5 ms·
I think the writing is on the wall for completely djfferent reasons: 1-Lack of funding and development progress. After 24 years, they're still not even close
by jqpabc123 6y ago
I think the writing is on the wall for completely djfferent reasons:
1-Lack of funding and development progress. After 24 years, they're still not even close to version 1.0.
2-Microsoft is working toward Windows being freely available (zero cost). This dampens the motivation for an open source alternative.
3-Drivers for the latest hardware will always be an issue due to #1 above.
- geogra4 6y agoI think really the use case is to run in a VM to handle old code and keep security up to date. I wouldn't want to run it on bare hardware for that reason (3)
- Koshkin 6y agoWell, security is a whole another kettle of fish. I'd be wondering how secure ReactOS is (or can ever be).
- Frenchgeek 6y agoAt the very least ReactOS makes for a good test suite for Wine...
- jqpabc123 6y agoOld code? Do you need to run 16 bit code under Win64? There are solutions for this. Here are a couple: https://github.com/otya128/winevdm https://github.com/otya128/winevdm https://www.dosbox.com/information.php?page=0 https://www.dosbox.com/information.php?page=0
- flyinghamster 6y ago> Microsoft is working toward Windows being freely available (zero cost). I don't see that happening anytime soon, other than the usual "hidden in the price of the machine" way it's usually handled. Not to mention, it would inevitably be tied to a cloud account at the price of your privacy, and your risk of being "deplatformed" from your own machines for doing something that Microsoft (or Hollywood, or one of their AIs) doesn't like. I'd love for ReactOS to succeed, but they're up against a constantly-moving target.
- geogra4 6y ago>I'd love for ReactOS to succeed, but they're up against a constantly-moving target. I don't think they are - my understanding is that it's primarily focused on Win98-type compatibility
- OJFord 6y agoServer2003
- jqpabc123 6y agoI don't see that happening anytime soon... Today, you can download, install and use Win10 for free (zero cost) from Microsoft's web site. https://beebom.com/get-windows-10-key-free-cheap/ https://beebom.com/get-windows-10-key-free-cheap/
- coolspot 6y agoYeah, method 1 describes how to get unactivated copy that you can’t legally use for anything other than evaluation.
- robmurrer 6y agoZero Cost with "Zero Privacy and Control"
- Jean-Philipe 6y ago> 2-Microsoft is working toward Windows being freely available (zero cost). This dampens the motivation for an open source alternative. Somehow I always thought, ReactOS had a use case in the Enterprise market, for companies that need an older version of Windows for existing and can't/don't want to upgrade to a newer one; maybe like HaikuOS? But I might be totally wrong on either.
- ch_123 6y agoBuying an old copy of Windows NT/2000/XP costs next to nothing on eBay, and you can be guaranteed that you get the platform that your legacy software was targeted for, and not a clone.
- Jean-Philipe 6y agoYou might want security patches and support. An old cop from ebay won't get you that.
- ptx 6y ago> Microsoft is working toward Windows being freely available (zero cost). Are they? I know they gave away free upgrades when they wanted more users for the Windows Store and UWP apps, but even then only upgrades, not free licenses. Currently, it seems the licensing of Windows is giving GitHub and Azure a huge competitive advantage over other CI and cloud hosting providers. Why would they give that up?
- FreakyT 6y agoAt least for consumers, you can install Windows 10, never give it a license key, and it will run forever with almost no restrictions. (IIRC you're blocked from changing your wallpaper, there's an occasional nag prompt, but that's it.)
- jqpabc123 6y agoAre they? Yes. You can download, install and use Windows 10 for free (zero cost) from Microsoft's web site. The only issue is you can't customize the user interface and there is a watermark telling you to "Activate Windows" Why would they give that up? Competition from "free software". And because the "huge advantage" you speak of is non-existent. Azure has more Linux instances running than Windows. OS licensing to individual users is no longer a significant profit source.
- ptx 6y agoThe huge advantage I was referring to is that no competitor can provide Windows instances without paying whatever price Microsoft sets and complying with whatever terms they set. They can make it infeasible to compete whenever they feel threatened. As for downloading and using Windows for free, sure you can, but it's not allowed to. Using Windows illegally has always been an option even if it's slightly easier now. If you're a business, Microsoft will sometimes audit you, so you can't rely on this approach. In any case, regardless of whether it's a good idea to use an unlicensed copy, where are you getting that they're working towards making in free?
- jqpabc123 6y ago
- snvzz 6y ago>The writing is on the wall Naysaying. ReactOS has been around for a long time and survived. And AIUI it is, now, more active than ever. There's not even a hint that now, of all times, it is going to go away.
- squarefoot 6y ago> 2-Microsoft is working toward Windows being freely available (zero cost). This dampens the motivation for an open source alternative. Zero cost and Open Source aren't mutually exclusive. I could make a wonderful and free (as in beer, ie zero cost) operating system, then fill it with telemetry and other routines phoning home that nobody but me could deactivate, let alone remove, because I'm the only entity having access to the sources. Or, I could give public access to some sources, but prevent any modification+redistribution behind threats of legal action. That's not freedom at all. Microsoft could reverse the OS cost by sticking a $1000 check to any Windows DVD, that is paying users to install it, but that wouldn't make it a bit more open or more trustworthy. That's why we refer to our software of choice as FOSS: Free and Open Source Software, which is software that is free as in beer and free as in speech and open. Should someone manage to put suspicious code into FOSS software, its free and open nature allow the community to discover that malicious code and remove it, fork it if needed, without any fear for litigation, being blocked by restrictive licenses etc. I don't see Microsoft allowing that anytime soon with Windows or any other of their most important products.