10 ms·
He didn’t, but suppose my grandfather legally (or even semi-legally) disposed of some DDT and left my father some money. My father later me some money. What’s t
by sokoloff 6y ago
He didn’t, but suppose my grandfather legally (or even semi-legally) disposed of some DDT and left my father some money. My father later me some money. What’s the legal process to claw some of that money back to pay for the cleanup? Do you or the state have standing to sue me for something I never did, knew nothing about, and can’t reasonably answer to any specifics about?
- meed2000 6y agoSuing you to the extent of having to pay back whatever your father passed on to you, at least what's left of it would be reasonable, don't you think?
- sokoloff 6y agoNo, I do not. If my grandfather left my father $X, my father left me $Y, at the very most the maximum would have to be the lesser of $X and $Y, decremented by the full cost of answering the lawsuit. This is problematic from a variety of practical angles, though, not just mathematical ones. It seems like something the forensic accounting lobby would salivate over. Should I be forced to defend a lawsuit because my great^6 grandfather owned slaves? (As far as I know, none did.) That’s more abhorrent than legally dumping chemicals that today’s common sense says should have been done differently.
- dubcanada 6y agoBut if you grandfather lost all of $X, your father would not have any of $Y (based entirely on $X being an amount they got from business dealings and $Y being a smaller amount which came from $X).
- sokoloff 6y agoThat strikes me as non-sensical. My father had his own earning, creating, and saving abilities.
- pessimizer 6y agoSubtract it from what he would have earned if he had dumped the cash into an index fund, and we may find that his earning, creating and saving abilities were negative. His only profitable skill may have been having a father who dealt in slaves.
- dathinab 6y agoYes. The only think which could in anyway get close to legality would be to: - Legally hold a case against whoever did it and win it. (Can even legally have a case against a dead person?) This requires thinks to have been illegal when done. - Requiring that (likely dead) person to pay a fine based on existing law. - Arguing that whoever accepted an inheritance did inherit the fine, too. But as far as I know every point of this list has many legally questionable aspects. But what you MUST NOT do under any circumstances in a state of law is to not base judgement on law but arbitrary "I feel like this should be done" arguments. This is also why it's of upmost importance to fast adapt laws make them general instead of specific and not put any loop holes in them. Because then you can judge people to some degree even if they do something bad even if that specific think wasn't explicitly forbidden. (E.g. based on a generic law which makes any form of causing environmental damage in a context where it's reasonable to assume it the person should have been aware illegal. Sure you need some threshold, too. Else driving your care is illegal.)
- toast0 6y agoI'm sure you could have a civil case against a dead person's estate. Although, my understanding is it's legally and logistically challenging to reopen an estate after it has been settled. I don't see how you could have a criminal trail against a dead person in the US, without violating the sixth amendment. It would be impossible to inform the deceased of the charges, etc.
- darkcha0s 6y agoYes let us just start collective punishment, because we have such a justice boner. Jesus christ, sometimes HN has some wild opinions. Just to be absolutely clear -- it's not reasonable, and what you're suggesting is literally how North Korea handles crime. "Oh but you know here it's different" -- you're setting a precedent which, if allowed, would mean your family members could face jail time for crimes YOU commit.
- CJefferson 6y agoNo-one is talking about putting people in jail, but also (in my opinion), someone shouldn't get to inherit millions of dollars just because their grandfather committed some terrible crime -- inheritance should not be a right, when the original money was acquired illegally.
- macspoofing 6y ago>No-one is talking about putting people in jail, but also (in my opinion) Every law, no matter how small and well-meaning, has implicit threat of prison behind it. You can't be so naïve as to believe that this enforcement action won't result in prison for some, destroyed lives for others, and because laws and enforcement are man-made, there's also a guarantee that your dragnet will punish some innocents, and let some guilty go (maybe because they can afford great lawyers and/or bribes). And of course, because this would be a very controversial measure, it would be highly politicized.
- pessimizer 6y ago> Every law, no matter how small and well-meaning, has implicit threat of prison behind it. If someone doesn't comply with the court, but that would be a crime committed by the child, not the parent.
- eesmith 6y agoWhy do people keep making this claim? There are plenty of laws which don't have an implicit threat of prison behind it. Here's one: https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/4/1 https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/4/1 . Quoting Wikipedia: "This is a U.S. federal law, but only suggests voluntary customs for handling of the American flag and was never intended to be enforceable. The code uses non-binding language like "should" and "custom" throughout and does not prescribe any penalties for failure to follow the guidelines." - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_Flag_Code https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_Flag_Code
- ByteJockey 6y agoNo. No I do not think that's reasonable. Having a period after death for the government to bring charges against the estate seems reasonable. We already have this, but I could see a reasonable person arguing to make it a longer period. I think it's unreasonable for the same reason getting rid of all statutes of limitations would be unreasonable. At some point, you have to let people stop looking over their shoulder. Society doesn't work very well when you incentivize people to dig up century old dirt on their enemies.
- charlesu 6y agoThis is a great argument for an absurdly high estate tax. You can’t inherit ill-gotten gains if you don’t inherit anything at all!
- ChrisLomont 6y agoSo punishment for everyone because someone, somewhere may have done something that decades later was made illegal? What kind of bizarre sadism is that?
- FDSGSG 6y agoWho does estate tax punish?
- throwaway0a5e 6y agoThe children of the people who managed to live out their days without going broke and becoming a burden on everyone else have less money than if their parents spent it all (presumably some of which would have been on them) and died with debt. The people who lived out their days without going broke lose because their property rights are being violated. Their property and their dollars that they have already paid taxes on should be theirs to give away as they see fit.
- pessimizer 6y agoNot being entitled to something no one else is entitled to either is not a punishment, otherwise it's a punishment to me when I can't have your dad's money. Children aren't even entitled to their parents money in adulthood. Parents have to choose to give it to them either explicitly or by omission.
- eesmith 6y agoIf that's punishment for the children of the rich, then those children born to parents who are broke must also live a punished life, yes? If you are against children being punished because of the economics of their parents, then surely you are in support for a strong social safety network for children (universal subsidized/free childcare, including meals, and healthcare), yes? Which requires taxation or other funding sources. Which means we must ponder things like: how much of Sam Walton's $100 million inheritance did his children need in order to not be punished by a higher inheritance tax? $5 million each?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- dusted 6y agoHave you noticed how we generally do not bear any responsible for the wrongs of our parents? For instance, we are not forced to pay their debts, yet, we're somehow entitled to any riches they may have left behind? Seems asymmetrical to me. I'd say, yeah, I guess if you accepted the money, you should accept at least some of the responsibility for how they were amassed.
- unishark 6y agoThe estate can be sued for debts. There is a time limit on filing claims though and there might be some limits on what they can come after in the sense they might be considered jointly-owned like a house if you're still living there.
- macspoofing 6y ago>yet, we're somehow entitled to any riches they may have left behind The kids of Bill Gates and Warren Buffet are getting a miniscule amount of their fathers' wealth - how is that possible if supposedly they have a right to it? So you have it all backwards. The descendent are not entitled to the wealth of their parents or ancestors. The right to property (including disbursement through inheritance) is given to those that own it! The dollar I earn, I can do as a please with and has already been taxed.
- bzbarsky 6y agoThis is very country-dependent. In a number of European countries, the children are in fact entitled to some minimal share of the wealth of their parents (in France this share is between 50 and 75%, depending on the number of children for example), and what Buffet and Gates are doing would be illegal, as I understand it.
- foobarian 6y agoI would not call 50-75% minimal :) Though I imagine you meant "minimum" - somewhat subtle difference.
- effingwewt 6y agoI'll do you one better. Suppose your forebears made the money illegally. Most certainly the ill-gotten gains must be clawed back. Are you seriously positing that you should keep illegally obtained money because you yourself didn't know? Punishment is another story, of course it wasn't your fault, so you won't do the time, but you certainly don't get to be rich off the proceeds of the crime. ie If I rob a bank and leave the money for my kids, they don't get to keep the money when the feds finally crack the case.