4 ms·
I have basically no background in the subject, but I'd be interested in your perspectives if you feel like answering any of these questions: - What are the Uni
by thaumasiotes 6y ago
I have basically no background in the subject, but I'd be interested in your perspectives if you feel like answering any of these questions:
- What are the United States' goals with respect to Iran?
- What goals of Iran's are being hindered, objected to, or otherwise meddled with by the United States?
- In the end, dictators know that the Western block is finicky, unstable, and short-termish; This makes it so that high-pressure strategies do not work. Just to be sure I understand this, you're saying that because Western countries (Europe / the US) cannot maintain a consistent foreign policy, their targets (other countries) see the best strategy for dealing with moments of high pressure from the West as being "wait for the pressure to go away"?
- I do not know of a solution, frankly; Most of my peers see immigration as the only viable solution. Solution to what problem? Immigration of who, from where, to where?
Western democracies generally are very bad game-theoretic agents; They play repeated games as if they are oneshots.
I suspect term limits have a lot to do with this.
- fakedang 6y agoNot OP, not Iranian, but going by my Iranian friend, it's mostly as follows: - odd that you're asking an Iranian Qn#1. They don't know either - Iran wants to play a regional power in the Middle East, far greater than it is now. It is to be noted that many countries in the ME, such as the UAE, Qatar, Syria, Iraq, Lebanon and Bahrain have significant Shia minorities or majorities in some cases. When the Arab Spring happened, Iran actively encouraged protests within the Shia population to overthrow the monarchy in Bahrain, until the UAE and Saudi Arabia reacted. Even now, the UAE regularly arrests Shia folks it suspects of cavorting with Iran (a large part of the Arab population in the Emirates are descended from Persia). Not to mention, Iran invaded and expelled the local Arab population of a tiny island of one of the constituent Emirates of the UAE, before the country's formation and during the time of the Shah. Iran is quite the expansionist. - basically what Rouhani thinks. Wait until Biden gets into power, and hope that he's going to continue the Obama policy. This is not common among all dictators though - some want Trump to be in power, like the monarchs of the Arab states, since he's an Iran hawk. - a solution to Iran's repressive regime, duh. Iranians have been immigrating en masse for a long time to the US, Canada, UK and Europe. Anywhere there is a democracy. There are a ton of Americans, British, Europeans and Canadians who graduated from Sharif University of Technology, the equivalent of Iran's MIT. - not just term limits, but the need to "pander" to their constituencies. One decade, they warred in the Middle East, the next decade they want to leave the mess they created, but then commit more troops (Obama on Iraq)? It's definitely not like Russia or China or India (all of which are/were friendly with Iran) who have had a steady policy in the region of being on talking terms with everyone.
- gadders 6y agoIran is also a state sponsor of terrorism (Hezbollah, Hamas), wants nuclear weapons and would destroy Israel if they could.
- fakedang 6y agoWhich is just a part of playing the Middle Eastern powers game. The current five major powers in the region are Israel, Saudi Arabia, Qatar, UAE and Iran. Out of them, one is rumored to be a nuclear power, three are delayed nuclear powers, while all but one are state sponsors of terrorism directly, and the last one sponsors them indirectly. Two of them want Israel destroyed, one is openly allied to Israel and one is secretly allied to Israel. Yep, the Middle East is complicated.
- reducesuffering 6y agoSaudi Arabia is the open ally to Israel and UAE is the secret one?
- fakedang 6y agoYou got it the other way around - the UAE is the open ally, Saudi Arabia is the secret one. If you're wondering about the rest, Israel is the secret nuclear power, the UAE recently became a nuclear power (civilian purposes, of course :P), Iran is building up nuclear capability, and if it does, Saudi Arabia will just buy nukes off Pakistan since they funded the latter's nuclear programme.
- throwaway_pdp09 6y ago> Solution to what problem? Presumably, the 'oppressive' part of oppressive regime. Guy has my sympathies FWIW.
- Siira 6y ago1 & 2) I do not have any expert knowledge on this, and doing web searches will provide better answers. But I can tell you that the only point of contention that the people also care about is security. The middle-east is a warzone, and people rightly think they need some defenses. The regime goes about this with their (effective) tactics of starting/funding foreign terrorist/militia organizations, and their ballistic and nuclear programs. If the Western block could somehow satisfy this need for security, the regime’s bad actions will become a lot more unpopular. (Of course, the Western bloc can’t do that because they can’t promise anything durable. They also abandoned the Shah, which doesn’t set a reassuring precedent.) 3) Yes. Even compromising is made more dangerous; E.g., Obama definitely paid a risk premium in his deal. The Iranian side factored in the possibility of the US annulling the agreement when they agreed to it. Inconsistency in foreign policy sucks A LOT. 4) A solution to Iran being a shitty country to live in, and things getting worse almost every single year. I also meant a solution to Iran exporting shittiness to the world, but immigration doesn’t help with this part.