3 ms·
This study sounds way off. It was by NASA which means they were trying to tell a lawn from satellite. That's probably tough--having to discount natural grass la
by jonknee 18y ago
This study sounds way off. It was by NASA which means they were trying to tell a lawn from satellite. That's probably tough--having to discount natural grass land and farms (which there is a fair amount of) and accurately getting the percentage. Not to mention seeing through tree cover to see if there is grass below. There is a lot of green out there, not a whole lot of it is mowed lawns.
50,000 square miles is 1/70th of all land in the US including Alaska (3.5m sq mi total). If you've ever driven through the country, 1/70th is not a mowed lawn. You can drive for hundreds of miles without seeing a single one. If you discount Alaska the total is 1/58th.
Looking another way that would be 32,000,000 acres of lawn. which comes out to 1/10 acre of lawn per person in the country. At first that seems more reasonable, 1/10th of an acre isn't a lot, but that's per person not household. A 4-person family comes to 4/10 of an acre--a decent sized lot. And since there are large numbers of people with no lawn the number increases for people who actually do (10m in NYC without one means 10m other people would need twice as much space, etc).
- xlnt 18y agoCongratulations, you're smarter than NASA. Well done. Now please solve this problem too: making NASA competent. (To be clear: no sarcasm intended.)
- astine 18y agoI don't think he was saying that NASA was incompetent, but that the task at hand was infeasible, particularly using the means that NASA typically has a hand (ie. using satellite images instead of of county records.)
- xlnt 18y agoHe didn't say that, I did. He just pointed out mistakes they made, including not subjecting their results to a basic sanity test.
- jonknee 18y agoI found the study in question: http://earthobservatory.nasa.gov/Study/Lawn/ http://earthobservatory.nasa.gov/Study/Lawn/ And does admit the limitations: > The satellites that can identify such small areas only observe small areas at a time, and the images they collect are expensive. So the author of the study created an equation and plugged in some numbers. Hardly actual research. The actual methodology is cute, check the sat for lights at night and then predict how "urban" it is and that means there is less lawn. (Though ironically on her map NYC is the highest concentration of lawn in America.) Too bad the results don't pass a reality check. She claims more lawn than farm, which is absurd (the CIA World Factbook shows the US at 18.01% arable land which is a cool 600,000 sq mi).