4 ms·
GitHub isn't siding with anyone here. They're not increasing liability to protect Popcorn Time, they're only following regular counter-notice procedure by reins
by judge2020 6y ago
GitHub isn't siding with anyone here. They're not increasing liability to protect Popcorn Time, they're only following regular counter-notice procedure by reinstating the repositories after 15 days of the MPAA not filing a lawsuit against the owners of Popcorn Time[0,1]. This procedure will also happen with youtube-dl if they decide to counter-notice.
0: https://docs.github.com/en/free-pro-team@latest/github/site-policy/guide-to-submitting-a-dmca-counter-notice#article-contents:~:text=If%20you%20do%2C%20we%20will%20wait,legal%20action%20against%20you%20before%20then https://docs.github.com/en/free-pro-team@latest/github/site-....
1: https://github.com/github/dmca/blob/master/2020/05/2020-05-04-MPA-counternotice.md https://github.com/github/dmca/blob/master/2020/05/2020-05-0...
- eli 6y agoNo because the RIAA letter wasn’t a takedown notice
- judge2020 6y agohttps://github.com/github/dmca/blob/master/2020/10/2020-10-23-RIAA.md https://github.com/github/dmca/blob/master/2020/10/2020-10-2... > and in plain violation of Section 1201 of the Digital Millennium Copyright Act, 17 U.S.C. §1201. Doesn’t mean it’s legally valid, just that the service provider must take it down until they receive a counter.
- eli 6y agoThat’s not a takedown notice and does not allege that the repo is infringing any RIAA copyright. They are alleging instead a violation of the anti-circumvention provision of DMCA which is not covered by takedown notice procedure. The letter is also missing several required elements of a takedown letter which makes sense because it’s not a takedown notice nor does it purport to be one. It’s just a letter making demands that cites the DMCA. It carries no legal weight other than the implied threat of a lawsuit.
- rndgermandude 6y agoThe RIAA letter was a takedown notice, tho from the looks of it a rather frivolous one. They used a DMCA (17 U.S. Code § 512) takedown notice not to complain about infringing content but to complain about "circumvention" (17 U.S. Code § 1201). This is probably outside of the scope of DMCA notices, but courts often rule like common people would not expect (shout-out to Google vs Oracle). Github then followed the letter of the law (and case law and jurisprudence) and processed the takedown request without looking into the merit, just making sure the notice had the required elements under the DMCA. Doing anything else would potentially open up Github to liability. Now it's up to yt-dl to file a counter-notice, pointing out that the RIAA members do not actually own any copyright to the code itself (and maybe also state that yt-dl is not "primarily" a "circumvention" software according to 17 U.S. Code § 1201), and see what happens. RIAA can then file a lawsuit, which at this point they would probably win just because they can throw more money at it. Hurray for the US civil law legal system, where the richer party almost always wins.
- eli 6y agoIt’s not a takedown notice and doesn’t follow takedown notice procedure. It doesn’t claim to be a takedown notice. RIAA sent a letter asking GitHub to take a repo down and they listened. They weren’t legally obligated to but they chose to and that’s their right. A counter notification wouldn’t necessarily do anything since the original letter was not a takedown notice. GitHub can’t be compelled to host something they no longer wish to host.
- rndgermandude 6y agoI determined this based on being a person who has to read a lot of these regularly (even tho I am not in the US; fun innit?!) It does not lack any of the required elements (compare https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/17/512 https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/17/512 ). In fact, it is specifically written to hit all the required elements. Let's go through this. Statement there is copyright infringement and demanding takedown: >In light of the above noted copyright infringements and anticircumvention violations, we ask that you immediately take down and disable access to the youtube-dl source code at all of its locations where it is hosted on GitHub, including without limitation those locations in the representative list set forth above. (yes, the "copyright infringement claim is very most likely bullshit, but it's not Github's place under the law to rule on it, unless they want to lose their safe harbor protections and open themselves up to potential liability) (vi) statement of authorization (with perjury) > Under penalty of perjury, we submit that the RIAA is authorized to act on behalf of its member companies on matters involving the infringement of their sound recordings, audiovisual works and images, including enforcing their copyrights and common law rights on the Internet. (v) statement of good faith of accurateness >We have a good faith belief that this activity is not authorized by the copyright owner, its agent, or the law. We assert that the information in this notification is accurate, based upon the data available to us. (iv) and (i) contact details and (electronic) signature >You may contact me at RIAA, [private] Tel. [private], >[private] (ii) identification of content >We also note that the source code prominently includes as sample uses of the source code the downloading of copies of our members’ copyrighted sound recordings and music videos, as noted in Exhibit A hereto. For example, as shown on Exhibit A, the source code expressly suggests its use to copy and/or distribute the following copyrighted works owned by our member companies: [list] (yes, this is basically trickery to hit the (ii)) (iii) identification of infringement > https://github.com/ytdl-org/youtube-dl https://github.com/ytdl-org/youtube-dl [...] And there you go, all 6 required elements + claim of infringement + demand for takedown are there.
- cesarb 6y ago> This procedure will also happen with youtube-dl if they decide to counter-notice. They might decide not to counter-notice, because there's a big trap in the DMCA counter-notice: as far as I know, for a DMCA counter-notice to be valid, the one doing the counter-notice must agree to be bound to the jurisdiction of an USA court. If the youtube-dl author is not from the USA (I think he's from the EU), that would expose him to legal risk. (As a non-USA person, to me this is the most evil part of the DMCA take-down system: even a defective DMCA notice leads to a dilemma, either you keep the content offline, or you risk being sued in a foreign jurisdiction you have no control over. This is also why I believe one should always prefer to host in one's own country, so that any dispute can be resolved by the local courts.)
- phendrenad2 6y agoIANAL, but I suspect that if this were ever tested in court, the court would instead find that the DMCA counter-claim functionality isn't available to non-citizens, which may actually be worse.
- crazygringo 6y agoI'm curious... what if the author created an LLC in their home country, and assigned IP to that? Is there any reason why that wouldn't fully protect them from legal risk if they wanted to visit the US personally? (Though I would guess you probably can't do that retroactively.)
- jwalton 6y agoAsk Dmitry Sklyarov[0]. 0: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_v._Elcom_Ltd https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_v._Elcom_Ltd.
- naivedevops 6y agoJust never leave your country of citizenship. It should be easy with the current Covid-19 situation.
- 6y ago