4 ms·
>When I was a teen, growing up on a diet of Carl Sagan’s Cosmos and Alvin Toffler’s Futurism, I had plenty of big ideas: spaceflight, supersonic travel, mag-lev
by Barrin92 6y ago
>When I was a teen, growing up on a diet of Carl Sagan’s Cosmos and Alvin Toffler’s Futurism, I had plenty of big ideas: spaceflight, supersonic travel, mag-lev trains, geodesic domes, bio-nanotech for longevity, and social organization to provide maximum freedom for all. Cheesy, but optimistic.
Now I am 29 and I have no big, optimistic ideas.[...]It feels like I’m in the belly of the ship, frenetically plugging leaky holes, never even having the space of mind to think where the ship should go. Ostensibly, those decisions are made on the bridge of the ship, which, in October 2020, seems to be populated by well-intentioned individuals, but hamstrung in their ability to make good collective decisions.*
So the author turned into an adult. Geodesic domes and flying cars are cool but whether the future is good or not will depend on many people doing boring work over many decades and stuffing those leaks in the ship. Torvalds has said many times that you make the future better fixing one pothole at a time, and what he has built proves that's true. Bold visions aren't all they're cracked up to be and I'll take the linux kernel and git over Bezos phallic rockets when it comes to world improvement in tech. What I'll take from Bezos is the decidedly non-futuristic idea of putting books into boxes a little bit faster than everyone else. That made the world a bit better as well.
- Animats 6y agoSo the author turned into an adult. No, that's not it. We don't have a vision of the future any more. Here's a well-known vision of the future: Futurama.[1] No, not the cartoon. The 1939 World's Fair exhibit. Yes, it's General Motors' view. Note the expectation of unlimited progress. Most of what you see there as the future was achieved. GM tried again at the 1964 World's Fair.[2] There was still optimism, but what we see there - huge moon bases and undersea cities - didn't happen. The big moment of disillusionment was the end of the US moon program in 1972. Going into space was just too expensive. That was about the time when science fiction turned dystopian. "Silent Running", the first "dirty future" movie, came out in 1972, and set the pattern for most later SF films. Crystal spires out, grunge in. For about a century and a half, manufacturing and transportation changed the world and led to the future. Then what? Well, we got computers, and that carried us for another half century. What's next? There's nothing obvious in the near term. Eventually biology may be figured out to the level that organisms can be designed and engineered. But that's not close. Fusion power? Not going well. We have enough technology and resources to provide a good standard of living for everyone on the planet. Nobody seems to have a scalable political system able to make that happen. This isn't a technology problem. [1] https://vimeo.com/329901114 https://vimeo.com/329901114 [2] https://youtu.be/2-5aK0H05jk https://youtu.be/2-5aK0H05jk
- Barrin92 6y agowhat we had was a vision of the future. The World fair, the Jetsons, world music etc, the visions of the future we had was the Flintstones or the suburb on Mars including a robot maid, and the Fallout videogame franchise did a very good job of pointing out of much of a boring, contemporary version of the world that was, just relocated into space. Today we have many visions of the future, we just don't have one vision of the future. On the frontpage of HN right now is a great article about Solarpunk, emerging out of cyberpunk. Which I never considered to be 'dystopian' in a negative sense of the term, but in contrast to the World Fair GM aesthetic, genuinely transgressive, rather than utopian or corporate. And in the real world we have countless of futures too. From change in China that is so rapid you can physically see it every two or three years, to a wholesale restructuring towards renewables, kids in rural India getting access to social media and changing how we communicate, agriculture incorporating technologies in diverse ways all over the world, autonomous cities, virtual reality, and so on. What we indeed don't have is the science fiction world as imagined by guys in the 60s in America, nobody's forcing you to hang onto it or not to go look somewhere else for a vision of the future though. When people make this take about the lack of futuristic visions almost exclusively what they seem to be looking for is a sort of retro-futurism and nostalgia.