6 ms·
The trainings I'm familiar with have the opposite intent: to help people who don't believe they are racists (or believe racism doesn't exist) understand the unc
by shadowgovt 6y ago
The trainings I'm familiar with have the opposite intent: to help people who don't believe they are racists (or believe racism doesn't exist) understand the unconscious mental processes that feed into racism and the nature of structural discrimination, even when unintended.
- kofejnik 6y ago> understand the unconscious mental processes that feed into racism and the nature of structural discrimination, even when unintended. I wonder how scientific this understanding is
- shadowgovt 6y agoUCSF has a useful overview on the topic. https://diversity.ucsf.edu/resources/state-science-unconscious-bias https://diversity.ucsf.edu/resources/state-science-unconscio...
- tomp 6y agoQuite biased. At least the Wikipedia page includes a Criticism section. Also, as with most psychology, the prior should be that all these studies are a result of p-hacking and publication bias (i.e. that the effect is actually noise). https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Implicit-association_test#Criticism_and_controversy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Implicit-association_test#Crit... Also pretty obvious biased cherry picking on that page. Counterexample: Women preferred 2:1 over men for STEM faculty positions https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9372481 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9372481
- shadowgovt 6y agoI don't see how the provided counterexample is a counterexample. It appears to indicate unconscious bias favoring women in STEM faculty positions for hiring.
- srtjstjsj 6y agoNo evidence is given about whether the bias is unconscious.
- shadowgovt 6y agoI believe it can be inferred that it's not conscious, because if women were actually being hired intentionally at a 2 to 1 ratio, that would be an obvious violation of law against gender discrimination.
- kofejnik 6y agoDoing "X" intentionally would be illegal, therefore it could be inferred that whoever did "X" wasn't doing it consciously.
- nec4b 6y agoExactly what the Chinese government says about Uighur reeducation centers. They only want to help them to understand the unconscious mental processes that feed,...
- SuoDuanDao 6y agoHow is that not the same as forcing people to stay in an unpleasant class until they confess to racism?
- shadowgovt 6y agoI believe the fact some people perceive it to be is the root of, perhaps, quite a bit of consternation on the issue. But I see it is the same as forcing people to stay in an unpleasant class until they understand type theory. We teach people things they need to know so that they know them, because knowledge is useful. We're certainly not calling the question of "having education seminars" into question, are we?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- SuoDuanDao 6y agoBut the 'knowledge is useful' stance presupposes that these classes have value, that what they're teaching is actually true or useful. That's precisely what many of us don't believe. Suppose we were discussing a risk management seminar which you had reason to believe was teaching a flawed methodology, one likely to cause serious harm if widely adopted. Would you be similarly sanguine in that case?
- shadowgovt 6y ago> That's precisely what many of us don't believe. With respect, I'll defer to the career sociologists and psychologists on the topic, much as I'd defer to the risk management PhD on the topic of risk management. I've known too many tech-savvy folk who think humans can be reduced and deconstructed like a computer, declare humanities research bunk because it doesn't fit their mental model, and get profoundly surprised when their mental model doesn't fit actual human behavior. The psychologists and sociologists have a better track record on modeling and predicting human behavior.
- 6y ago
- rayiner 6y agoWe have been teaching people about unconscious bias for years without these theatrics.
- shadowgovt 6y agoHow well has that worked?
- rayiner 6y agoPretty much every civil rights victory that has been achieved had been done through appeal to universal principles. People in America really don’t understand what the alternative is like. Academic theater seems workable, or at least harmless at best so long as we’re standing on solid bedrock. But that’s a framework that exists so long as you maintain it. What society really looks like absent this framework is what happened in Iraq after in 2005. The first time people voted, they did so strictly along ethnic lines and then tried to annihilate each other. Or in my home country where we went to war to separate ourselves from people who had the same skin color and same religion, but spoke a different language. The United States is the most successful multi-ethnic democracy in the world. For example, while Muslim immigrants to the US achieved economic parity within a generation or two, in countries like France they’re facing multi-generational poverty. We are not perfect. While we have successfully integrated (socially and economically) wave after wave of immigrants. We are doing it again right now—income mobility among Hispanic people is similar to white such that within a few generations incomes for these groups converge. Our persistent failure has been our inability to fix the legacy of our shameful history of slavery, segregation, and Indian removal. But nobody else has figured out how to do that either. In countries like the UK, the Black-white income gap is just as large as in the US. The gap in maternal mortality rates is even larger. And in most of the rest of Europe, it’s not even legal to keep statistics about these disparities. Maybe some professors have figured out a better replacement for our universal values that will work better—one that replaced a broad, shared commitment to equality with individual white people admitting complicity in perpetuating systemic racism. But they probably didn’t.
- shadowgovt 6y ago
- StanislavPetrov 6y ago>The trainings I'm familiar with have the opposite intent The person who ties you to a stake and burns you alive to cleanse the devil from you can sincerely intend to save your soul, but what they are doing is still horrible. Intent is vastly overrated.