3 ms·
> Without a vaccine, the only option is herd immunity, regardless of lockdowns. We already have evidence that reinfection can occur within 6 months. And the r
by bsder 6y ago
> Without a vaccine, the only option is herd immunity, regardless of lockdowns.
We already have evidence that reinfection can occur within 6 months. And the reinfection can be worse than the original. https://blogs.sciencemag.org/pipeline/archives/2020/10/14/immunity-and-re-infection https://blogs.sciencemag.org/pipeline/archives/2020/10/14/im...
Now, not everybody will get reinfected. And maybe these people wiped out their infection by latching onto a different protein. And one was immunocompromised. etc.
However, reinfection by coronavirii is the general norm, not the exception.
The fact that reinfections can occur on a short (6 months) timescale puts a really big pin in the "herd immunity" balloon.
- WalterBright 6y agoFrom the cited article: "The confirmed examples worldwide could possibly be counted on your fingers (depending on whose count you believe) out of at least 38 million total cases." Statistically speaking, this is 100% immunity. Biology is never perfect.
- henrikschroder 6y agoWHO put out an estimate a couple of weeks ago that up to 750 million people worldwide could have been infected with the virus. The confirmed cases is an obvious lower bound, and it's probably safe to use the WHO estimate as an upper bound. Either way, a handful of cases of reinfection among hundreds of millions of cases means we're in lightning strike territory. It's completely statistically irrelevant.
- WalterBright 6y agoEvery vaccine I've taken comes with a page of horrific (but very rare) possible side effects I have to acknowledge. I take the vaccine anyway because the risk of the disease is worse.
- bsder 6y agoRecurrent infection is rare, but you cannot make that jump from the rarity to say 100%. 1) Reinfection rarity decreases with time and we are barely 6 months into this mess--that's much less than a "cold season" which is known to reinfect. You are betting against a known Bayesian prior (other coronavirii families reinfect with a small but not irrelevant percentage) with no evidence to support your statement. 2) "Confirmed reinfection" has to pass an incredibly high bar. You have to have two symptomatic infection events, AND both infections have to have been sequenced AND the sequences have to be sufficiently different to differentiate from never having cleared the virus. Reinfection would normally be with a virus that is almost exactly the same. So, reinfection being rare could be that it's amazingly rare. OR it could be that it's only somewhat uncommon but we don't have enough events with sequencing data to confirm. The low Bayesian prior of rareness means we shouldn't panic about reinfection, but it doesn't imply that we can just ignore it, either.
- WalterBright 6y ago> So, reinfection being rare could be that it's amazingly rare. OR it could be that it's only somewhat uncommon but we don't have enough events with sequencing data to confirm. I can agree that 6 months of data says nothing about what immunity would be like after a year or two. But still, it's hard to imagine how some tidal wave of reinfection remains currently undetected. But let's postulate that reinfection immunity only lasts 6 months. Ironically, that means that lockdowns and isolation will prevent herd immunity. To stop the disease, everyone would need to get infected within that 6 month window.
- bsder 6y ago> To stop the disease, everyone would need to get infected within that 6 month window. No, they would have to get infected on exactly the same day otherwise a rolling window effect would occur where populations roll into and out of immunity. Herd immunity simply has never happened in the history of disease without a vaccine. Typhoid, smallpox, polio, etc. never went away and smallpox was about 1 in 13 deaths in London. Ironically, if we do achieve something close to herd immunity, we will wind up confining the disease to mostly children like what happened with smallpox.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]