5 ms·
Those of you who think locking the account was a good idea should remember you won’t always be in the majority.
by tomcam 6y ago
Those of you who think locking the account was a good idea should remember you won’t always be in the majority.
- AnimalMuppet 6y agoOr on the side that Twitter thinks is the good side.
- wow_yes 6y agoWe are on the right side of history - progress always is. People like me are much more trustworthy because we're not motivated by greed, but for the desire for a better world.
- jaywalk 6y ago"My idea of progress will always be correct, because I am a good person and people who disagree with me are not."
- dcolkitt 6y agoHistory has no shortage of horrific atrocities carried out by people with a genuine desire to remake a better world.
- brynjolf 6y agoAnd vice versa, the side that has been Conservative continue to be on the wrong side of history over abs over again, yet never fail to say the other side is to blame. Gay rights Women rights Liberty Always one side saying let's wait a bit longer, let's listen to our lies for a bit longer.
- vanattab 6y agoYou might want to look up which party was more supportive of the 19th amendment and check which party supported ending slavery. "On May 21, 1919, the amendment passed the House 304 to 89, with 42 votes more than was necessary. On June 4, 1919, it was brought before the Senate and, after Southern Democrats abandoned a filibuster, 36 Republican Senators were joined by 20 Democrats to pass the amendment with 56 yeas, 25 nays, and 14 not voting."
- yarabarla 6y agoWhile not a one to one match with current politics, the parties largely swapped demographics and southern Republicans today would have been Democrats at that time. See: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Southern_strategy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Southern_strategy
- rabbitXIII 6y agoI don't think they mentioned a party anywhere in the parent comment. They were simply talking about the conservative vs progressive side of a debate or policy change
- vanattab 6y agoAround the same time as the 19th amendment was passed. Eugenics was a very "progressive idea"
- BurningFrog 6y agoCounterexample: Conservatives opposed Communism.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- breakfastduck 6y agoYou seem very certain of that, which is incredibly frightening.
- yjftsjthsd-h 6y agoOn my first read, I assumed that they forgot to type the /s, but I think you're right and this was meant to be serious, which is... disconcerting.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- devthrowawy 6y agoIs that a quote from Hitler? I honestly can't tell.
- awerawerawrjhui 6y agoEvery tyrant and dictator in history thought he was on the side of "progess" and was building a better world.
- AnimalMuppet 6y agoSome really thought they were. And some said they were, even if they didn't really believe it.
- adamnew123456 6y agoI'm going to take a stab and say this is meant satirically? Are we invoking Poe's law here?
- MuffinFlavored 6y agoIf you had to put it into numbers, how would you say the user base of HackerNews breaks down in terms of right-leaning versus left-leaning? I think that's where it all stems from. If you lean right, you don't want to see this level of censorship. If you don't, you're fine with it because it's pretty much exclusively in the direction of Trump.
- RIMR 6y agoIf you think locking the account was a political decision, you're paranoid and wrong. They broke the rules on publishing hacked materials. They openly did this despite the rules. You want them exempted from the rules on political grounds, which is a problem.
- tomschlick 6y ago"hacked materials" but according to the story the laptop was now the property of the shop owner after Hunter Biden allegedly left it for service without paying and never came to pick it up. Most of those kinds of shops have a 90ish day policy that you sign and after that its theirs. That would not be hacked material. Also, if the policy on hacked material was enforced; wouldn't the NYT story on the tax returns hacked/leaked from Trump also apply? Most of the controversy here is that Twitter has selectively taken action, and now that they changed their policy, they still wont reactivate the account even though its no longer in violation until the NYP deletes the original violating tweet.
- pnw_hazor 6y agoBut there is no evidence anything was hacked.
- awerawerawrjhui 6y agoSuch nonsense. Everyone knows that if someone published "hacked" materials which were damaging to Trump then Twitter would laugh you out of the room if you suggested they block it. This article has been suppressed for one reason and one reason alone: because it's potentially damaging to Joe Biden's election campaign. I know it, you know it, Twitter knows, everybody else knows, so stop pretending that this is about anything else because no-one is fooled.
- mantap 6y agoDo you think that fake news websites (websites that intentionally post falsehoods to drive traffic) should be allowed to post on social media with impunity? How is that workable? Many people cannot distinguish fake news from legitimate sources of information. Increasing noise (disinformation) is just as damaging to free speech as decreasing the signal (censorship).
- koolba 6y ago> Do you think that fake news websites (websites that intentionally post falsehoods to drive traffic) should be allowed to post on social media with impunity? Unless it's directly inciting violence, yes. > How is that workable? Many people cannot distinguish fake news from legitimate sources of information. The track record of restricting information from people because you feel like you're smarter than they are is not great. It's also impractically subjective. > Increasing noise (disinformation) is just as damaging to free speech as decreasing the signal (censorship). I consider your suggestion of encouraging clamping down on free speech too dangerous to discuss. By your logic should I be able to prevent you from expressing it?
- philipkglass 6y agoUnless it's directly inciting violence, yes. By this standard, Facebook must allow everything that you can find on Pornhub and Liveleak. Plus much of the material published in Al Qaeda's magazine Inspire. Telling people "crusaders should die" and "here's how to make a bomb from over the counter materials" aren't direct incitements to violence. Reddit could never have banned r/WatchPeopleDie or r/jailbait. (Although it could be hard to spot any actual jailbait in r/jailbait once torrents of MLM schemes and cryptocurrency scams flood every subreddit.) The First Amendment protects a lot. That's why back in 2014/2015 American legislators who were unhappy with Islamist terrorist propaganda circulating on social media called on social media companies to do something instead of passing a law. A law that says "it's illegal to publish photos of dead Americans or their allies with gloating commentary" wouldn't survive the First Amendment. But social platforms could and did deplatform groups cheering for ISIS, to bipartisan approval. You may sincerely believe that only direct incitements to violence should be suppressed on social media. I don't think that there is legislative support for that state of affairs, though. Not even among the conservative legislators who are currently the most critical of social media moderation decisions. If legislators managed to pass a law that said "social media platforms cannot suppress anything that is legal to publish under the First Amendment," I think that they would regret that choice a month after seeing the consequences.
- rat87 6y agoLocking the account was the right thing to do Also I don't know why you think people on the left think big companies are on their side We know they're not. And that they unfairly censor liberal stories. https://www.nbcnews.com/tech/tech-news/sensitive-claims-bias-facebook-relaxed-misinformation-rules-conservative-pages-n1236182 https://www.nbcnews.com/tech/tech-news/sensitive-claims-bias... But for once they seem to be trying to do the right thing, and avoid spreading propoganda