3 ms·
> It's outrageous indeed that GH/MS is complying. Not really. They're legally required to do so. The DMCA notice (despite what someone suggests downthread) i
by kelnos 6y ago
> It's outrageous indeed that GH/MS is complying.
Not really. They're legally required to do so. The DMCA notice (despite what someone suggests downthread) is unfortunately quite properly served. Even if it is flat-out wrong, GH/MS has no reason (and likely no resources) to investigate whether or not that's the case. And if they did, and got it wrong, they'd lose their safe harbor status and be liable for damages.
If the youtube-dl author believes it to be bullshit, they can send a counter-notice, and GH/MS will then put it back up. If the RIAA still has a bone to pick, they can file a lawsuit. Unfortunately, they very well may.
> It's not that far from targeting wget or curl, were it not for the widespread use of them in industry.
I get really confused when I hear things like this, because this makes no sense. Targeting a program called "YouTube Download", which has the main purpose of downloading clean copies of YT videos, against the wishes of the content creators is absolutely not the same thing as targeting a generic HTTP/FTP download tool.
I think the DMCA is garbage, but it feels like willful ignorance to be at all surprised about things like this, and to compare this to something obviously non-infringing.
- progman32 6y ago> which has the main purpose of downloading clean copies of YT videos Among many other sites and services. > against the wishes of the content creators I'm a content creator on YouTube and I'd be honored if anyone chooses to save my videos on disk. The tool has its legitimate uses and abuses.