5 ms·
Um...I have close, personal, and intimate relationships with many people that suffer from mental illness, and have had this for decades. I do a lot of "extracu
by ChrisMarshallNY 6y ago
Um...I have close, personal, and intimate relationships with many people that suffer from mental illness, and have had this for decades.
I do a lot of "extracurricular" work, trying to help folks get back on their feet.
So, not academic. Personal.
> Because in the real world, the therapy method I have mostly seen, was and is keeping people calm with pills.
I consider that offensive. It's a fairly classic "strawman" argument that is used to "dehumanize" people that suffer from mental illness, and also dehumanize people trying to help them. I know many people that would be in very dire straits, if not for medication, therapy, and many years of hard work.
I'm pretty upset by this, and by the reactions.
I am not a therapist. Just someone with "skin in the game."
These aren't "data points." These are people, and chances are good that we all have folks in our orbit that have mental health issues.
- meritganset 6y agoTo be fair, you made a claim that "mental health treatment has come an incredibly long way". And the only evidence you have offered to back that up is a vague personal anecdote. The poster was simply providing their viewpoint on the state of mental health that differs from yours. I understand these things can cause strong emotions, but you don't do yourself or your stance any favors by letting it get the best of you here.
- ChrisMarshallNY 6y agoTo be fair, even though I am not, myself, a therapist, I have been dealing with them for decades. It's not "vague, personal anecdotes." It's real world experience. But you are right. This is upsetting, and seeing the way that it is being treated by people that I respect, otherwise, is upsetting. This is the last I'll say anything.
- airstrike 6y agoVague personal anecdotes doesn't mean they are not from the real world. You're taking someone else's valid criticism of the state of the therapy methods available today and taking it personally as well as unwarrantedly attributing it to a lack of sympathy. You fail to understand that the goal of criticizing the therapy method is precisely so we may find ways to improve it.
- tsm_sf 6y agoWhat makes this single point of view a valid criticism?
- airstrike 6y agoWhat makes it not valid? It would actually be great to have an answer to that instead of the parent's complaints
- hn_throwaway_99 6y agoBecause, getting back to the original point, stating "Mental health treatment has come an incredibly long way, just in the last couple of decades" without offering any substantive support for this viewpoint (regardless of whether one's anecdotes are "real world" or not) is, in and of itself, a valid criticism. The onus is on the person making the claim to provide a rationale to back it up.
- behringer 6y agoVague personal anecdote's versus hutzlibu's vague personal anecdotes. Quite frankly, the pills work. A lot of people would unable to lead normal lives without them.
- BigBubbleButt 6y ago> Quite frankly, the pills work. Sometimes they do and sometimes they don't. I had a seizure because of medication I was put on for a mental illness I didn't believe I had. I wasn't 18 and my parents essentially forced me to take them. The pills didn't do anything for me besides give me a seizure that easily could've killed me (I was hospitalized). There's also actual research suggesting these pills can increase suicide attempts. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3353604/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3353604/ There is enormous money to be made suggesting these pills are useful, so I don't just assume it to be true. I also know many other people who feel anti-depressants ruined their lives. I also know many people who feel anti-depressants saved their lives. It's not black and white. Personally, I feel the efficacy of pills for mental health are greatly exaggerated - but it's easy to see why I might be biased.
- OpticalWindows 6y agoAlso the placebo effect is right on their heels in terms of effectiveness
- lazyasciiart 6y agoCan the placebo exist without the "real" pills? More practically, does anyone prescribe placebo outside of a clinical trial?
- manquer 6y agoHomeopathic treatment is largely placebo. A board certified doc will never prescribe placebo he will get sued, plenty of ppl are getting them via alternative medicine though
- Dahoon 6y agoAnd I have close, personal, and intimate relationships with mental illness and its medication myself and if you do know so much as you claim you would know that many (as in likely most) physicians today think the future will see our current medications on par with lobotomies. Anti-psychotic medicine especially is seen as chemical lobotomies. On top of that when 1/3 of the US population is on antidepressants these medications clearly doesn't work either. https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/blog/out-the-darkness/201603/chemical-lobotomy https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/blog/out-the-darkness/201... You might have "skin in the game" but then it is depressing you do not know that almost all mentally ill people would in the long run be healthier without these pills. They mostly only work short-term and absolutely destroy ones health long term. You should be advocating for people to get short-term medically help and long term medicine-free therapeutic help if you really care.
- stjohnswarts 6y agoThis is a terrible sentiment. You aren't a mental health expert. I have seen more than a couple of people come back from the edge because of medications. We use pills for other issues like heart disease, diabetes, etc and people live a relatively normal life. The brain is just an organ. Sure some people would be better off without medication, but lots more would be dead or locked up in a mental institution. Lots of people have chemical imbalances and no matter how much "lie back and tell me your problems" they get they will never be well. Are medications over-prescribed I'm sure that's true in some cases as well.
- Negitivefrags 6y agoI would be much more willing to believe the chemical imbalance concept if someone could actually explain which chemicals, and what the correct balance is. Serotonin you may say? Okay, how much is the correct amount of serotonin then? Can you just give me a test to see if I have the right amount? What’s going on here is not quantifiable science. It’s throw something at the wall and see what sticks.
- matz1 6y ago
- LudwigNagasena 6y agoIt is sad that instead of providing evidence that would support your claim you basically called the person you replied to a nazi that dehumanizes mentally ill people.
- hutzlibu 6y ago"> Because in the real world, the therapy method I have mostly seen, was and is keeping people calm with pills. I consider that offensive" You might also consider, that other people might have a "skin in the game", with close, intimate relationship to mental illnes patients, too. Some of them tragic. And my experience simply is not, that in general psychotherapy evolved a lot. I see rather a trend to favor pills to keep people calm as this is cheaper, than deep psychoanalytical therapy. So consider that offensive, if you must, downvote, if that makes you feel better, but it does not change my personal experience.
- andypea 6y agoI completely agree with you. I know many people who's lives are made much easier because they have access to medication. The last fifty years have also seen a massive improvement in the lives of people with severe mental health problems (in europe at least). However, support for people with mental health problems is still severly underfunded. The improvements we have seen say as much about the terrible treatment of the past as they do about how well we are doing now. Almost all studies I have read find that a combination of medication and other therapies provide for the best outcomes. Most people can only get funding for medication, which is often better than nothing, but it really falls short of what society could, relatively easily, provide. It is really a tragedy, not just to the individuals suffering from mental health problems, but also to society as a whole which misses out from all the untapped productivity and creativity.