3 ms·
This is such a red herring. I've got a Galaxy S4 here that is bricked with a bootloop, due a software error on the emmc chip. I know this is the case, because s
by mindslight 6y ago
This is such a red herring. I've got a Galaxy S4 here that is bricked with a bootloop, due a software error on the emmc chip. I know this is the case, because someone has done the painstaking work of investigating the bug on the S3, and hacking up a reverse engineered fix. I'm guessing it would take a week to retrace their steps on my model. Meanwhile if these devices were well documented by the manufacturers, it would be an easy no-solder repair.
Given both the complexity and the shoddy engineering of modern software/firmware, I wouldn't be surprised if the majority of "hardware" problems are similar.
- jojobas 6y agoWhat is a red herring? It's just not perceived by the public to be an issue. If it was, it would be legislated just like car manufacturers are forced to carry parts for a number of years for every produced car.
- mindslight 6y agoThe narrative that "razor thin" devices preclude repair. If I had the manufacturer's documentation, the problem with my S4 could likely be fixed with just a USB cable. Its physical form has nothing to do with its general lack of repairability.
- jojobas 6y agoThey don't preclude repair but definitely make it harder to make modular, user serviceable devices. Software repair is a different story of course, but it's another double-edged sword- you wouldn't like your phone's memory to be fully accessible with just a USB cable. I can't imagine a mechanism that would only allow USB tampering only if the phone is malfunctioning.
- freeone3000 6y agoYour phone's memory effectively is fully accessible with just a USB cable. I am unaware of any android phone which actually verifies the signature on its bootloader - run `adb fastboot flash` and you can load arbitrary ROMs onto arbitrary chips. The contents of the ROMs is what's secret.
- jiggunjer 6y agoYou'll need more than a USB cable if you've bricked it, even fastboot won't be accessible.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- Nextgrid 6y ago> you wouldn't like your phone's memory to be fully accessible with just a USB cable Use cryptographic authentication then, with a password/key provided to you when you buy the phone?
- pettycashstash2 6y agoOn the topic of bricking, I had my $250 amazon kindle display the dreaded battery with exclamation mark a day after warranty expired. Coincidence? I contacted amazon and was kindly informed that there are no authrized repair facilities and amazon does not fix it. Was offered $5 to return it and 15% discount. Had to do a bit of research online but it turns out one can take it apart. I disconnected battery and reconnected it and it started charging again. I’m not a conspiracy theorist but this felt like amazon would software brick the device so I would buy new one due to timing of warranty. Disconnecting battery literally reset device. Anyone experience this?