3 ms·
1) I believe your "top 5 highest taxing states" is inaccurate. In 2000, at least, California ranked 19th in combined state + local tax burden according to the U
by scarmig 16y ago
1) I believe your "top 5 highest taxing states" is inaccurate. In 2000, at least, California ranked 19th in combined state + local tax burden according to the U.S. Census Bureau, which is decidedly middle of the pack. Pretending like we're the most highly taxed state in the country is deceptive and gives the impression that good governance (well, bad in our case) comes for free.
Note that though the ranking of 19th does factor in our larger economy, it doesn't account for the reality that more highly advanced economies require a better trained and more specialized bureaucracy. So just as we shouldn't be surprised when Sweden has a better compensated civil service than Namibia, all things being equal we should expect for California government to account for a larger portion of the economy than Mississippi's or Oklahoma's, instead of being in the middle of the pack.
2) The Economist is left-leaning? Heh.
3) Most technocrats, be they left or right, absolutely hate the 40% rule as well. As a Democrat, I'd gladly trade a repeal of Prop 98 for a repeal of Prop 13. Hell, I'd repeal Prop 98 just on its own.
Government by ballot box is terrible.
- hugh3 16y agoI believe your "top 5 highest taxing states" is inaccurate. In 2000, at least, California ranked 19th in combined state + local tax burden according to the U.S. Census Bureau, which is decidedly middle of the pack. Is that burden in dollars-per-capita or burden in percentage-of-GDP? Since California has a higher GDP per capita than most states you could both be right. * Note that though the ranking of 19th does factor in our larger economy, it doesn't account for the reality that more highly advanced economies require a better trained and more specialized bureaucracy. So just as we shouldn't be surprised when Sweden has a better compensated civil service than Namibia, all things being equal we should expect for California government to account for a larger portion of the economy than Mississippi's or Oklahoma's* Sweden vs Namibia ain't exactly California vs Oklahoma. In particular, Oklahoma's state government provides pretty much exactly the same services as California's... it just provides them much cheaper. The point remains, I think, that it's fairly disingenuous when folks (almost always folks whose own personal ox is unlikely to be gored in this case) suggest that Prop 19 is responsible for the California budget woes. California's state government is rolling in money, it's just that they're incredibly bad at spending it.
- anamax 16y ago> Most technocrats, be they left or right, absolutely hate the 40% rule as well Since technocrats hate any restrictions on their power.... Technocrats have had small successes but in the large they've been a disaster. > Government by ballot box is terrible. It's better than the alternatives.
- anamax 16y ago> In 2000, at least, California ranked 19th in combined state + local tax burden according to the U.S. Census Bureau http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/State_tax_levels_in_the_United_States http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/State_tax_levels_in_the_United_... says that CA is 11th on a per-capita basis. However, Alaska (which is number 1) gets almost all of its tax revenue from folks who buy oil, most of whom are in other states/countries. IIRC, Wyoming, #4, is similar. I don't recall whether CT and DE, #5 and #7, get a lot of their revenue from corporate francise fees, which are also (effectively) paid by folks in other places.
- scarmig 16y agoIn state level taxation. State and local taxation and spending, however, are highly coupled, and looking at state level taxation in isolation can be misleading. Especially in the case of California, where local property tax rates were made artificially low, and as a result state income tax and sales tax artificially high.
- TomOfTTB 16y ago1) Actually I was wrong in that I meant to type 9 instead of 5 (I didn't reach high enough on my number pad). I got the number from here: http://www.statemaster.com/graph/eco_tot_tax_bur-total-tax-burden-per-capita http://www.statemaster.com/graph/eco_tot_tax_bur-total-tax-b... 2) The Economist calls itself a "Classical Liberal Newspaper" in their advertisements. Beyond that they endorsed Obama, Kerry, and Clinton (and it may go back further those are only the ones I could get off a quick Google Search) 3) But would you trade it if Republicans had a majority? It's easy to want to abolish a 2/3rd requirement when your party has the majority. But in my experience all things are cyclical (California voted for Republican Presidents until 1992 so it isn't that far fetched)