4 ms·
Unlike California (37 million), http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Direct_democracy http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Direct_democracy is more suitable for smaller nations
by known 16y ago
Unlike California (37 million), http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Direct_democracy http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Direct_democracy is more suitable for smaller nations like Switzerland (7 million)
- pnathan 16y agoOne thing I've often thought - but never investigated to test - is that governing at scale requires different policies and approaches than governing at 'small'. What always brings it to mind is the oft-cited success of the Scandinavian states on welfare, as compared with the USA.
- anamax 16y ago> What always brings it to mind is the oft-cited success of the Scandinavian states on welfare, as compared with the USA. Size isn't the only difference - the US is far more diverse. Compare Sweden http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Demographics_of_Sweden http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Demographics_of_Sweden with LA http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Demographics_of_Los_Angeles http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Demographics_of_Los_Angeles . Sweden is about as diverse as Wisconsin http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Madison,_Wisconsin#Demographics http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Madison,_Wisconsin#Demographics .
- scarmig 16y agoImagine a world where California were 4 or 5 separate states. Mendocino to Santa Cruz, including the Bay Area, as one; LA and Ventura as another; San Diego and the Inland Empire as a third; Central Valley, Shasta, etc. as the 4th. Probably would improve governance, as the Republican Party we deal with in the Bay Area would offer people like Tom Campbell instead of Prop 8 NOMers.
- hugh3 16y agoI've always thought that the problem with America is too many states, which allows effective one-party states to develop. In Australia there's only six states, and they're all large and demographically diverse enough to be (in the American terminology) purple. That means that there's a regular cycle of kicking the bums out and installing the other set of bums every few election cycles, keeping things relatively healthy. In the US, though, problems seem to develop when one party controls the legislature more or less indefinitely. In blue states this leads to slowly-collapsing economies where public-sector unions slowly suck increasing amounts of money out of the economy, and in perma-red states this leads to zany places where sodomy is theoretically illegal and you can't even buy a vibrator. So what we really need to do is join California up with Nevada, Arizona, Idaho... maybe even as far as West Texas.
- omouse 16y agoWhat you've pointed out are problems with large governments in general. Australia still has a lot of problems and when you have larger states that means the law applies to more people. Even if the majority of people are in favour of a law, they're still forcing the minority to abide by their choices and that's pretty much mob rule. On the flip side, if there's fewer people voting in elections, a minority of voters can force the rest of the people in the state to be represented by some jerkoff politician.
- evgen 16y agoAustralia has about 2/3 the population of California, 2/3 the economy of California, is far less diverse than California and yet six seems a healthy number of sub-divisions for Australia while California should be merged in with other states? That makes no sense at all.
- hugh3 16y agoI think there are many cultural reasons why these things tend to work out okay in Switzerland but not so much in other countries. Swiss people are (and yes, I'm about to overgeneralize about an entire country here, but I'm pretty sure it's true en massse) fairly mature and responsible people, keenly aware and extremely protective of the uniqueness of their country.
- omouse 16y agoWhy not have more direct democracy at the local level and make it so that initiatives don't apply to the entire state? Split things up into smaller regions that are closer to the size of Switzerland :)