3 ms·
Subjectively, the presence of food or drink implies a concern for your physiological wellbeing. Since it was not a defined contractual element of the exchange,
by ggm 6y ago
Subjectively, the presence of food or drink implies a concern for your physiological wellbeing. Since it was not a defined contractual element of the exchange, it also represents a bonus, an above-and-beyond.
It would be interesting to have tested this during the time of fidget spinners or some other tchotchke, to remove the food element but that aside, I think a weakly confirming result would be confirming what we expect: signs of care and emotional engagement beyond the immediately neccessary improve mood, and so improve some outcomes.
There is a saying that positive reinforcement beats negative reinforcement but it comes with an implicit corollary: negative reinforcement beats nothing: That negative pupil teacher interaction reports exist with higher scores should not be surprising, because it is possible SOME people achieved higher scores, despite hating (and negatively rating) their teacher.
- srtjstjsj 6y ago> corollary: negative reinforcement beats nothing That's a separate claim not a corollary. In fact, all else unknown, positive beats negative is suggestive that negative is worse than neutral, which might be better than positive.
- ggm 6y agogood point. I vote to be in the cookie set, not the electric jolt set testing this one.
- polm23 6y agoIt seems the full paper makes it clearer that 1. cookies were only provided in one session 2. there was no effect on grades / learning outcomes despite a change in evaluations https://twitter.com/emollick/status/1318737313497812996 https://twitter.com/emollick/status/1318737313497812996