3 ms·
If you believe there is inappropriate censorship by large tech platforms, this is still probably not the hill to die on over the issue. This is an unrepentant m
by ineedasername 6y ago
If you believe there is inappropriate censorship by large tech platforms, this is still probably not the hill to die on over the issue. This is an unrepentant member of a terrorist group who advocates the use of violence as the means to resolve political & religious disputes. [0] Freedom of Speech generally doesn't acknowledge advocacy of violence as a covered by that freedom.
[0] Some use words, some use arms and some use politics. Some use negotiations. I chose arms and I believe that taking up arms is one of the main tools to solve this conflict
- nullc 6y agoThis is San Francisco State University and New York University being censored. Would you also have zoom suppress a SFSU lecture discussing Mein Kampf? -- a book by a genocidal maniac? I think these events are making a good case that schools (and especially universities-- where people are expected to be able to engage with controversial or wrong-headed ideas) should not be using zoom.
- ars 6y ago> Would you also have zoom suppress a SFSU lecture discussing Mein Kampf? If the speaker agreed with Mein Kampf, and was promoting it, I'd have a very hard time criticizing zoom over it. Free speech is important, but this speaker can find her own tools to promote her terroristic ideas, zoom has no obligation to help her. > are expected to be able to engage with controversial or wrong-headed ideas That's a very charitable interpretation. And if in fact this was a forum to discuss ideas, with pro's and con's, I might agree. But this is simply giving a platform to a terrorist, there is no intellectual discussion going on here. The way you wrote "discussing Mein Kampf", you are implying they would actually be discussing it. But that's not what's going on here. It's kind of like a reverse strawman - you changed the event into a much less controversial one, and then told people they should criticize zoom for blocking it. But zoom didn't block your strawman, they blocked an actual terrorist.
- nullc 6y agoI don't know anything about the event but what was obvious in a glance at the parent article. How many orginizations should get a veto over events run by universities? Wouldn't you prefer to not run events using tools that have vetoed your decisions on appropriate materials and can be expected to do so in the future?
- srtjstjsj 6y agoThe US government gets a veto over the acts of its foreign military enemies. I don't see this as a Zoom issue. Have any other US-operating companies hosted this person?
- nullc 6y agoIf this were an action by the US government it would end up in court on first amendment grounds extremely quickly.
- ineedasername 6y agoNo, it was the speaker being blocked. If it was merely a lecture on the topic of this person, their organization & actions, then I would share your belief that it was censorship rather than an acceptable limit on Free Speech.
- srtjstjsj 6y agoIn the US we build giant monuments to people who not only advocates but who engaged in the use of violence as the means to resolve political disputes. We also put them on our money and name cities and states after them.
- 542354234235 6y ago> This is an unrepentant member of a terrorist group who advocates the use of violence as the means to resolve political & religious disputes. You might want to look up the violence against civilian targets that the government is using, which could be argued to be terroristic. We aren't exactly talking about someone using violence against someone else they disagree with. We are talking about about two groups using violence, one of which is vastly more powerful than the other.