3 ms·
Former lead developer Philipp Hagemeiste: These videos were never fully downloaded anyways; they are automated test cases where the test just downloads the fir
by dredmorbius 6y ago
Former lead developer Philipp Hagemeiste:
These videos were never fully downloaded anyways; they are automated test cases where the test just downloads the first 10KB, which amounts to a couple of seconds at most. This is certainly fair use.
https://news.perthchat.org/youtube-dl-removed-from-github/ https://news.perthchat.org/youtube-dl-removed-from-github/
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- cookiengineer 6y agoI know this is an unpopular opinion and I probably get downvoted for this. But I stand my ground that I think the assumption of fair use for this copyright circumventing algorithm is wrong. ------ First off: Fair Use does not exist. It is an assumption, not a defined situation as it requires legal evaluation in court to apply. And on top of that: It is a regional difference and is therefore completely unpredictable whether it applies or not. Assuming fair use on a platform with a proprietary license that even forbids downloading, while downloading proprietary content specifically to circumvent copyright protection, while fair use does only exist as a "possibibility" inside, and only inside, the US and only after a legal case was decided in at least state level court ... really? You get sued for downloading 512kB of porn illegaly, just as you can get sued for downloading 10kB of copyrighted youtube videos. As I said, this was just a suggestion to remove that attack surface. Another attack surface is the trademark violation, but that's a different case.
- dredmorbius 6y agoNotwithstanding the provisions of sections 106 and 106A, the fair use of a copyrighted work, including such use by reproduction in copies or phonorecords or by any other means specified by that section, for purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching (including multiple copies for classroom use), scholarship, or research, is not an infringement of copyright. In determining whether the use made of a work in any particular case is a fair use the factors to be considered shall include— ... -- 17 U.S. Code § 107 - Limitations on exclusive rights: Fair use https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/17/107 https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/17/107
- cookiengineer 6y agoHow can you prove that youtube dl is used specifically for, say, classroom purposes? Can you prove it? Probably not. Is circumventing a copyright mechanism an educational or journalistic purpose? In a testsuite? ... Even when siding with you, you would need a court case to evaluate whether fair use applies or not. Again, as I said, unnecessary attack surface. I don't care whether you or I am right or wrong. Nobody of us can be right unless a court case has been made. It's unnecessary and could have been prevented.
- dredmorbius 6y agoYou made a bald assertion that Fair Use does not exist, and is not law. U.S. Code demonstrates otherwise. You might wish to show the sportsmanship of admitting your previous error before embarking on further ones.
- cookiengineer 6y agoFair Use is a circumstancial definition in the law. It is not clearly defined and needs a court case in order to apply. Therefore I still think that the assumption of Fair Use to apply is wrong. However, the assumption of copyright to apply on the other hand is correct. But, referring to whether fair use exists or not, I agree with you that technically it exists. But as the rest of the very same law criminalizes by default, you can still not refer to fair use if you do not have the required-by-law evidence at hand for it to apply. I think that fair use is almost always nearly impossible to prove, that's why I wrote my statement like this. And I agree that it was worded badly.
- toast0 6y agoCopyright is certainly easier to interpret than fair use, but both rely on courts. If I claim you violated my copyright and you disagree, it will be determined in court. If I claim you violated my copyright and you claim it's fair use, and I disagree, it will be determined in court. What's the difference?
- 6y ago
- temprature 6y ago> First off: Fair Use does not exist. It is an assumption, not a defined situation or law. https://en.wikisource.org/wiki/Copyright_Act_of_1976#%C2%A7_107._Limitations_on_exclusive_rights:_Fair_use https://en.wikisource.org/wiki/Copyright_Act_of_1976#%C2%A7_... Further recommended reading: Lenz v. Universal Music Corp.
- GoblinSlayer 6y agoIs the problem with copyright or drm or they are the same thing?
- corobo 6y agoBut of course you're not saying the thing the hive mind wants to hear so now HN has made your comment barely readable
- pessimizer 6y agoIt's wonderful to have a hivemind that rejects factual misstatements. Fair use does exist, in law. It's the only reason we use that particular, awkward phrase. I agree that they should have stayed away from copyrighted material as if it were radioactive, but I'm not forced to support every bad argument that agrees with my conclusion.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- corobo 6y agoI was just commenting on how HN makes the text literally unreadable when you get downvoted enough
- dredmorbius 6y agoUniversal's sole textual argument is that fair use is not "authorized by the law" because it is an affirmative defense that excuses otherwise infringing conduct. Universal's interpretation is incorrect as it conflates two different concepts: an affirmative defense that is labeled as such due to the procedural posture of the case, and an affirmative defense that excuses impermissible conduct. Supreme Court precedent squarely supports the conclusion that 11331133 fair use does not fall into the latter camp: "[A]nyone who ... makes a fair use of the work is not an infringer of the copyright with respect to such use." Sony Corp. of Am. v. Universal City Studios, Inc., 464 U.S. 417, 433, 104 S.Ct. 774, 78 L.Ed.2d 574 (1984).* -- Lenz v. Universal Music Corp., 801 F. 3d 1126 - Court of Appeals, 9th Circuit 2015 https://scholar.google.com/scholar_case?case=12567649168680108221 https://scholar.google.com/scholar_case?case=125676491686801...
- thrownaway954 6y agono it's not. intent is also taken into account of fair use and the intent of those test cases is to make sure their program gets around a specific counter measures youtube as put into place so people cannot directly download the media and are forced to stream it. look... i love the project and everything, but philip is just plain in the wrong and doesn't want to admit it.
- dredmorbius 6y agoThe statement is relevant regards one of RIAA's three claims; that youtube-dl infringes RIAA member works in executing its test suite. That averred infringement is a specific claim. Though weak, it's the strongest specific claim RIAA makes. Hagemeister's comment establishes that minimal copying is performed in the testing itself, contrary to RIAA's claim. The infringement does not occur in the source code or test suite itself, it occurs inccidental to testing functionality of the software (that is, it is inherently functional, not expressive), the copies made fall within existing limitations to exclusive rights (§112, §117, §512(a) and (b)), and tests (1), (3), and (4) of §107 fair use. RIAA's standing on anti-circ §1201 is separate from this question, poorly justified, and likely lacks standing.
- thrownaway954 6y agodude... you just dug your own grave with your statement: "Hagemeister's comment establishes that minimal copying is performed..." bottom line... they are still downloading and copying the file, regardless of what for or how much which is exactly what the RIAA is claiming. you can cite whatever it is you want, the fact is that youtube-dl is DEAD wrong in what they are doing.
- soraminazuki 6y agoSince when did fair use mean "no copying at all?"
- thrownaway954 6y ago
- gamblor956 6y agoThe issue isn't how much of the music videos were downloaded during testing. That may or may not fair use. The issue is that they were testing the ability to download music videos in the first place, meaning that the tool was intended at least in part to download music videos subject to copyright.
- dredmorbius 6y agohttps://news.ycombinator.com/user?id=dredmorbius https://news.ycombinator.com/user?id=dredmorbius