1684732 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1684732 ... "If you're not paying, you're the product"). There are those who can't pay, and for that reason I do think it's good to fight this kind of blatant identity-theft. Still a lesson: If you can afford it and if you have anything of worth on someone else's servers, you should be paying for that privilege.
- sudonim 16y agoFound the old site in the google cache: http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:c9cda-O7YsMJ:zephoria.tumblr.com/+zephoria&cd=11&hl=en&ct=clnk&gl=us&source=www.google.com http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:c9cda-O... Last post was in January, but she wasn't squatting by any means.
- quinndupont 16y agoGood riddance. Her vacuous posts, a step above a "social ninja/guru" need not tarnish the fact that she somehow managed to get a PhD, by making the revelation that Myspace is old, Facebook is new.
- m0hit 16y agoI don't matter. But - goodbye tumblr.
- shawndrost 16y agoTumblr renames almost-dead [0] account after notifying user [1] and not hearing back. When she complains, they give it back [0]. What assholes. Can I flag this? I'm flagging this. [0] Last post Jan 21; 5 posts since Sept '10. http://zephoria.tumblr.com/ http://zephoria.tumblr.com/ [1] http://twitter.com/#!/davidkarp/status/63313370283122688 http://twitter.com/#!/davidkarp/status/63313370283122688
- kmfrk 16y agoThey e-mailed her on Passover and gave her 72 hours to reply[1]. Assholes in my book. [1]: http://www.zephoria.org/thoughts/archives/2011/04/27/tumblr-disappeared-me.html http://www.zephoria.org/thoughts/archives/2011/04/27/tumblr-...
- gammarator 16y agoupdate: Tumblr has now restored boyd's account name: http://www.zephoria.org/thoughts/archives/2011/04/27/tumblr-disappeared-me.html http://www.zephoria.org/thoughts/archives/2011/04/27/tumblr-...
- domador 16y agoI've written an article about this particular situation: http://www.hashcollisions.com/2011/04/a-solomonic-response-to-username-disputes/ http://www.hashcollisions.com/2011/04/a-solomonic-response-t...