3 ms·
Nuclear is really good at producing consistent power. Unfortunately, that's not what we want. Peak demand for power in the evening is several times what it
by bryanlarsen 6y ago
Nuclear is really good at producing consistent power. Unfortunately, that's not what we want. Peak demand for power in the evening is several times what it is during the middle of the night.
- AnthonyMouse 6y agoExcept that it is exactly what we want for the level of demand that we never fall below, which is still about half of the peak demand. And if we use nuclear for that, it significantly reduces the amount of storage we need for renewables. Also, nuclear combines well with thermal storage because you don't incur double conversion losses. If you store heat from the reactor during the day when solar is generating, use it during the peak demand in the evening when it isn't, and then run directly from the reactor overnight, you don't really need any other storage.
- bryanlarsen 6y ago> Except that it is exactly what we want for the level of demand that we never fall below, which is still about half of the peak demand. And if we use nuclear for that, it significantly reduces the amount of storage we need for renewables. The bottom half of the demand is the easy half, why would you use your most expensive power for the easy stuff? > Also, nuclear combines well with thermal storage because you don't incur double conversion losses. If you store heat from the reactor during the day when solar is generating, use it during the peak demand in the evening when it isn't, and then run directly from the reactor overnight, you don't really need any other storage. In other words, you're running your nuclear at a 50% duty cycle, doubling it's price. I don't think there is much appetite for power that costs over $200 per MWh.
- gravypod 6y agoI think this is, again, too simplistic a model for understanding the costs of different power systems. Industrial use cases (think data centers, factories, etc) likely reduce usage during night time hours but they surely don't drop by 50% usage. > The bottom half of the demand is the easy half, why would you use your most expensive power for the easy stuff? Factoring in carbon footprints nuclear would likely beat our battery based storage options if carbon output was taxed. Nickel–metal hydride battery and LiPo are not carbon neutral and are consumable components. > In other words, you're running your nuclear at a 50% duty cycle, doubling it's price. I don't think there is much appetite for power that costs over $200 per MWh. 50% duty cycle means 50% fuel usage (not really but not not) meaning you're not really "wasting" energy here. Another question to ask ourselves: we make the Total Cost of Ownership of a plant far better than it even currently is? We can do this by extending the lifespan of a plant to amortize construction. If you could design a power plant to last 100 to 200 years, that could be amortized further factoring into lower costs. We can also do this by reducing construction costs or improving efficiency. I think those are accomplish-able goals (at least judging by China's adoption of Nuclear). Current plants in the USA operate for ~40 years. That means current plants were built with ~$today-50 (or more) years of physics and material science knowledge. For context, that's the 70s. In the 70s: - C was invented - TTL logic was just starting to be used - Stainless steel did not exist <- this statement was wrong Edit: philipkglass pointed out that stainless steel is quite a bit older. Disregard that last item.
- philipkglass 6y agoStainless steel did not exist Stainless steel was about 60 years old in the 1970s. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stainless_steel#History https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stainless_steel#History
- gravypod 6y agoAh it was large scale manufacturing of Stainless that came into prominence around the 60s. Made a mistake there!
- chongli 6y agoNuclear requires huge amounts of cement and steel to build. Both of these resources are enormous sources of CO2. Cement clinker manufacturing, in particular, is a horrible emitter, responsible for 8% of global CO2 emissions all by itself. That’s one type of building material among many that are needed in huge quantities.
- sgt 6y agoThat's a pretty weak argument. Those are once-off building requirements, not something that is repeated. If you compare the cement used by the one nuclear powerplant to the closest city it would be like a drop in the ocean.
- gravypod 6y agoThere's been large improvement in cements specifically in the past few years. It can be recycled, enforced, and supplanted by other materials. Concrete sold today can be bought with an advertised lifespan of 100 years. If you replace a coal plant with a nuclear plant how many years would it need to be net carbon negative? What is the grams of CO2 / kWh of nuclear vs coal vs solar?
- anfilt 6y agoConcrete resorbs CO2 from the air after you pour it. This carbonation of concrete can cause corrosion to rebar or other re-inforcments. A large portion of that CO2 is eventually reabsorbed back by the concrete. Depending on the mix this process can adsorb 1/3 to 2/3rds of the CO2 produced during production. However, this is a slow process and we keep making new concrete. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Concrete_degradation#Carbonation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Concrete_degradation#Carbonati... Also there is the all energy used for processing concrete which a lot times is not from CO2 neutral source.
- AnthonyMouse 6y ago> The bottom half of the demand is the easy half It's not so easy when you have to meet it even when there is no wind or sunlight for twelve hours straight. > In other words, you're running your nuclear at a 50% duty cycle, doubling it's price. You're still running it at a 100% duty cycle, you're just shifting the generation times. You have a reactor that can produce heat enough to generate 1GW continuous power, so it stores that heat for six hours a day during peak solar generation, then generates 2GW for six hours to cover peak demand in the evening, then generates 1GW directly for twelve hours overnight. It's generating 1GW worth of heat at all times, you're just converting the heat to electricity at different times of the day.
- epistasis 6y agoThe problem isn't 12 hours of no wind or solar (and, come on, that's not even realistic). The problem are week long wind droughts with heavy cloud cover. That's where there's a clear argument for geothermal, hydro, and hydrogen. Maybe natural gas with carbon sequestration. If nuclear wants to join these options, it needs to prove itself as something that can be built. And as somebody who doesn't believe that we are close at all to natural gas with carbon sequestration, I think we are a lot closer to making that work than we are to having the managerial and technical skill capacity to build new nuclear. Nuclear is not the only option, we have so many more.
- GoOnThenDoTell 6y agoI don’t understand the hydrogen angle specifically, doesn’t it require energy to produce and that it’s really difficult to store?
- ncmncm 6y agoIt is, exactly, storage. And also industrial feedstock, immediately, and after a while, aircraft fuel.
- pfdietz 6y agoThe key point about hydrogen is that the cost of storage capacity (to be distinguished from costs related to charging and discharging rates) is extremely low. So if you need a system to cover very rare extended outages, or to store energy from summer for use in winter, hydrogen is much better than batteries.
- jnxx 6y ago> When there is zero wind and zero sun then it doesn't matter how much over provisioning there is: your output will be zero. A lot of energy use is room heating. But nobody wants their bedroom and living room in the night warmer than during the day.
- stjohnswarts 6y agoYou're wrong, nuclear is very controllable. Look up control rods. It's not like it can only pump out one level of energy.