3 ms·
Sure, we all want the right to repair, but don't we realize that easily repairable devices could add as much as 1 to 2 mm of thickness to our phones? Sure, my
by ineedasername 6y ago
Sure, we all want the right to repair, but don't we realize that easily repairable devices could add as much as 1 to 2 mm of thickness to our phones? Sure, my Galaxy Note 2 had a replaceable battery and a shattered screen the local repair shop could fix for $50, but I paid for that with more than 0.5mm in additional device thickness than my current phone.
- munk-a 6y agoIt's amusing - I like light laptops but at this point I'd prefer an artificially deep case just so they could get some key-travel back in. For portability of a laptop the width really isn't a consideration... For phones and tablets ditto.
- com2kid 6y agoWant things to change? Stop having reviewers point out that extra couple mm as being a "glaring design flaw" or comment on "how extra chunky" the phone is. FWIW rugged, durable, battery replaceable devices have repeatedly failed on the market. Notably, Motorola tried, and failed. Everyone bought Samsungs.
- breakingcups 6y agoAlright, I'll do that..? With all the influence I have on this worlds' reviewers.
- com2kid 6y agoMy point is that device manufacturers are responding to the pressures they are given. And it isn't like there are very many phone reviewers for any given market. If someone wanted to organize a letter writing campaign to try and convince the top 5 or 10 phone reviewers to just not mention device thickness that just might have an effect. (On the flip side reviewers complained about the removal of the headphone jack and that didn't help any so...) The other thing to remember is that with modern battery charging tech, batteries can last a long time. Samsung is the best in this regard, their chargers are really smart and work hard to preserve battery life.
- glhaynes 6y agoI certainly don't have numbers to back it up but I'd guess WAY more purchase (or not) decisions come from holding phones in hands rather than reviewers complaining about a phone being too thick.
- CogitoCogito 6y ago"Right to repair" isn't really a universally fixed idea in its details, but one interpretation could be that a company needs to provide access to spare parts and documents to support repair by unaffiliated 3rd parties. That would not necessarily mean that the company would need to make their devices easily repairable (by for example making batteries replaceable), but instead require the companies to support unaffiliated 3rd parties in their repairing endeavors similarly to how they would do it internally. In a scheme like this, there would be nothing standing in the way of continuing to make thin devices. That said, I do personally wish there were some sort of "minimum repairability" that would potentially put limits on how thin something can be if that made repair much more difficult, but that's a bit of a side-issue to "right to repair" for me.