2 ms·
The last time this appeared on HN [1], this chart was (rightfully) called out for being unsourced, garbage data. This chart continues to be unsourced, garbage
by vkou 6y ago
The last time this appeared on HN [1], this chart was (rightfully) called out for being unsourced, garbage data.
This chart continues to be unsourced, garbage data. Look at the source for it - it is this spreadsheet. [2][3]
The primary source for all of China's figures in that spreadsheet is this [3][4] puff piece.
Now, the astute reader will notice something strange with this data. Somehow, the primary source [3][4] for the spreadsheet claims that camera/capita in China is similar to the rest of the world - yet, for some reason, the spreadsheet - and the subsequent article claims that all the major Chinese cities have an order of magnitude more cameras than the rest of the world.
Garbage in, garbage out. The methodology for gathering the per-city statistics was wildly inconsistent (There is incredibly obvious undercounting[3] happening for nearly every datapoint that's not in China), and the end product is completely worthless - unless you are, of course, using it to reinforce pre-existing biases.
[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20737023 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20737023
[2] https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1I-WpH2KOiguKy9JTQ9zC2JxBBhH2scdbSRI8lJVjzdo/edit#gid=979494433 https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1I-WpH2KOiguKy9JTQ9zC...
[3] You can tell this spreadsheet is utter garbage, by looking at the entry for NYC in it. It claims that NYC has 31,490 cameras in it. I've visited NYC twice, and I've probably walked past more cameras than that in the ten days I was there.
[4] https://www.360kuai.com/pc/9d0f97d8eb6ea1d8f?cota=3&kuai_so=1&sign=360_7bc3b157#ch=youlike https://www.360kuai.com/pc/9d0f97d8eb6ea1d8f?cota=3&kuai_so=...
- kmlx 6y agothis comment should be at the top.