3 ms·
They asked volunteers to install a browser extension to collect the data for them. So technically aren't they bulk collecting their volunteers' data, not Faceb
by jedberg 6y ago
They asked volunteers to install a browser extension to collect the data for them. So technically aren't they bulk collecting their volunteers' data, not Facebook's?
We really need a law/court case that establishes who owns data and who has permission to share it. The volunteers should be allowed to share whatever they want.
- jcims 6y agoCurious if we'll see facebook sniffing for extensions now.
- rbecker 6y agoAn even stronger, still accurate phrasing, would be to say the volunteers are telling the researchers what ads they see on Facebook. The browser extension is just a tool, doing the bidding of the volunteers, to make that sharing easier. Facebook is essentially saying we're not allowed to talk to each-other ("in bulk") about what ads Facebook is showing us. Not the first time corporations try to prevent consumers/users/workers from organizing.
- Reelin 6y agoThis came up recently on HN regarding Facebook taking legal action against two Chrome extensions. (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24661891 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24661891) Scraping appears to violate the ToS. Tortious interference was brought up in the comments but I'm not convinced it applies. Regardless of whether the scraping itself is legal, redistributing the content to a third party is likely to violate copyright in many cases. The entire situation seems overly complicated.
- artemisyna 6y agoYou might be underestimating the number of folks that would be willing to install an extension for $10 and expose the private data of themselves and their friends and family in the process...