3 ms·
I'd expect the opposite: The more we build the better, cheaper and safer they become. That's what happened with cars and airplanes for example. I'm not aware o
by BurningFrog 6y ago
I'd expect the opposite: The more we build the better, cheaper and safer they become.
That's what happened with cars and airplanes for example. I'm not aware of counterexamples.
- danielheath 6y agoThey didn’t build all the cars they would need concurrently; they mostly finished a small number at a time. That let them learn along the way, but there isn’t time to do that for nuclear because we need hundreds or thousands of plants and they each take years to build.
- rbanffy 6y agoIt doesn't take 20 years, billions of dollars, and thousands of specialized workers to build each car.
- bryanlarsen 6y agoCounterexample: Large infrastructure projects that take >10 years to build. Big Dig, trains, et cetera. They take so long to build that people only work on a very small number during their career so the ability to learn lessons from one to apply to another is small. Nuclear plants are in this category.
- apendleton 6y agoThey're only in this category specifically because each one is a bespoke custom project. That's not a compelling argument against standardization and mass factory production.
- bryanlarsen 6y agoEven the NuScale SMR reactors only produce the core in a factory setting. They still need a large bespoke building and containment vessel.
- waterhouse 6y agoIf you work on years 1-2 of Project 1, shouldn't that put you in a good position to work on years 1-2 of Project 2? You might not see the effects of bad decisions that start mattering in year 6, but it seems there should be lots of workers for whom that doesn't matter, and for the rest, it seems like having some people do close inspections and produce good reports (which others read when they're on Project 3+) might mostly cover that. Seems like this should be mostly solvable...
- BurningFrog 6y agoChina has learned to build those projects in 6-12 months.
- epistasis 6y agoEven China has huge problems with nuclear. When they took the French EPR design, they thought each would take less than 4 years to build. Ended up taking 9 years. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/EPR_(nuclear_reactor)#Taishan_1_and_2_(China) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/EPR_(nuclear_reactor)#Taishan_... Western countries aim for a decade of construction, but will probably take 2x as long as the initial schedule.
- pfdietz 6y agoNuclear is itself a counterexample. It didn't get cheaper as we built more.
- BurningFrog 6y agoMy take is we never built a lot. The industry died from bad PR before it got to mature much.
- pfdietz 6y agoIt was grossly overhyped by a government trying to make trillions (current dollars) spent on nuclear weaponry not seem such an egregious drain on humanity. That it would crash back to Earth as the hype and groupthink met reality was inevitable.
- cm2187 6y agoThat’s not my understanding. That’s precisely the benefit France enjoyed when it decided to scale up its nuclear power. Right now very few new reactors are built so the benefit and the expertise are gone. But if a country decides to scale up rapidly in the same way you should see that benefit.
- pfdietz 6y agoFrance didn't see good learning effects either.