7 ms·
> Nuclear power is a zero emissions source of power. Alternative renewables (e.g. wind, solar) require fossil fuels to power the electrical grid when they are n
by bryanlarsen 6y ago
> Nuclear power is a zero emissions source of power. Alternative renewables (e.g. wind, solar) require fossil fuels to power the electrical grid when they are not able to generate power.
Renewables are about an order of magnitude cheaper than nuclear. $15/MWh vs $112/MWh. So what you do is overprovision your renewables. In other words, build more than you need. The major reason to do this is so that when the wind is barely blowing and/or it's a cloudy day you still get enough power to supply your needs without peakers. Then on the days when you're producing excess power (ie, most of them), you use that excess energy to produce methane from CO2. Use that methane to run your natural gas peakers, making them carbon neutral. This is likely much cheaper than batteries, certainly if you already have the gas peakers.
You'll have to overprovision to cover the very unlikely time that both the wind and sun disappear for a long stretch, so you'll be overprovisioned all other times. Methane production takes Hydrogen as an input, so you can use some of that excess energy to create extra Hydrogen. Or you can turn methane into plastic for use or storage. Or just sell the extra electricity, there are several industries that can soak up cheap electricity (please not to bitcoin miners though).
> Nuclear energy is more cost effective than alternatives. The main issue is that antinuclear activists, funded by the fossil fuel industry, have lobbied to make it cost prohibitive to build nuclear power plants by way of onerous regulation and prolonged legal battles.
Even in China, nuclear is incredibly expensive and takes a long time. So I don't think regulation is the main problem.
> Why? Producing hydrogen is inefficient and unnecessary
Clean steel & cement.
- gravypod 6y ago> Renewables are about an order of magnitude cheaper than nuclear. I think there are a lot of complications that are encountered when doing this sort of calculation. You might get a max output of "$15/MWh" or "$112/MWh" but that's only a portion of the picture. Firstly Nuclear is X amount of power essentially on tap 24/7 where X is between some Min and Max value. From what I understand this makes grid management much simpler and reduces storage, transmission, and conversion losses. Even in the best case situation of "renewable" energy you'll see, in the absolute best case claimed by pumped hydro storage, you're seeing about an 87% efficiency. Suppose you had a nuclear power plant that could output 100W consistently. Suppose you wanted to build a similarly efficient "renewable" energy source. How much more peak power would it need to output to be competitive? If we assume the power source is 0% efficient at night and 100% efficient during the day, off the bat, you'd need to generate 200W continuously during the day. Then you'd need to generate an extra 13% on those extra 100Ws to make up for storage losses (1.13*100 ~= 113). That means 100W from Nuclear is ~= 213W "renewable". Obviously this is a terrible calculation and not at all accurate but it's just a sample of some of the math that needs to be done. Another factor that I've been skirting around is that "renewable" sources of energy are often not so renewable. Specifically things like like solar require a huge amount of rare metals & complex fabrication. Right now none of those externalizations are represented in the price of solar because there are no carbon taxes in countries that manufacture them. Money in this case is a proxy of what needs to be measured and should not be the only factor we optimize for.
- bryanlarsen 6y agoNuclear is really good at producing consistent power. Unfortunately, that's not what we want. Peak demand for power in the evening is several times what it is during the middle of the night.
- AnthonyMouse 6y agoExcept that it is exactly what we want for the level of demand that we never fall below, which is still about half of the peak demand. And if we use nuclear for that, it significantly reduces the amount of storage we need for renewables. Also, nuclear combines well with thermal storage because you don't incur double conversion losses. If you store heat from the reactor during the day when solar is generating, use it during the peak demand in the evening when it isn't, and then run directly from the reactor overnight, you don't really need any other storage.
- bryanlarsen 6y ago> Except that it is exactly what we want for the level of demand that we never fall below, which is still about half of the peak demand. And if we use nuclear for that, it significantly reduces the amount of storage we need for renewables. The bottom half of the demand is the easy half, why would you use your most expensive power for the easy stuff? > Also, nuclear combines well with thermal storage because you don't incur double conversion losses. If you store heat from the reactor during the day when solar is generating, use it during the peak demand in the evening when it isn't, and then run directly from the reactor overnight, you don't really need any other storage. In other words, you're running your nuclear at a 50% duty cycle, doubling it's price. I don't think there is much appetite for power that costs over $200 per MWh.
- gravypod 6y agoI think this is, again, too simplistic a model for understanding the costs of different power systems. Industrial use cases (think data centers, factories, etc) likely reduce usage during night time hours but they surely don't drop by 50% usage. > The bottom half of the demand is the easy half, why would you use your most expensive power for the easy stuff? Factoring in carbon footprints nuclear would likely beat our battery based storage options if carbon output was taxed. Nickel–metal hydride battery and LiPo are not carbon neutral and are consumable components. > In other words, you're running your nuclear at a 50% duty cycle, doubling it's price. I don't think there is much appetite for power that costs over $200 per MWh. 50% duty cycle means 50% fuel usage (not really but not not) meaning you're not really "wasting" energy here. Another question to ask ourselves: we make the Total Cost of Ownership of a plant far better than it even currently is? We can do this by extending the lifespan of a plant to amortize construction. If you could design a power plant to last 100 to 200 years, that could be amortized further factoring into lower costs. We can also do this by reducing construction costs or improving efficiency. I think those are accomplish-able goals (at least judging by China's adoption of Nuclear). Current plants in the USA operate for ~40 years. That means current plants were built with ~$today-50 (or more) years of physics and material science knowledge. For context, that's the 70s. In the 70s: - C was invented - TTL logic was just starting to be used - Stainless steel did not exist <- this statement was wrong Edit: philipkglass pointed out that stainless steel is quite a bit older. Disregard that last item.
- pfdietz 6y ago> Clean steel & cement. Even today, 6% of all natural gas consumed in the world goes to making hydrogen (about 700 cubic kilometers of H2 per year at STP). The major use is in making ammonia.
- freeflight 6y agoNobody is saying this is being done now, but Germany for example is heavily banking on a hydrogen based energy economy for the future [0], just as the EU comission does. Which makes a lot of sense: It's a way to utilize the overproduction from renewables and existing gas infrastructure can be retooled for hydrogen without too much investment [1]. There are even considerations for a European hydrogen backbone by gas infrastructure companies from nine EU member states [2] [0] https://www.fraunhofer.de/content/dam/zv/de/ueber-fraunhofer/wissenschaftspolitik/Positionen/2019-10-a-hydrogen-roadmap-for-germany.pdf https://www.fraunhofer.de/content/dam/zv/de/ueber-fraunhofer... [1] https://www.rechargenews.com/transition/german-pipeline-operators-present-plan-for-world-s-largest-hydrogen-grid/2-1-810731 https://www.rechargenews.com/transition/german-pipeline-oper... [2] https://www.euractiv.com/section/energy/news/gas-grid-operators-unveil-plan-for-european-hydrogen-infrastructure-backbone/ https://www.euractiv.com/section/energy/news/gas-grid-operat...
- epistasis 6y agoYour post and links got me thinking: in many ways hydrogen is happening a lot more now than nuclear. China is building tons is alkaline electrolyzers. Europe is looking to PEM. There are new MW-scale electrolyzers used for silicon production. There's an active industry that is scaling and innovating and growing. Nuclear is in decline, with all the giants failing. The few startups are working on engineering projects where iteration is measured in decade time scales rather than months. The hydrogen industry exciting right now, and honestly I can't imagine saying that even a year ago. Europe's investing tens of billions of dollars in it, which will result in massive changes and improvements for the technology. A similar investment in nuclear would not move the needle at all.
- ncmncm 6y agoLocal ammonia production is the best use for power from wind turbines that are distant from grid access. It is directly usable as both fertilizer and fuel, on the spot, for farms, and marketable to neighbors without turbines. Demand exactly matches supply.
- throw0101a 6y ago> So what you do is overprovision your renewables. In other words, build more than you need. The major reason to do this is so that when the wind is barely blowing and/or it's a cloudy day you still get enough power to supply your needs without peakers. When there is zero wind and zero sun then it doesn't matter how much over provisioning there is: your output will be zero. I live in Ontario, Canada, where we do have wind and (some) solar in our energy mixture. Wind can go from 100 to 2900 MW, and solar from 0 to 350 MW. Looking at the Supply tab (18-24 Oct), on Tues, Oct 20, at 05:00 we had 173MW of wind and zero solar (sunrise@07:48): * http://www.ieso.ca/power-data http://www.ieso.ca/power-data The amount that we would have had to to "overprovision" to get useful renewables would have been ridiculous. Luckily our 9,500MW of nuclear just chugs along filling our base load with >4,000MW total available hydro helping, as well as some gas peakers. If we built another 3000MW of nuclear then we could handle our base load with that, and hydro would be used for the variable portion of demand. As someone who lives <50km from a nuclear power plant [0] bring in more. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pickering_Nuclear_Generating_Station https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pickering_Nuclear_Generating_S...
- ncmncm 6y agoEnergy storage is cheap. Underground air pressure, mine-shaft gravitational, hydro-dam gravitational, molten salt, LH2, they all work.
- bobthepanda 6y agoAt least in the US this was supposed to be solved by interconnecting the three major grids, since it's highly unlikely that there would be zero wind and solar across the entire continental US all at once. How connected are grids in Canada?
- throw0101a 6y agoCanada is connected inside itself and to the US: * https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/North_American_power_transmission_grid https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/North_American_power_transmiss... Ontario specifically is part of the NPCC: * https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Northeast_Power_Coordinating_Council https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Northeast_Power_Coordinating_C... It connects to Michigan, NY in two places, and Quebec in a few.