4 ms·
> any copying not either licensed or protected as fair use (which even the article here does not claim applies) is infringement. Not sure what you mean by this
by kelnos 6y ago
> any copying not either licensed or protected as fair use (which even the article here does not claim applies) is infringement.
Not sure what you mean by this, as the article does claim the use in the test suite is fair use.
> At best, youtube-dl’s test suite may be infringing works when run [...]. Even that argument is specious: Given output is discarded, no permanent copy is retained, and the action is for research and development, and numerous Fair Use affirmative defence claims exist under §107, notably (1) and (4), test suite execution falls outside exclusive rights.
Am I misunderstanding?
- dragonwriter 6y agoIt claims that a fair use defense exists and points to two of the four factors in fair use (mistakenly referring to them as separate claims). And, sure, that's an argument that Fair Use applies, which I missed, but is not an argument that this isn't a valid 512 notice. A valid 512 notice does not require actual infringement, it requires that the person the sending the notice have and assert a good-faith belief in infringement. While we can't explore the mind of the RIAA as to whether they have such a belief, they clearly have asserted that the tool exists for the express purpose of infringing their works such that knowingly distributing it would make the host liable for contributory infringement as well as making anti-circumvention claims. An assertion of non-infringement, whether based on fair use or anything else, is obviously a basis for a counter-notice, and also an argument to make if the RIAA actually sues the content provider after the takedown (without or without counter-notice based restoration) to the service provider.