8 ms·
Curious if anyone with legal expertise knows if this has legs? They say: > The clear purpose of this source code is to (i) circumvent the technological protect
by crazygringo 6y ago
Curious if anyone with legal expertise knows if this has legs? They say:
> The clear purpose of this source code is to (i) circumvent the technological protection measures used by authorized streaming services such as YouTube, and (ii) reproduce and distribute music videos and sound recordings owned by our member companies without authorization for such use.
But the "circumventing" is still accessing a stream the user can view anyways, and the "reproduce and distribute" feels like a stretch -- there's no inherent distribution. This isn't anything like a pirating or a torrenting tool.
It feels more akin to when movie studios sued VCR manufacturers for being able to record TV back in 1984 -- and lost [1].
(Also, side note but I have never in my life seen a story upvoted so quickly on HN. 130 points in just 7 minutes so far.)
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sony_Corp._of_America_v._Universal_City_Studios,_Inc https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sony_Corp._of_America_v._Unive....
- fiddlerwoaroof 6y agoThe entire IP concept is really hard to make sense of with the web: a browser works by making a local copy of a remote resource and then making that local copy available to the user. I don’t see why, from the server’s perspective, the precise client matters: if I use curl + pandoc to read your webpage, is that really meaningfully different from using Firefox or Chrome?
- superkuh 6y ago> is that really meaningfully different from using Firefox or Chrome? In the USA legally it is because the vast majority of the judges that have ruled on these things think anything that isn't a browser is a hacking tool. Using wget is enough to get you thrown in federal prison for accessing public web resources.
- ReaLNero 6y ago> Using wget is enough to get you thrown in federal prison for accessing public web resources. Example?
- aspenmayer 6y agoAaron Swartz remains a prominent example. RIP https://www.newyorker.com/tech/annals-of-technology/when-programmers-scrape-by https://www.newyorker.com/tech/annals-of-technology/when-pro... His JSTOR code (below) calls wget: https://osf.io/bnd2h https://osf.io/bnd2h
- moonchild 6y agoSo, had he opened a browser and used the javascript console to download everything instead, he would have gotten off scot free?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- _jjkk 6y agoWhat's a javascript console? Sounds like a hacker tool, off to prison with him.
- wafflesraccoon 6y agoNitpick, on page three of the document you posted it states that his script used curl and not wget
- aspenmayer 6y agoI was interpolating, the article implies wget but I didn’t mean to imply I had verified that or anything. I’ll admit I did make a stronger statement than intended and was relying on third party interpretations of the code. Thanks for the clarification! I think weev may have used wget in his AT&T work where he discovered links or interactions between customer data and iOS in an AT&T subsite? http://madisonian.net/2013/04/09/academics-go-to-jail-cfaa-edition/ http://madisonian.net/2013/04/09/academics-go-to-jail-cfaa-e...
- nsgi 6y agoWere those public resources, though?
- jagged-chisel 6y agoI feel like if they'd been more patient, they might have addressed the similarity to the "analog hole."
- adrianmonk 6y agoAlso, does the fact that YouTube doesn't supply a download feature constitute a "technical protection measure"? From the RIAA's point of view, it works to their benefit that a download link doesn't exist, and it may be something they like, but that doesn't mean that's why. It could just as easily be that a download feature doesn't exist because YouTube wants you to keep returning to their site if you want to rewatch a video. It would be one thing if some YouTube videos had a download button and others didn't. That would suggest that, on the ones where it's missing, it is missing for a reason, and that reason might be DRM. But as far as I know, YouTube doesn't have download for any videos. Software doesn't always have all the features that end users might want, and the mere absence of a feature doesn't necessarily tell you why it's missing. Also, it's not some weird, suspicious thing to write software which fills in a feature gap in some other software. (Google encourages add-on software on other products, too. For example, Chrome extensions and Gmail add-ons.) But, maybe there is some legal reason why this could make sense. Maybe some terms of service or licensing (for video uploaders or for regular end users) says not to download something, which would make it clear that the download feature is missing on purpose.
- mig39 6y agoYoutube does have a "download" feature in YouTube studio. Where you can download a heavily compressed version of any video you've uploaded. But only videos you've uploaded.
- vongomben 6y agoIANAL IANAT yet the video I am watching isn't being stored in my browser?
- adrianmonk 6y agoThe data obviously must make it to your computer. A distinction that can be made is whether it is possible/easy to use it separately, outside of YouTube.
- 6y ago
- ikeboy 6y agoI'm NAL, but familiar with IP law. My analysis is at https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24874277 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24874277 and I'm broadly skeptical of the legal viability under US law.
- mr_toad 6y ago> a stream the user can view anyways The true purpose of the DCMA is to control the distributors via the use of tools like DRM. The fact that you can view music on YouTube at all is something of an anomaly. The recording industry would love to dispense with YouTube entirely if they could.