4 ms·
Quick note that anyone using a US based cloud provider will likely be blocking all sanctioned countries. It’s not configurable at all. It was a sticking point
by dijit 6y ago
Quick note that anyone using a US based cloud provider will likely be blocking all sanctioned countries. It’s not configurable at all.
It was a sticking point for us when deploying the sequel to a game I was working on. Ultimately we determined that the benefits of using the provider outweighed the benefit to users since we weren’t shipping the game there officially anyway. (With one notable exception)
It still leaves a sour taste in my mouth.
It should be noted that it’s also Cuba and Crimea that are blocked. I was principally annoyed at the lack of usability in Crimea, as any way you slice it it’s part of a country that is not being sanctioned in the same way and the citizenry did nothing wrong.
- da39a3ee 6y agoYou might want to delete the "and the citizenry did nothing wrong" ending to your otherwise reasonable post. I don't think you meant it the way it sounds.
- jrochkind1 6y agoI legit am not sure how it sounded to you in a way that seemed unfortunate.
- da39a3ee 6y agoIt implies that, unlike Crimea, the citizenry of countries _other_ than Crimea (Iran/Sudan/Cuba etc) _did_ do something wrong.
- jrochkind1 6y agoAh, I see. I mean, yeah, I think that kind of is the theory behind US sanctions sometimes honestly. It's pretty messed up. (And the US, which is a "democracy", would want to avoid looking in the mirror too).
- bigbubba 6y agoWhat do you think the citizenry of Crimea did wrong?
- trhway 6y agothey voted wrong way.
- bigbubba 6y agoI'm under the impression that nobody but Russian state media claims that election was legitimate.
- trhway 6y agowrong way in wrong elections :) Of course, like any Russian election it was just a formality, a décor. Nobody really needed it as the will of the people was clear - no more threats of more of those "trains of friendships" full of Western Ukrainian nationalists, especially given all the quiet massive arming of those nationalists that had happened under the cover of the Ministry of Internal Affairs in the run up to the 2014.
- kdmytro 6y agoWhat massive arming?
- f6v 6y agoAh yes, the legitimacy. I don't think it means what it's implied to mean. The USA do many illegitimate things and no-one bats an eye.
- da39a3ee 6y agoNothing; see my reply elsewhere in this thread. I meant the opposite of what you understood me to mean, but I can see why I was misunderstood.
- da39a3ee 6y agoI am being misunderstood because of the wording I used. The reason "and the citizenry did nothing wrong" is problematic is because it implies that, unlike Crimea, the citizenry of countries _other_ than Crimea (Iran/Sudan/Cuba etc) _did_ do something wrong. I was not saying that the citizens of Crimea did something wrong: I was saying the opposite.
- hevelvarik 6y agoIt was obvious and you are dealing with pedants
- lucb1e 6y ago> US based cloud provider Huh, I thought it was GitLab B.V. and that still exists[1], but Wikipedia says they're headquartered in the USA as of 2018[2] and the official "About" page[3] mentions Amsterdam, the Netherlands nor B.V., but does mention a "GitLab Inc.". The history on Wikipedia doesn't mention them having moved and still has the "Tech companies from the Netherlands" category (not sure if that's because they're still originally from there, or because the category was never removed). Not sure blocking Iran would have happened if they hadn't opened a corp overseas. [1] https://www.kvk.nl/orderstraat/product-kiezen/?kvknummer=600348310000 https://www.kvk.nl/orderstraat/product-kiezen/?kvknummer=600... [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=GitLab&diff=826856844&oldid=825392993 https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=GitLab&diff=82685... [3] https://about.gitlab.com/company/ https://about.gitlab.com/company/ Edit: slightly older, 2017 reference of USA headquarters https://www.ycombinator.com/library/6J-gitlab-s-secret-to-managing-160-employees-in-160-locations https://www.ycombinator.com/library/6J-gitlab-s-secret-to-ma... Editv2: the TOS still says that the intellectual property is with GitLab B.V. but the branding page says the trademark is held by GitLab Inc. The privacy policy is not GDPR-complaint (on multiple counts and I haven't even read it, just spotted some things like implicit+non-opt-outable consent while looking for who is the data controller) and doesn't mention who the data controller is. It does make clear that all data goes to the USA and you better suck it up. Looks like they fully embraced all of the USA's freedoms including censorship and privacy violations under their home country's law. I'm giving up searching for more info about the move at this point: there is no news article in HN search, the blog search requires me to accept more tracking which (after seeing the illegal-in-the-EU privacy policy) I'm not sure I'm willing to engage in, and the website seems to have had mixed mentions of B.V. and Inc. as of 2016.
- dijit 6y agoGitlab is hosted on google cloud, and fronted by cloudflare... those IP restrictions apply to google cloud, AWS, Azure and Oracle Cloud. (and Cloudflare since that's a US company also)
- miracle2k 6y agoTo my knowledge, services hosted on AWS are not blocked in Iran. Also, if that were the case, literally have the internet would cease to function w/o VPN, which should give pause to those who would shrug off such a policy.
- godelzilla 6y agoImperialism always attacks innocent citizens.
- einpoklum 6y ago> I was principally annoyed at the lack of usability in Crimea, as any way you slice it it’s part of a country that is not being sanctioned in the same way and the citizenry did nothing wrong. If "doing wrong things" is a criterion for being blocked on GitLab, then there are _so_ many organizations and states which should be blocked, and arguably hundreds of Millions of people who serve in military forces which do wrong things etc. So, there is really no justification for this regardless of slicing. IMHO.
- names_are_hard 6y agoIn the past I worked for an Israeli company listed on a US stock exchange. They were proud that they had customers in virtually every corner of the world, and had just six countries they couldn't do business in. One (Lebanon) because of the Israeli government, and five (including Iran) because of the US. Most interesting to me: apparently when they first went public and became subject to US regulation they had to close quite a large number of customer accounts in Iran.
- freehunter 6y agoIt’s interesting to me that the US views Iran more harshly than Israel does.
- mcny 6y agoIran, Israel, Kingdom of Saudi Arabia... There is so much going on there. Are they all at conflict with one another? Who are allies? How does this work?
- Fuzzwah 6y agoOn a long enough time scale, everyone is the bad guy.
- sudosysgen 6y agoIsrael is an ally of the KSA against Iran, though they both pretend not to be for domestic consumption. They are indeed both in conflict with one another, because in truth Iran is really the only country in the Middle East that could threaten to become an independent power, on the level of say, Turkey.
- RedComet 6y agoIt doesn't, the US is just Israel's proxy warrior in this fight. (cf. the Clean Break memo, etc)
- markdown 6y ago
- toast0 6y agoAt least on some clouds, it's configurable, but your lawyers need to speak to their lawyers, etc, to get worldwide access enabled, and annual reconfirmation between lawyers. You would probably have to be in an OFAC exception category, of course. Routing to sanctioned countries from a provider that mostly blocks them probably isn't the best either.
- Symbiote 6y agoI only use Amazon Route 53. Does anyone know if that's ever been blocked in Iran etc? It doesn't seem to be blocked at the moment, but it's also something I can't find any official documentation on.
- f6v 6y ago> and the citizenry did nothing wrong Well nobody is wrong when it comes to Crimea except those who claim it’s part of Ukraine.
- KorematsuFred 6y agoDoes that mean Ali Cloud would be a better option here ?
- dicomdan 6y agoNot really.
- CKN23-ARIN 6y agoOther than GCP, which US based cloud providers do this?
- DetroitThrow 6y agoAWS: https://reclaimthenet.org/amazon-aws-iran-proxies-vpn-sanctions/ https://reclaimthenet.org/amazon-aws-iran-proxies-vpn-sancti... I'm not sure Azure has been available for Iranian IPs for the past few years or ever, feel free to Google "Azure Blocked Iran" though - plenty of petitions.
- CKN23-ARIN 6y agoAWS and Azure prevent Iran-based users from having an account, but if you have an account, you can exchange traffic with Iranian IPs. GCP blocks traffic to/from Iranian IPs for all users. It sounded to me like GP was referring to the latter type of blocking.